Reviews of Scordato Bakery Inc. (Bakery) in Milwaukee (Wisconsin).

Scordato Bakery Inc

297 Reviews

196 Comments

Bakery

Bakery

5011 W Howard Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53220, United States

Description

Information of Scordato Bakery Inc, Bakery in Milwaukee (Wisconsin)

Discover the opening times, the location, contact, popular times, photos and real reviews by internet users.

This place has a very good rate, they treat their customers well and you’ll feel welcome, super recommended

Map

Open hours of Scordato Bakery Inc

Popular times

Monday

Tuesday

Wednesday

Thursday

Friday

Saturday

Reviews of Scordato Bakery Inc

Meghan Ann

When I don't feel like slaving away and making my own Italian cookies or cannoli, Scordato Bakery for the win! Today I FINALLY was able to try the sfinciuni (Sicilian pizza) I have heard everyone rave about. It is always gone the other times I have visited. Oh how I have been missing out. The crust is thick and crunchy in some spots. The tomato sauce is not overbearing and is very flavorful. It isn't greasy like your typical pizza either. I had the perfect breakfast today. The sfinciuni and a cannoli. If you have never been to this gem of a bakery, you are really missing out!

Jodi Kresa

I love coming to Scordato's! Hot ham and rolls on Sunday are my favorite. The bakery is always busy but well staffed with courteous and pleasant workers. Keep up the good work!

Heather Hantz

I just got married on the 24th of September and ordered our cake from Scordato's. All I can say is absolutely beautiful and delicious. Antonella was such a sweet woman to work with as well as the staff. I would definitely suggest using this bakery..and I would again!

sharon rafalski

Never got disappointed with anything I got from there.. when they first opened and I can't remember how many years ago I didn't think they would make it because it was small.. but now I was there at 7:00 a.m. on Sunday and the store was packed

Gina D

This is a place we have driven by many times and just didn't see it. But after stopping at this little strip mall, we finally saw it! We had to go in. Its small, but has a big selection. Great customer service, the young lady who helped us was very patient with us, offered suggestions and answered all our questions. By far my fav was the cream horn, my son lived the chocolate filled crescent and hubby loved the eclair. The lasagna was yummy, but pricy. The garlic bread was like giant croutons, little to hard for me personally. It's our new special treat spot.

Emily Reding

This review comes from Ms. Widen's 1st grade class at Glenwood Elementary School: Our whole class went to a bakery called Scordato Bakery. In our opinion, everyone should try Scordato's. One reason we recommend Scordato's is because they were super kind and helpful, and the service was fast. The second reason is the prices were affordable. We were able to get cookies for our whole class and some adults in our school for a low price. A third reason we recommend Scordato's is that even though the shop is small, it fit all of us inside. The shop was clean and organized. Another thing we really liked was the variety of cookies. There were so many treats to choose from. With so much variety, it was hard to choose just one! Most importantly, the food is delicious. Here are some quotes from the first grade shoppers: "My favorite was the lemon. It was so good and a little sour." "I loved my sugar cookie with sugar on the bottom." "My cookie had walnuts in it and it was really good." "The inside of my cookie was really good and the outside was dipped in white chocolate." "I recommend the orange cookie." "My cookie had two flavors and I liked both parts." As you can see, Scordato's is a great bakery for a lot of reasons. If you have never tried it, we recommend that you visit soon.

Liz Sanders

Found this place accidentally while looking for a gas station. This is hands down the best arancini I’ve had in Milwaukee. The eclair was also amazing. It is pretty far from my house…I’m going back anyway. :)

Pauline Bilot

Great cookies and eclairs. Delicious Italian sausage and breads as well as Arancinni

Landon Nyren

Amazing cannoli, made fresh if you request it. My grandmother also raced about the green olive salad. Brought her back to her childhood in Chicago. Cookies were spot on and very reasonably priced. Open Sunday mornings for ham and rolls. Highly recommend.

Tim F

Small bakery big flavor. I love the hot ham and rolls on Sunday. The seeded rolls totally make it for me. They are amazing! I'm not big into sweets but they are slowly changing my mind. Everything sweet I've tried was delicious. They also make their own Italian sausage. Do yourself a favor and try them out. The staff there also makes this place efficient but warm, and inviting. I want to keep going back to try somthing new. So far I have a thumbs up on everything.

Jerry Martocci

Here's the old fashioned neighborhood bakery I've been searching for. Mainly breads and Italian cookies. Some desserts. No danish. I bought some Italian bread and two desserts. All tasted terrific.

Joyce Britt

Today was my first visit to Scordato's Bakery. OMG! What a fabulous place. Everyone was so friendly. Everything looks so delicious. I can't wait to try my goodies that I purchased. I highly recommend going there. Can't wait to go back.

Peter Gargano

Best cannolis! Antonella made us a beautiful and delicious wedding cake that was absolutely amazing.

Jon Young (Highlander)

Great bakery and deli! Wonderful employees! The Christmas cookie selection is awesome!

Neil Aggen

Delicious Italian bread & rolls. Every other Saturday they serve a very tasty Italian with peppers & onions on a fresh roll. Makes a great lunch. On the other alternate Saturday they have homemade lasagna with a slice of garlic bread. Nummy!!!

Karen Reske

Love the ham cookies and desserts. Nice small place

Chris Larson

A great Italian bakery with a great selection of cookies, breads, and desserts. Staff was excellent, providing quick service where everyone was helpful. Cookies by the pound makes for a great deal too.

Luis Daleccio

The cookies are to die for fresh and tasty. The ham and rolls are a Sunday thing for me I honestly eat that all day.

Robbie Bong

Excellent bakery! Great turnovers and chocolate eclairs. Their bread & rolls are so good, too. Beautiful, delicious Italian cookies. Great service! Try it & you'll be a lifetime customer!

Jennifer Roberts

Great locally owned family bakery. Quality tasty treats! The cookie assortment is amazing. We need to support these small bakeries, they are few & far between. This bakery is a hidden gem!

Gina Guzlecki

Amazing selection of Italian cookies. Great pizza dough & deli. Staff is very helpful and prices are amazing. Would be great if the offered espresso, Gelato or Italian sodas TO GO.

Katherine

Cute down home authentic Italian bakery.

Bob L

Such a nice place, friendly staff, even when they're busy. Beautiful homemade bakery, all kinds of delicious offerings. I love these non-chain stores. You get so much more than big grocery stores can offer, in terms of quality and hard to find unique items.

Christina Reddy

Love this place. I always go there for Christmas cookies and bread. Great cannoli, sometimes muffins. So delighted to have them on the south side of Milwaukee.

Mary Spadafora

Very authentic Italian bakery with more than just bakery. Free rolls with the purchase of a pound of ham. Incredible assortment of cookies and pastries. I came for cannoli's and they made them fresh while I waited. They were absolutely delicious.staff was friendly. Bakery clean. I will certainly go again.

Teresa Rechlicz

Lovely welcoming staff, terrific hot ham and rolls, and the cookies are absolutely out of this world. They offer a great variety of baked goods, deli items, cakes and more. Will absolutely return often.

Cindi Dickens

I cannot tell you how fabulous this bakery is!! We ordered Italian cookies for our wedding and had them shipped to NC. They were the absolute BEST, most delicious, fresh, authentic Italian cookies I have ever had. They all tasted so fantastic and delicious! The customer service couldn't be better. So sweet and accommodating. Extremely pleasurable to work with. I called after the wedding to get a copy of my order because I plan on ordering these same cookies for all my future events, holidays, or just cravings. I can't even tell you in words how delicious they all were. Once you taste them, you will be hooked. We even fought over who got to take the few that were left on the plate after the wedding. What can I say, we're Italian.

Erika robinson

If you haven't had the pleasure of trying this place youre missing out! Everything looked fresh, made that day. Bought a fresh soft baguette, and some Sicilian pizza. SO GOOD!!The prices can't be beat either. Stop in and support your local small business 😊 …

Robert M

This place is simply amazing. Excellent cookies--the amaretti are flavorful and chewy, the cuccidati burst with intensity. The Sicilian pizza is a favorite--doughy and chewy crust with a bit of pull around the edges. Lots of other great goods for sale here. They have a very safe and efficient customer service process during the Covid-19 era.

G D

I’ve been going here around 20 years. I moved pretty far away but still swing by when I’m in the area. The quality has always stayed amazing, staff have always been awesome too. This is the only place where I get cannoli. I hope they stay in business forever

Diane Kelly

This is the same Italian breads, cookies and sfinjuni (Sicilian pizza) that I grew up with. It is so good! Like eating my mom and aunties cooking all over again.

Dean Milinski

So completely friendly, helpful, and patient. The visit to explore Scordato Bakery's offerings. Today we chose 1 lb of Italian cookies, S pastries, mini cream puffs, and a canolli. All these have been highly enjoyed, and we'll worth the expense. Candidly, the cost matched the quality offered.

Betty “Booper” Engibous

Wow! YUM! What an assortment of cookies, bread etc. Staff is awesome. I love this place. Visit, you won't be disappointed.

Lucy Hilgendorf

Visited this bakery for the first time today and when I left I smiled and said jackpot! What a delightful and delicious family bakery. Being I was a first time customer I was treated to several samples of their sweet treats. It would be hard to choose if i could only pick one. They have dozens of cookies I've never seen before. Also got some historical background. How I never knew about Scordato's before is beyond me however I am so happy I know now. If you appreciate made from scratch, with limited ingredients and no preservatives breads and sweet treats; if you appreciate being treated as a special guest, then this bakery is a must. They also have olive salads, Italian sausages, pizza crust with herbs, cheeses, ham and rolls, some gluten free sweets, etc.

Jamie M

One of the few excellent, remaining traditional family Italian bakeries.

Arin G

I have so much yet to try, but everything I’ve had is delicious. I love the sfinciuni, tutu’s, tiramisu. Moist, and great flavor. My mom loves the olives, and for a great price. I used to go to Scortino’s, but I found Scordato’s- much closer to home, and better in my opinion. The staff is friendly and helpful. It’s a gem.

Glen Davis

They're hot ham and roll is phenomenal to one thing I like about it is cuz it's a mom and pop shop the bakery is delicious a must stop if you're in the neighborhood

Jennifer Cone

I always enjoy coming to get ham and rolls here. It's delicious and the staff are awesome. Some desserts are a little pricier then I'd like but it's still worth going to. Thank you for being awesome.

Matthew H

Great canolis my gram hasn't had one in 10 years. She was so happy for her birthday. Last min. Day of they made fresh ones for us. Clean and takes cleanliness seriously as we all should. Thank you

Craig Burbey

Absolutely wonderful Italian cookies. I judge an Italian bakery by their ameretti and they were spot on with texture and flavor. The french bread was also great. They have specials during the week that I will definitely be trying.

Alyssa Holley

Was a little unusual set up but had nice friendly people. My coworkers and myself enjoyed the donuts they had from there. Next time I might try their ham special on Sunday.

charles fontanazza

Best Italian bakery in Milwaukee. Moved to godawful florida 6 years ago, and really miss their crispy breads rolls, & cannoli. Even their cookies are good; each cookie tastes differently, not like the flat tasting cookies at Sciortino's. We grew up on Sciortino bread, but after the old man sold it, it was never the same; Peter should have taught them how to bake. Fortunately he did teach Scordato, who now has the best bread in town. I always stop when in town, and ocassionally have my sister send a few loaves.

Deanna Mejchar

Love the bread! Simple Ingredients and hard working family. The lemon cello is outstanding! Such a tiny place with so many delicious choices❣️

MikƏ OŇƏ

My favorite bakery. Love the bread, great customer service and clean. Thankyou all for what you do.

Marisa B.

My family have been customers for a long time. They always do an excellent job on our custom ordered cakes! Worth every penny! I highly recommend Scordato Bakery!

Google User

Great place and I am so glad I visited, it was the first time for my dad and I. The people working there are wonderful. The product there is very good, we had bread, cookies, and potato salad. It was all good! Their is a lot of other stuff I want to try yet.

Jozeffa Jimenez

Best EVER...Tiny place with HUMONGOUS COOKIE VARIETY. Bread & rolls phenomenal. STAFF is WONDERFUL..They have the BEST OLIVE SALAD I have ever eaten in my life! On Saturdays they rotate between lasagne & Italian sausages..if you have not had either of these, you have no idea what you are missing out on...try their rice balls..YUM YUM YUM...Give Scordatos a try...you will NOT regret it.

Z Zylka

Best ham n rolls !! Grandma Potato Salad is great and canolis n tiramisu rock.

Barbarajean Tarantino

By far the best shaved ham in Milwaukee! Service is always great. I always call ahead so my order is ready when I get there.

Janise Janikowski

My favorite Italian bakery! The customer service is top notch and nobody has better rolls than here! Don't go home without some cookies either... you will be glad you did.

Stephanie Post

We love the ham and cookies! The kids talk about how delicious the cookies are. Thank you.

alice grenfell

Bread & rolls excellent. Service great. They have a system to separate customers 6 feet apart. Rest of salads & sweets all home made.

Gary Turznik

Great place for eclairs and delicious salads and ham. If you see Milwaukee Fire Firefighters stop and pick up some stuff you know that it's a awesome bakery to go to.

Amber Unger

A colleague of mine recently told me about Scordato's and I have already been there twice now. We have tried their donuts and desserts. Everything has been yummy!

Manuela Manke

Ham & rolls the best. Salads & bakery top notch. Will return.

Monica Shreeves

I bought I full tiramisu and an array of cookies for a welcome to the family. Everyone raved about it and my Aunt about cried thanking me for giving her a slice of home. Thank you Scardato Bakery for making this possible!

Debbie Obrien

Great find. Breads and cookies are outstanding. Staff lovely.

gat 2asp

Excellent bread. There Italian sausage is vary good. Great sweets too.

Christine Cavallaro

Fantastic Italian breads, rolls, salads and treats. Wonderful owners! I always get my Italian Christmas cookies here too.

Mary Jo Heiser

Excellent plus, only bought bakery which was so yummy & filling I skipped supper! Hugh Eclairs!!!

Christine Renock

The best tasting bread/rolls. Cookies are beautiful. Service is great! Ham & rolls....YUM

Sharon Ward

great local Italian bakery! Hit ham & rolls on Sunday!

Cassandra Walker

Love there cookies and bread. Great value for the quality and quantity.

Nino Piller

Best Italian bread in town, worth the drive, and staff was very friendly, will definitely go back there again and again

Wendy Sobczyk

Great. Better prices on hot ham than Canfora plus six rolls for every pound. No limit. Bew Sunday go to

Janet Van Brunt

Love their bakery !! Want to come back for their hot sandwich special..yummy ❤

Tim S.

This is a great little family owned bakery /Deli. The food is always fresh and of good quality. We are never disappointed when we go there.

Stephanie Suchecki

Their Italian cookies are AMAZING and addicting—especially the night and day ones! 🤩 …

Jorge Moran

Very delicious bread and the cookies outstanding !! The environment really nice and service first class !! It is a family business with a really big heart.

Vincent Tripoli

Love coming here for Italian cookies and pastries. And they're always very friendly and helpful, and you'll definitely who love the food.

Cheryl Sanders

Smells fantastic....Great customer service? I got hot ham and rolls. 2 jelly filled doughnuts, a chocolate eclair and a chocolate horn.

Anna P

My favorite bread! Everything is delicious. Service is always on point.

Carol Murawski

One my favorite bakeries to hit when I come up from Texas. Bread, bakery, deli and hot foods to take home for dinner are incredible!

Andy Saputo

Great Sicilian bakery with fair prices and friendly staff.

Aaron Hand

My family and I love this bakery. It has great Italian pastries and other deli items.

Scott Mohr

Great little place. Excellent Christmas cookies. Got some antipasto too.

Susie Sell

Best bakery in the state. Very friendly people. Good variety.

Blake G

They made a delicious cake for a special occasion. We’ll be ordering from here again!

Michael Meeker

Some.of the best bakery I've ever had. nice workers and their Sunday Ham and rolls are good too

chris zylka

Best ham n rolls on Sunday, lasagna is great on Saturday n have excellent canolli's n tiramisu

John Townsend

My amaretti were day old, but the lemoncello cake was tasty.

William Bono

One of the best bakery's around. Best rice balls in town. Staff is always very helpful and pleasent.

Vincenzo L.

All of the food and Cookies are great, and the people there are nice, especially Antonella

Jeanne Frittitta

The Italian bread, cookies, delicious deli foods and other bake goods are exceptional.

Rayyan Talha

Cheesecake b hittin different. The carrot cake is otherworldly

Brian stipitch

Absolutely wonderful pastries and cookies. Cornettis are the best if you can get some early in the morning

Helen Guglielmi

Delicious bakery. The best breads and rolls. Friendly staff. Love it!!!

Angela Anderson

Great cookies! These are definitely in my top two Italian bakeries.

amanda jobs

Excellent cannoli and cassitini. Love the mini eclairs. The old man still works there, and really gives off a family vibe.

Gabriel Wright

I love their green pastry and cookies and their Greek pastas worth another visit

Adele Rauen

Some of the best delicious fresh donuts soft bigger than usual more delicious than usual

Roxanne Denomie

Fantastic variety of cookies. One of the more reasonabl places for pricing.

Heidi Mitchell

Great selection of cookies and Italian specialties! Friendly and helpful service.

Sarah McIntosh

Great assortment of cakes and cookies! The calzones and potato salad are also fantastic!

Meagon Ortiz

I was treated like family by the nice lady working. She was kind enough to give my son a cookie and ALL the food was amazing!!!

nikorr1

Excellent bakery items, Italian food and hot ham and rolls 😋 …

Al Hovey

It was great as usual. A great picture of the owner now in place above the bread. He will be missed.

Christy Beane

Amazing! Garlic toast, lasagna, etc. Macaroons are the best I've EVER had.

Wendy Young

Small local Italian bakery...great products...bought assorted cookies and cannoli...excellent

Gergg Bergr

Great food lasagna is incredible and Very helpful employees, and don't forget the fresh rolls.

alan wagner

Hot ham and rolls and turnovers.. so good

Dawn Nowak

Awesome bakery and delicious deli items. Always fresh.

Andrea Lambert

Great place for ham and rolls and bakery

Eva Endlich

I love their cookies and they have the best Tiramisu in town.

Jessica S

First time here, would highly recommend and prices were great for the quality of food and products.

Cicca

Better than canfora, now called lakeside. Lower prices better quality and nicer people.

Neil Aggen

Great family owned and operated Italian bakery. Great job Scordato family!!!

Allen Murphy

Good Italian bakery is to die for, and Scordato's is beyond good, and then some!

Todd Borts

Best rolls on west side of Milw County.

James Ouimet

Very good eats.high quality.yum very good 👍 …

John Jelacic

Good hot ham and rolls and Italian bread Sundays three different kinds of hot turnovers

Chris Kissinger

Excellent selection, fantastic service in a small business that will take you back to fondest childhood memories.

Keith Werner

Great bakery and hot Ham and rolls.

Jennifer Johanson

The lasagna, available every second Saturday, is excellent, as are the almond cookies.

jose Balistreri

Great hospitality. Fast service. And I mean who doesnt like fresh food.

Jose Parra

Great hot ham and bakery. Service is excellent

Lillian Laird

Bakery, cookies, sandwiches are very good! Very good variety of cookies!

Roger Stoltz

Great Staff! Great treats as well!

tonya pomietlo

This is such a neighbor hood gem. Delicious everything.

Matrix Truther

5 stare go there. Sunday ham n rolls too

Olas

What a great shop! Best Italian cookies in Milwaukee.

Bob Tolfa

Best Italian bread that you'll find in southeastern Wisconsin

Jenni OMalley

Great ham and potato salad! And great customer service!

Roxanne Maier

Super friendly delicious food great prices

Novak Novakovic

We are buying there for years. Nice store, nice people, high quality products.

Pam Frinzi

I was brought back to wonderful childhood memories, THE BEST OLD FASHIONED TRUE BAKERY!

Kevin Kelsay

Eclairs. Italian bread. Ham N rolls. Yum

Josie Carini

Best bread without preservatives... service is friendly

M P

Excellent Italian Cookies, pastry, breads and much more.

Ce Ce

Excellent Italian Bakery. Great cookies!

Kenneth Sidello

Wonderful food, excellent service! Will always go for more

giavanna kurtagic

I LOVE the cannolis here! They are my fav!

Nancy Wieland

Best Sunday hot ham and rolls in the city!

Dan Braun

Great food and service, I love it there

Jen and Damian Hilgendorf

Best italian bakery in town.

Andrew Malone

great bakery, excellent deli. hidden jem

Deann Thiede

First time customer. Customer service and food is excellent!

Karla Hackbarth

Excellent place to get good rolls or good cookies

Maria Dentici

The best place to go! Great people and bakery!!!!

Linley “Lin” Hibbard

Great place for turnovers ! I love them !

Kristin N

Fresh filled cannolis and all kinds of delicious goodies

Basil Sadowski

Experience authentic Italian pastries awesome place

Ann Vollmer-Goralski

Great bakery and helpful nice people

Chris Bailey

Very good bakery, and it is very inexpensive.

Andre Navarre

Breads cookies all delicious

Tim Zak

Great breads. Decent prices.

Cesar Rodriguez

Fresh baked, need I say more... oh yeah canolis!

Paul

Fine for a small bakery.

Richard G.

Great fresh rolls. Hardworking employees.

Jeanne Bell

Awesome ham and rolls on Sunday.

Sylvia Campos

Great bakery and staff.

anita Nowicki

Best hot ham and rolls

Sandra Hanisko

Friendly staff and great great food

Christina Witmer

Delish cookies, great service

Mr Bear

Fantastic Italian bakery

juli Stojsavljevic

Great food and service!

Luz Hernandez

Best Bakery ever

LexyLex

Love the fresh baked goods

Rudy Pugel

Nice buns!

Jeff Kacheris

Fantastic! Will definitely be back!

MaryBeth Cottrill

Great staff and great selection.

Carol Maestas

Very good

Bryan Wezyk

Nice place old fashion

Derrell Blada

JUST THAT THE ROLLS ARE GETTING SMALLER , AND THE PRICE LARGER...

Steven Feltes

Our favorite bakery

Norman Behrendt

Best cannolis in town.

C Faust

Great cakes and bakery.

Julie Klosiewski

The best rolls!

Aliye Berzati

good service and great people

John Spirewka

Excellent hard rolls!

Joseph Cooper

Small home town feel

Karen T

Amazing breads and pastry

Nancy Krueger

Love this bakery!!

sin dee rella

Excellent

Matthew Pilarski

Fantastic Italian deli

Wade Pivett

Delicious

Joseph H. Seidita

Great

Dennis hohnsteim

Excellent backery

dan demeulenaere

Excellent

Mixxer 28 (Mixxer)

Best rolls

Dave & Pat Halter

Busy busy busy

Elizabeth R

Love this place

Donald Teal

Great service

Toni Seydel

Best cookies

Roxanne szolwinski

This place is fantastic!!!

Kathy Hernandez

Try everything.

Melissa DeFalco Menge

Excellent!

Andre Navarre

Love everything

Predrag Jevtic

excellent pastry

Sandra Rosas MK Consultora de Belleza.

(Translation) I loved the cookies. The service is excellent!!!! And the prices are affordable. (Original) Me encantaron las galletas. El servicio es excelente!!!! Y los precios son accesibles.

luis ojeda

(Translation) Excellent place. Very good breads (Original) Excelente lugar. Muy buenos panes

Christine Canino

(Translation) Best Centralization! (Original) Best Canoli!

Jerry Sidello

(Translation) Great Produv (Original) Great Produv

Andrew Fluckiger

Ante Pelicaric

kim

Contact

Photos