Reviews of Buffalo Exchange. (Thrift Store) in Newark (New Jersey).

Buffalo Exchange

251 Reviews

101 Comments

Thrift store

Used clothing store

332 E 11th St, New York, NY 10003, United States

Description

Information of Buffalo Exchange, Thrift store in Newark (New Jersey)

Discover the opening times, the location, contact, popular times, photos and real reviews by internet users.

This place has a very good rate, they treat their customers well and you’ll feel welcome, super recommended

Map

Open hours of Buffalo Exchange

Popular times

Sunday

Monday

Tuesday

Wednesday

Thursday

Friday

Saturday

Reviews of Buffalo Exchange

Michal A

An absolut must for thrift lovers. Every time I'm in NYC I find amazing things there. Prices are higher than salvation army kind of stores but lower than others second hand and consignment shops for sure. Amazing service every time and fun atmosphere.

Eden Bensadoun

Hannah was great, she was very helpful, and I was able to find a midi black polka dot dress !

Samuel S

Only went once a couple years ago but got a really cool pair of sweatpants and a Misfits t shirt that I still wear. Was with a friend and they tried to give in their clothes but the person observing the clothes was very picky about what the store can take. If you are looking to buy cool/trendy/vintage clothes and you are in the LES area, I definitely recommend going to Buffalo Exchange, but better to just give your old clothes to goodwill and get a tax write off.

Edward Mistretta

Great selection of pants and vintage Tees. Nice staff

Oriana G

One of my favorite go-to thrift shops! Nice selection of clothing. Very hip and trendy stuff. The price range is pretty decent and mostly cheap. The employees were super friendly and nice. The place is quite small so it can get kinda crowded. Also, bring your own bags!!

Alyssa Slotnick

I come here all the time and find lots of gems! The prices are very reasonable for the quality clothes and accessories. Selling is easy and I usually take the store credit because I always find something to buy! The staff is also super friendly and helpful.

Gabriel

I went here 2 days ago. Honestly, it was a great experience and I bought one item that's pretty unique and the rest were a jean jacket and a track suit. The staff were chill and nice and a very welcoming environment. The only problem I have is that there should be more selection for Mens and also the prices we're a little too expensive.

Alana Zaic

I. Love. This. Place. :D <3 <3 <3 It's a like a bottle of happy exploded in one store. If you're willing to put in the time and effort, the selection is actually REALLY GOOD, the buyers are absolute, complete dolls who actually have a good eye for style, and the manager is...well, I just love him. I sell clothes here with some frequency and I have found the pricing to be a liiiiiittle low, but that's because their price point is lower for the customer as well. So. I don't mind getting a little less because I know that savvy thrift shoppers like myself will be getting a good deal on great merchandise. One thing I can't stress enough is that the, er, high handed attitudes that I have experienced at similar places (cough, Beacon's Closet), is NOT present here: the staff here is helpful, knowledgeable, upbeat, and just really, really fun. ;)

Sebastian Gold

Great clothes, but rude staff. My fried tried on a shirt he was about to buy over his t shirt to make sure it fit, and got yelled at for doing so. He almost didn't buy it as a result, but thankfully I convinced him otherwise. I get corona times but trying is no different from touching.

Zoë McGinnis

Great prices, exceptional service. I was helped by Foxy, who went above and beyond and found stuff that she thought was my style (she nailed it!) as she was putting it out on the racks. She was such a sweetheart and I ended up buying like half the stuff she suggested— give that girl a raise! My only qualm about this store was that they kept putting new stuff out so I kept having to go back and try more things on, haha.

Rudy Taveras

Great place to go buy some fashionable clothes. They are picky with the clothe that they buy from costumers but they always try their best to help you and make you feel comfortable. Met this kid/worker who was really kind. Great place to sell clothe. I will keep being a active buyer and seller. I really recommend this place and specially for the accessories and jackets.

J Au

3.5 star for okay service in consignment/ reselling clothes If you’re buying clothes from this place, this place’s got really good unique things, with Urban NYC styles. But if you’re reselling your clothes, remember to go to their website to read the instructions. 1. Go with a Take or No Take Mentality When you go there, don’t expect to sell everything for any $$$. I’ve read other comments about people trying to sell a bunch of clothes with the expectation of profiting off of every items they own, and went home with $0. The thing is, this place is a privately own retail store. Even though they take donations, retail stores rely on quality goods to sell. Unlike places like L Train Vintage (previously No Relation on 12th & 1st), they don’t just take anything you offer them. So, really, are you trying to clean out your closet? Or are you trying to make a profit? You really can’t expect too much from them. 2. Know what they sell, but they might not want it. Just because they sell one or two of what you own, doesn’t mean they want it. I had a faux fur coat and a genuine leather jacket to sell. They marked $30.5 for the coat and nothing for the jacket, even tho they were selling lots of both fur coats and leather jackets. The conditions were very good too. So, it depends on your buyer’s taste. Also, I brought in about 30-45 pieces of items and they took only 3-4, marked the price of $70~ and I got about $23.5~ back. Again, come in with a take or no take mentality. I just wanted to 3.You get 30% of their offer Say you take an item to them, and they don’t want it. They’d return it to you or they’d ask you to donate them. But if you present an item to them and they like it, they’ll mark a price, and give you 30% of that price in cash OR 50% of that price in store credit. 4. NEVER TAKE STORE CREDIT I’ve heard too many stories from this store that people loose their store credits after selling their clothes. So, when in doubt, ALWAYS TAKE THE CASH. 5. Bring your ID /PASSPORT. They need your ID/ passport to register your consignment. Not sure why, but perhaps because of reselling stolen items? 3.5 for resell. It’s okay.

Tessie Viola

Reality 3.5 Buying - I've been coming to this BE for almost a decade. A lot of my favourite pieces are from here, but so are a lot of things I've bought and regretted. (More of a reflection on me tbh.) Let's start with the good. It's relatively organized. Occasionally the racks are overstuffed, and shifty through everything is impossible. But maybe there isn't a lot of storage in the store. The place is small -- so if you're serious about shopping come prepared. Bring a small bag, light clothing, and hands that are readily movable. It's best to come on a weekday, Thursdays and Wednesdays have been the best for me. The middle of the day 3pm is fine almost every day. Keep in mind they don't give bags, so you can buy one or cram your purchases into your own bag. The people who work here are nice but aside from the freshies. Occasionally they get NYU freshman to work here and god they are always obnoxious and unhelpful. I get they're new employees but maybe the hiring process needs to be a bit better. The place, like I said is small but not crowded. The front of the store is male oriented, the back is female. The switch up the section occasionally. Currently the back left wall is shoes. They have a large selection of sizez 7 -8. If you're a size ten, they usually have like 4 shoes for us. It's really annoying. The plight of big feet women. The max items in the dressing room is ten, the rooms are clean and well lit. Selling - More of a hassle. Depending on the seller. If you're expecting top notch prices. Do not come here. Or come here when you see someone that's older than 19. My suggestion set a day where you do nothing but travel around and sell your stuff. Here's why, Selling is based on person and trends. Mostly person. There have been times where I have been rejected, come in the next day and they took the very same item. There have been days where I was rejected, went to the one in BK and was accepted. It's really a complete toss up. The NYU freshman employees are the worst buyers. Wait until you see an adult buyuer to get the best bang for your buck. All in all, Buffalo Exchange isn't a place I would TRAVEL TO per se, it's more "I'm got time to kill before drinks. Let me see what they have today." Walk in with zero expectations. Leave with maybe a quiet pleated skirt.

Molly Farrell-Savage

I've never had a bad experience at Buffalo. I've been to to one in Philly and this one by Union many times and have always enjoyed myself. The staff is extremely friendly. Whoever does the hiring, I applaud you! I usually come in with things to sell and they'll usually buy back one or two items, which is fine with me. Some people get so offended when Buffalo doesn't want to buy their stuff, it's not that serious lol!

Danielle Kellier

This place is like everything trendy you find at a thrift store minus the musty old things too. And that's why the prices are much higher than a store like say Goodwill. But the items are quality. The staff are pretty friendly and helpful too! So if you want a trendy item but you don't have the time to comb through a thrift store, try this place!

Samantha Olivieri

thrifting is always an experience. you can walk out empty handed or with some nice finds. that's my experience with this location. i don't find as much great clothes as i find in the bk store, but it's still nice to look around. they are really picky about which donations they take in though. i come from the west side way uptown just to find out they're not taking a certain brand this week or this color isn't in for the month. i guess they have to be exclusive but i had great clothes,some even designer. i feel if they accepted more clothing, they would have more of a variety of people coming in and also make more sales. i do realize there are many clothes of the same style...

M K (Smuttynose)

Buffalo exchange on E11th was pleasant. Helpful and friendly staff, good music playing, overall a great time there. They give 30% cash of the resale value, and 50% of store credit. I found a great Levi Jean jacket for $24. Most things seem to cost about $20. It's a great deal!

Tom Lewkowitz

Great place to sell and buy some second hand clothing! Decided to raid out my closet and bring most of clothing here. They bought a good amount of polos and flannel. I was surprised that they did not take any of my nicer clothing. They explained they were looking for specific styles and fits. They really liked flannel judging from the clothing on the racks.

Nic Morgan

Like most buy-sell clothing shops in Manhattan, every visit is a hit or miss depending on their current inventory. The few times I've been in this place, it has seemed a little bit too picked over for my preference, and the racks weren't very full as well as a line about 3 people deep to sell your stuff. So, while I wouldn't necessarily choose this location to shop, because it seems like they're a busy branch it might be a great location to bring your stuff in to sell as it looks like the demand is much higher here than other locations. In general, still a good place to pop into on occasion to see what they've got in store!

Qingyi Yu

I would suggest bringing things under $100 there to consign only. Most of my stuff get a $30 ish tag price, which means I would get $10 in cash, including things that’s under $100 to things at $700. The buyer isn’t professional, and I can tell she is not familiar with many brands... so the price calculating system is not smart, and I feel like the most important factors for it is only the category, the material, condition (cleanliness). I got my $700 Coat back of course. Can you imagine selling it for $30 at such great condition???? But left several coats for $200-$300 there.... I guess friends you should check them out. Lol

Robert Maldonado

Great place to buy and sell clothes

Rafael Yau

Good thrift shop but not a big collection of men clothing mostly women clothing. The staffs are super friendly and nice. They buy your clothing 50% for trade in value and 30% for cash value to what they would sell the clothes for. Overall this place is ok.

Nilda Martinez

I always come here and they always take clean and fashionable item and pieces and I get good amount of store credit ! I love it here the staff is so cool and friendly and they have cute clothes just have to look carefully ! Other buffalo exchange don’t take much items but here they do just make sure it’s neat and clean and not dirty or stained

Harry Huang

Pricey for a thrift shop. I've picked up a few stand-out items before, but they have always cost me equal value. The quality tends to be higher than the nearby competition, but not enough to justify the price. I haven't tried trading my clothes in; although, I've heard the rates are unfavorable to the seller.

Anaisa Garcia (Nisa)

I took a bunch of clothes new , brand new shoes, and grate condition sneakers compare to the things that were in the store & used things and in great condition to me wasn't worth it for forty-two buy back dollars so I just donated the rest just not to carry it all back don't think I will consider doing this again :/

Angel R

I was so intimidated to go in because of some of the bad SELLING REVIEWS for this specific location but it was not bad AT ALL. There was a line to sell but they move pretty quick. Don't come with stuff "you would not wear yourself, I came with things I still liked but was ready to get rid of because I need any little space I can get in my crammed closet space and it was so worth it. The staff here is a little more down to earth and relatable than the other nyc locations maybe it's just the location.... but I felt really comfortable talking to the buyer and that's a big deal for an introvert. lol Good luck selling!

Michael Sparkuhl

Been there a couple of times. Always something new and interesting. Found a couple of men's good quality RL items (Purple Label !!) . Could not believe my eyes and the price was perfect; beat Madison Ave. The counter people are very helpful, always with a smile, especially that long blonde, fashionable looking gal, Ali. She's great.

Kristen Xie

Pretty cool vintage store. Just got a perfect pants. Love the recommendation from Hannah.

Jessi Schlewitt

Wide selection, from graphic tees to hawaiian shirts to crop tops. I’ve gone twice and found new things that I can wear as is or upcycle. Very excited to go back another time, too.

Brookie Rex

Pretty nice for a thrift shop. The staff is sweet and kind. Unfortunately, I couldn't find my size in mom jeans. Other than that, the close are extremely cheap and affordable.

Renaud Bourassa

Good selection and well organized, this is a great place to go thrift shopping and don't want to go through a ton of junk to occasionally find something good. The downside is that it tends to be more expensive than nearby thrift stores that do not curate their merchandise.

Iris

Good place to buy but not a great place to sell. Some items are sold for way more than they should be, for the brand and type of clothing. Underwhelming men’s section.

P. B. Khanimov

Affordable and good quality equals a great thrift store. But think twice before trying to exchange things, your just gonna waste your time b/c they hardly take anything and give the excuse that they have it already. Maybe just this location. There are others throughout the city!

James T

Nice place to pick out something you need to were with something else that inexpensive and has a variety of high end shoes and clothing . i like it cause you can go in with clothing you might not wear and exchange it for cash or trade for something else.

Michael Dollar

There is an eclectic array of clothing to choose from in addition to accessories, shoes, etc. Prices are very reasonable, and the staff is quite friendly.

Vicious C

Occasionally there's a good find but they're seriously lacking in fashionable plus-sized clothing... anything over a size 10 is as flattering as a moo-moo.

Gaby N

Out of all the Buffalo Exchange locations I like to sell here the most because the line is never crazy. They can be a bit pricey for used clothing but they have very nice pieces.

Amanda P

I used to stop by Buffalo Exchange all the time when I was in college because I lived on E 11th Street and it was on my way to class. They have a pretty good selection of clothing aimed at younger fashion.

lydia johnson

okay. I don't do the exchange thing, but sometimes you can find some funky stuff. It's not really for me as I"m a bit old for this type of shopping, but if you are a student on a budget, then go.

R. Mosley

Great selections for a wide variety of people. Great brand names and affordable prices and plenty of accessories. Staff is super friendly.

Morgan Mitkowski

Not true vintage clothing. Just recycled forever 21 garment and other stores like that. And honestly I think it’s more expensive then new clothes . I found one pair of shoes that’s it.

Sunee LaClaire

Every time I walk into a Buffalo Exchange, I find something to buy, It's a great collection or quality used items at decent prices. There's definitely something for everyone here.

Sarah Hudkins

Some great finds if you dig! Some things can be pricy and the selection is highly curated, but I bought a great blouse there for $15.

Dóra Horváth

This clothes store is just a piece of island where you can find a unique piece of item, clothes or accessories :) Everyone is in the store very helpful and kind.

Constance Li

Had a great find here! And Hannah was super helpful to us, def would recommend

Mica Sure

8/5. cool, considerate people work there! and they gifted me a lotta love! thanks truly! love and light :)

Jen Fraenkel

Decent selection and decent service. I'd go back and there are surely treasures to be found but I was underwhelmed overall

Andrew “Jamoozy” Sabisch

Smaller selection of clothes compared to their Brooklyn location. Ok quality, ok staff, ok in general.

Za Zou

Just love this place The staff is amazing and they have second hand items coming on a daily basis :)

Riley Berger

Not a great selection, they don't buy brand new, in-style clothing, and it's really cramped.

Ermen Berrios

I don't get why people get mad when they don't get a lot for their trade ins, it's a Thrift Store. Try selling them on Craigslist first and leave this as a last option....Js

Maëlle Rigaud

Really good I loved it ! Original clothing on good shape and not expensive

James Talbot

Really cool clothes for dirt cheap. You can find some real gems if you're dedicated.

victoria fallon

Stopped in with four teenagers and everyone walked out with a bag ... including me! Perfectly priced.

P.P. B

Over priced second hand "vintage" but not vintage... long waits to sell your goods and very picky and what they take...

James Coleman

It was a good experience, you can buy and sell clothes there.

GoldFinger TC

Love this place for all the cool stuff they got and all the clothes I sell there

Andy Zou

Come here all the time to update the old wardrobe. Good for finding pricier brands used

Ian Jones

There are good picks here you just have to look and stop by frequently. Perfect for the 16-30something crowd.

Cortney Buczkowski

Really really REALLY great finds.. the best Buffalo Exchange i've been to yet!

M Pierce

Great staff, wonderful selection. Just mind the wandering drunks that make their way in.

Jin Yoshikawa

Always find great brand name clothes at incredible prices!!

Danielle Fuentes

Staff is excellent and selection changes quite frequently. Everything is always in good condition.

Serena Syas

a little pricey but overall nice finds.

Edwin Arbito

Good prices and cool selection You may to have come back!

Jeff Smith

Excellent consignment store. Great selection of mens clothing.

anthony alvarez

Smaller than the location in Williamsburg but same style of resale clothing

Cedric Carl

Nice store a little pricy but cool finds

Malcolm Cain

Not as good as the other locations. Depending on the day certain staff profile people of color in the store and follow them.

Sergei Wallace

Great selection of quality shoes, clothes, etc

S ieveking

Small place but good variety and prices.

Rakia May

Great selection. Items are constantly cycling through.

David Wagenschuetz

Found two very nice pieces and the staff is super friendly

Tierra S Coleman

Love this store every time I shop there

Rosy Bale

Very nice staff. Very comfortable fun experience

Shari Figueira

Well organized, clean store, good finds.

Bogdan Se

Once in a while can find some amazing deals!!!

Christopher Andia

Cool people, cloths cost a lot but still cool

Sam F

Super cute and decent prices!

Kassi Guerverra

Best store ever want to work there

Cristina Tejada

Very nice customer service!!!

Susan Donald

A great find -neat clean and to the point

Nadja Blagojevic

Great selection of designer duds!

M Lectora

Really cramped, not the nicest staff.

Craig Bartkewicz

Not as good as California s selection s

matthew thom

Very good

kay La Lele

Loads of antiqueclothes loved it

Keiko Striplin

Not so good selection

zululemoko

Misty be willing to dig

Obi Orbital

I guess it's ok

Er.Mubashir Rauf

Good

Jean Baptiste Saint Pol

Cheap and cool stuffs

Israel Mena Muñoz

Nice

Jack Courtney

Nice

SRG “SR9” SRG

Cheap and good

Mirtha Dominguez

loved it loved it

ALisa R

Love this place

Viacheslav Zhidkin

(Translation) Very good store. I recommend (Original) Очень хороший магазин. Рекомендую

有我洋祐

(Translation) It's pretty good, and it's very cheap. (Original) けっこういいのが揃ってて、さらにとても安い。

Ingrid Reichert

Christa

Contact

Photos