Reviews of Michael's, The Consignment Shop for Women. (Thrift Store) in New York (New York).

Michael's, The Consignment Shop for Women

193 Reviews

104 Comments

Thrift store

Consignment shop

1125 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10028, United States

Go to all the reviews

Description Map Opening Hours Reviews Contact Photos

Description

Information of Michael's, The Consignment Shop for Women, Thrift store in New York (New York)

Discover the opening times, the location, contact, popular times, photos and real reviews by internet users.

This place has a very good rate, they treat their customers well and you’ll feel welcome, super recommended

Map

Open hours of Michael's, The Consignment Shop for Women

Sunday

Closed

Monday

Closed

Tuesday

11 am–6 pm

Wednesday

11 am–6 pm

Thursday

11 am–6 pm

Friday

11 am–6 pm

Saturday

11 am–6 pm

Popular times

Tuesday

11
12
13
14
15
16
17

Wednesday

11
12
13
14
15
16
17

Friday

11
12
13
14
15
16
17

Reviews of Michael's, The Consignment Shop for Women

Michelle Everett

Fantastic experience and not my first! I lived in NYC for many years! I've experienced Michael's in person. It's an awesome place and my on line transaction was seamless. I'm taking a break from my frivolous spending. But, when I decide to shop online again, I'll certainly return.

Francine Perri

Great little consignment shop. Lots to choose from. Items are in nice condition. People are friendly. Willing to work with you I purchased designer shoes at awesome prices and they were in amazing condition!

E. Michael Brezina, III

Wife bought a pair of shoes. My wife says this is one of her favorites of the City. Great service. Great prices for what it is. Ladies, if you shop here you need to understand that it seems a little (or a lot) expensive if you are not from the City — but the reality is that Michael’s has an impeccable collection of goods in pristine condition at generally remarkably cheap prices (under the circumstances). My wife likes all that stuff and we have spent a lot more $ for the same basic pair of wedges she bought today. Strongly recommend.

Afsaneh latifi

I have been going to Michael’s for more than 20 yrs. and they are like family to me. People have been working there since I started going, that should tell you something. They love being there and helping people look good. I have never had a bad experience and everyone is always smiling and happy to help. If you have never gone there, you are missing a hidden treasure of NYC.

Venus McDonald

I bought a beautiful Chanel necklace in excellent condition and a lovely Diane VF zebra print dress! The sales lady was extremely helpful and engaging. A great shopping experience! They had lots of other great items at great prices. I highly recommend them.

Randi Ungar

Michael's, The Consignment Shop for Women, has a fantastic in-store- and online experience. When i lived in the city, i went in monthly and never left empty handed. If you want high-end designer fashion, Michael's does not disappoint. Their inventory is current and they have many items. The staff there is extremely helpful but never pushy- a fine line to to toe, if you ask me. Also their prices are extremely fair- you won't find any better. Their online experience is also excellent- items are easy to find and there is a plethora of pictures for each item, something a lot of sites don't always have. Hands down a great store overall!

Elizabeth Marlow

I just want to say how much I love shopping at Michael's! I was there with a girlfriend last week and we had a fabulous experience. Not only did I find the most incredible pieces, I had a wonderful time because of Nicole and the other women working there. Nicole was incredibly helpful in thinking about how to style a Donna Karan wrap dress. She was also enthusiastic about all of my friend's and my purchases. I live in California and she and the other ladies were so helpful with shipping. I can't say enough about what a pleasure it is to shop at Michael's - your clothes are gorgeous but your sales ladies are beautiful inside and out!

Jen b

I wanted to update my last review from over a year ago. This place still deserves more than 5 stars. I have bought a few things here and there and have had a wonderful experience every time. I do not live in New York, and have not been to the store. But I do shop online and have had a great experience. Would highly recommend Michael’s to anyone. And will continue to do business with them in the future.

Nancy Klein

I have ordered twice online from Michael's and have been thrilled with my purchases. The pair of Manolo Blahnik flats I received were in such perfect condition that I splurged on a pair of Blahnik booties. Both items were in mint condition, and sent to me so quickly that I hardly had time to work up the proper excitement. I intend to shop again online, and look forward to visiting the shop when I am in NYC this summer.

Carol M. Shaheen

Michael's is a true find ! They have wonderful designer consignment from clothing and shoes to bags, jewelry, and scarves. They are meticulous in what they accept and reasonable with their pricing scale and owner split. An added bonus is the friendly staff and adorable dog mascot, Buster. You will not be disappointed if you consign or shop here !

Elizabeth Casperite

As a consignor, Michael's has priced my items fairly, and always been punctual mailing checks every month. They are selective about what they will accept, but you are assured pieces that are almost like new when you shop.

Lauren Palmer

I was in New York with my husband so he could have outpatient surgery at Lenox Hill Hospital, and wandered into Michael's by coincidence when I went looking for a way to distract myself. I had such a lovely experience there, and with some help from the staff, picked out a few pieces that I absolutely love. It was a great way to spend a little time, rather than sitting in the hospital waiting room. I also wore one of of my new dresses to see Hamilton the following night!

Shane York

A very trusted and honorable establishment. Laura helped me through my mother's estate and she couldn't have been more wonderful. They're best and the most established consignment in NYC because they're honest, trustworthy in what they sell, and completely professional. Buying or selling, it's always a pleasure to do business with Michael's!

Nader

The people here at Michael's are truly outstanding. They know how to choose the best merchandise like the most worldly fashionistas,, but also how to treat customers like small town friends. I can't rate them highly enough!!

Courtney Ott

What a great find this store is for anyone who loves quality fashion merchandise at a discount! I found this store while in NYC for fashion week in February of 2015 and have been a devotee ever since. A great secret on the upper east side for amazing finds in apparel, shoes, handbags and accessories. A must visit store when in the city... Courtney - Naples, FL

LC Tillman

I discovered your shop after I left the city so I wasn't able to stop by in person. I just received my first online purchase and I could not be happier. I want to tell everyone but at the same time, I want to keep you as my own little fashion secret! I just bought the most beautiful pair of Louboutins. I was nervous they wouldn't fit or they wouldn't look as good as the picture. Well, they fit like a glove! And looked as perfectly as you rated them. Not a scratch or knick on them. I could not be happier. This was my first purchase but will not be my last! And the next time I'm in the city, I'll be dropping in. Thank you!

Jennifer Janklow

It's consignment. What you'd expect. it's hit or miss. I'm not really much for designer resale as I prefer real vintage and rare exquisite pieces. yes you can find Chanel bags here but they are the ones usually no one really wants, I go to Pilgrim NY downtown for the cool iconic Chanel bags and other items. I've tried many consignment shops and everything just feels a bit creepy. Maybe it's me, but I just really like vintage, real vintage that is unique and divine and magical, this just feels like resale of stuff that maybe no one really wanted in the first place. I'm sure if you come here a lot you will find a gem or too, but I don't have the time or patience.

Anne Kirkup

Great choice of clothes, a pleasant shopping environment and super helpful staff. There was a small error on my receipt which they took care of promptly and graciously. I recommend this store to anyone looking for a good bargain for quality clothing. However, to be clear, this is not a thrift store.

Jan Clarke (JC)

This is THE BEST place for both consigning up to date "gently worn" designer items and buying wonderful things. Their Chanel and Hermes selections are great on 2 floors. The staff is always helpful and very, very professional. Opening at 9:30 am is a big plus, as well.....

jeanne parker

It was so nice to shop online with a business that I trust 100%.I used to visit the Manhattan store all the time but I moved to Miami and can now shop from home. The Prada handbag looked beautiful and it is! Thank you for sending it so fast and I will use it tomorrow!Thanks again.

Nancy Olsen

The staff at Michael's has been very helpful and professional! My consignments sold well at the prices they suggested and that I thought were fair. I'm out of state and they were able to work with me easily. Thanks, Michael's, for your great store and service!

kenneth wolf

I have both purchased and sold items at Michael's. The things they sell are beautiful and their inventory is well curated. When I sell items with them they pay promptly and keep responsible track of my items. Michael's is the top consignment shop in NYC.

Brid Hackman

A little pricier than the boutique next door but then these are authenticated luxury goods. In less than half an hour I nabbed a pair of Jil Sander wool slacks and a Theory cold shoulder sweater for a total spend of less than $200. Friendly staff and a wide range of items. Bonus: Scout the dog was in residence when I stoppped in. A must-see for any fashionista visiting New York!

Tara Gallagher

Have bought many fabulous items at Michael's over the years....Ralph Lauren vintage turquoise belt, Manolo Blahnik shoes, Oscar de la Renta shoes, great sunglasses, Prada skirt....this is the best consignment store in NYC.

Allene Feldman

I have been consigning and shopping at Michael's for more than 20 years, and the clothing is of the highest quality and of the best designers. The service is also courteous and helpful.

isa m Rosensweet

I ordered a beautiful Vera Wang dress thru the internet. Dress is magnificent, perfect for a wedding - price was under one hundred dollars. It is pure silk and gorgeous. I do not think anyone wore it.

Beth Mermelstein

I'm not an avid shopper but have scored lovely dresses, jewelry, handbags and scarves over 20 years at Michael's. Helpful and polite staff.

Teri Bohl

Had great experience consigning some of my clothes and accessories. The staff appraised my items and sold them! Kept me informed and sent checks as items sold. Very professional staff, very pleased.

Sally Green

Love my Fendi bag! Always got back to me very fast @ helped me a lot !! wonderful experience will buy again thank you so much ! Also very fast ship Sally Greem

Maria Broussard

Fabulous store! Well organized, super friendly staff and lots of beautiful merchandise! I will make it a "must " every time I visit New York. Thank goodness they have a website!!!

Giselle Carrilho

I love the store the staff is very courteous the stores beautifully decorated and warm you could easily look through all the garments and handbags it's a delight to go in there I would highly recommend it

Christina D

Fabulous! I love Michael's both shopping in the store and online. My dress came fast and was exactly as advertised. Thank you!!!

hana ramos

Always renewing and accepting quality goods

Stacy N.

Very nice and clean store. Was very pleased with the items I received.

Mallory G

Such a cute lux consignment shop, great place to stop if you are shopping in UES

Anjollie Feradov

A treasure hunt of immaculate high end fashion at unbelievable prices! The staff are so warm and friendly that I visit frequently since they make you feel at home!

Heather Diehl

Great selection of classic pieces in excellent condition. Chanel suits. Furs, accessories, Dior, Missioni, and St John.

Judy Acs

I hesitated to purchase a handbag I saw in the store on a recent trip to NYC. I now own the bag thanks to the great online and customer service you provide!

Tracy Mitchell

I love Michael's!! Every time I go to NYC I will be visiting!!! AND their online shopping is awesome too!

Andie Aylward

I love Michael's Consignment! I have purchased some wonderful pieces from them and they're prices are great!

Audrey Kubie

Wonderful place to shop for designer clothing and accessories. Have never had a problem with anything in at least 30 years!!!

Nancy Flaherty

I love looking through the racks of beautiful items at Michael's, The Consignment Shop when I am in NYC! You never know what you might find...

Amanda Rising

Item was exactly as described. The packaging was lovely. I will definitely check back often for more amazing deals!

Isabel Cheren

Excellent. Have Great items They let you shop with no sales pressure. In fact, I do not think there are sales people.

Yolanda Floyd

My Christian Louboutin's shoes arrived just as described! I love them! Fast delivery!

April Dickerson

I bought a pair of cute boots from, Michael's and they are very good quality.

Jolie Frank

Bought some fabulous items and consigned a handbag that sold in a few weeks. Very nice staff!

Clinton Carver

If you're ever in New York you must shop with Michael's. Great merchandise at an affordable price.

Sara Karrer

Great selection and everything is in excellent condition. Thanks for the zippy Prada skirt!

Jessica Elias

I have consigned here several times and when it works it’s great, but they have also lost some of my items.

Dr Carla Seleme

Michael's is FABULOUS! My daily addiction! Most highly recommend!

Maria Robles

Always deliver great customer service and very knowledgeable on authenticity of designers.

June Hersh

Pleasant to deal with, attracts a good clientele and has already turned some of many special giveaways into cash.

Betty Lam

Good selection of high end merchandise and nicely displayed with good dressing rooms to try things out.

Dannie Lopez

Fantastic selection of high end goods, staff is amazingly friendly and helpful.

sonia Richardson

Found a wonderful deal on a Botkier handbag. The service and delivery were impeccable.

jeanine ventura

received my items next day and am very happy with my purchases!

Andrea Wildman

I think Michaels is top notch with fair pricing. I would HIGHLY recommend Michaels

Shari Harbinger

Expert care and customer service in a warm and friendly environment. Everything is beautifully showcased. 👍 …

Karineh Carapetian

Organized, Clean with attentive sales team and great selection of merchandise.

Kate Bini

The Staff is very helpful and answer any and all questions. The Store is beautifful.

Yolanda Ledesma

A lot of great items to shop; plus great customer service!

Gayle Gurchiek

Love this place!!! It will be my first stop when I go back to NYC.

Carmela Barone

Great shop for designer deals, and great and courteous staff.

Shon H

Great Place to shop. Great customer service.

Rachel Nash

Fabulous! Great finds. Quality and priced well.

Karen Schneider

Beautiful items, great service, good quality.

Sandra Bross

We always find great things here.

Mara Ceglia

i believe Michael is the best reliable Consignment shop in town!

Monika Wiśniewska

Everything was Good a very Good store with nice people

sharon bryant

Just reviewing items online. Simply beautiful

Ronald Winchell

Love this place. Always find the best things

Lauren K

Best deals on vintage designer pieces!

claude sfire

There fabulous !!!

L. C.

Very friendly staff ! They will work with you !

Gina Yuan

very friendly and good products！

Kendall Coleman

Excellent merchandise like new fantastic!

cv houston

Always acomodating and fast shipping.

cat stephens

Fabulous service and amazing deals!!

lori anderson

Great place - Great service - Great experience!

Sarah Schlesinger

Michael's is the absolute best!

Gillian Flynn

Pro. Friendly. Sublimely organized.

Sun Lee

Customer service was excellent!!!

Psychic Chevy Chase

Best

MA Dantin

Fun! Fun!Fun!

mar blue

Wonderful!

Fayola Ricotta

super, super easy!

Jackie

Wonderful service

Cyndie Bellen-Berthézène

I'm a fan.

Robin H Moss

Excellent !!

blossom island

(Translation) It's a luxury vintage shop. Chanel and Hermes have a separate hanger and I don't care if I pick anything up and go to the dressing room. It's hundreds of clothes. (Original) 명품 빈티지 샵이예요. 샤넬과 에르메스는 따로 모아놓은 행거가 있고 아무거나 집어서 바로 탈의실 가도 신경을 안써요 몇백짜리 옷인데ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 구찌원피스 795불인가.. 예쁜 옷들 많아요 루부탱 구두도많고 가방은 그닥

Ramon Toribio

(Translation) I walk daily and I always see people wearing a mask and taking the right distance, I like that. RT... (Original) Camino diario y veo siempre las personas con máscara y tomando la distancia correcta éso me gusta. R.T...