Reviews of Buffalo Exchange. (Thrift Store) in Minneapolis (Minnesota).

Buffalo Exchange

326 Reviews

148 Comments

Thrift store

Used clothing store

2727 Lyndale Ave S, Minneapolis, MN 55408, United States

Description

Information of Buffalo Exchange, Thrift store in Minneapolis (Minnesota)

Discover the opening times, the location, contact, popular times, photos and real reviews by internet users.

This place has a very good rate, they treat their customers well and you’ll feel welcome, super recommended

Map

Open hours of Buffalo Exchange

Popular times

Sunday

Monday

Tuesday

Wednesday

Thursday

Friday

Saturday

Reviews of Buffalo Exchange

Cullen

Just visited this store for the first time. I have recently started to get into thrifting, and this place was a GREAT experience! The fitting room staff member at the time was very friendly and helpful! Most thrift stores I go to are 90% junk, along with some occasional lucky finds. This store was NOT like that at all. This store had plenty of trendy and cool items. It seems that Buffalo exchange is very particular about what products they hand-pick for their sales floor. I can appreciate that a lot! Buffalo exchange seems to be going for eco-friendliness in their store as well. I highly recommend checking this place out! (I wish I would have taken better photos; the store was very visually appealing to me and was very well organized.)

Tristan Klausegger

I like shopping here more than selling here - prices are a bit more than other resale shops, but they actually pay less. I have sold clothes at Plato's Closet and they bought more items and paid more per item, even though their sales prices are lower. Buffalo feels like a local, independent business, so I was surprised to find out it was a chain. I did find an amazing Walt Disney World raincoat here that is super lightweight and easy to tuck into a backpack. I mean this as a compliment, but I feel like this would be a great spot for drag queens to buy shoes.

Karen Raymer

I have mixed feelings about this Buffalo Exchange. Because it's one of the only consignment shops in the area to buy up front, I think they get some really really nice, in demand gems, like made well jeans, everlane shoes, and beautiful Anthropologie and free people. However, it's a small store and I would definitely echo reviewers who think the selection skews a little young/cheap. The buying philosophy here seems to be to go with the trends, so there are a lot of things like cropped wild fable tops, low to mid-quality trendy looking jeans, cutesy/cheap new items like mushroom printed socks and the like. I do come here now and then and I respect the work that the store does, but it's not my favorite.

pulp

got some rly dope stuff here in the past and sometimes you find gold, but most items are overpriced and mid. the cheapest tee i found was $10 and it was absolutely tattered, they had used champion clothes for more than the cost of them new, etc. buffalo exchange is a rich person’s thrift store lol just use depop or sumn

Molly B.

As others have said, the brands and prices of clothes here can be questionable; however, I believe the pros of this store easily outweigh those cons. The staff here is SO kind and always thanks me for bringing items in to sell - such a better shopping experience than another certain trendy resale chain. New items come in every day, making each shopping experience unique. I can always find at least one thing to leave with!

Souleymane Traoré dit soul

solid clothing store. You get some solid stuff for a decent price! On top of that the service is great!

Felicia Santana

The short wait outside the building, due to covid policies, was more than worth it. As soon as people came out, others were let in and the staff was vigilant and fair about tracking who is next to shop. Staff is so friendly and accommodating. While I was shopping I was politely and casually asked if I needed help and an employee offered to take my items I had in my hand to put up front with my name, great customer service. I went in with my service dog and there was absolutely no issues. He had been eating grass earlier that day and I saw him not looking well, I promptly asked the employee if she could hold my item while I took him outside and she did, when I got back they were getting water for him! So wholesome! The clothes must be well cleaned before they go on the rack because my whole bag had a pleasant scent when I got home. Not musky at all like the other places. They let you donate to a cause when you buy a reusable bag and the bags are unique and good quality! Great prices and awesome finds!! I cant wait to stop in again when I'm in the area!

Hayley Hansen

Always a great selling experience! The staff members here are very friendly and quick!

K S

Friendly staff but they were not interested in my quality 1980s vintage designer items (size 6, 8). I gave things I spent hundreds on to charity through them while I saw them buy up cheap worn stuff. I will look for quality vintage to take further clothing. They seem less interested in using quality pieces than in what's on the runway and fast fashion.

Morgan Martin

Lululemon, Free People, Champion, Levi, they won’t take it. Brought it some shein clothes and they took that. Very nice staff, but a common trend among minneapolis thrift stores that they forgot it’s a thrift store and not a retail store. spent more money in gas to get here then I received-save your time and sell your clothes online.

Isadora Tures

This thrift shop is always interesting to visit. The selection of clothes for plus size is pretty small but the decor and the accessories are tons of fun.

Grace Marek

Great experience the cashier was amazing! They helped me find more cool graphic t-shirts that i fell in love with! The vibe in the store is great, the co-workers are super happy and friendly. Overall the store is very welcoming and has super cool clothes a shoes. I’m definitely coming back :)

Zachary Lao

INCREDIBLE SERVICE!! The staff was extremely nice and very helpful! REALLY GOOD SELECTION!! The racks are FULL with really nice, vintage, stylish, trendy clothes and at a fair price! The selection also has really good quality name brand shoes for a good price. I was so happy with the store that I had to make an account just to leave a review.

Dakotah Starr

This store is AMAZING. They offer fair prices when buying clothes and have a great selection of clothing. They don't offer a lot in terms of pants for anything bigger than a size 10. But they constantly have Doc Martens coming and going. I have been here many times and the staff is always phenomenal and SUPER friendly. They where kind enough to hold a pair of boots until they were done assessing my donation. All around a great store with great employees 🙌

Connor Hills

Great finds to be had here. Speaking for the men's inventory, awesome styles and deals on jackets, sweatshirts and button downs can be had consistently. Pants and shorts are in shorter supply, but there are quality brands if you can find sizing.

Lawrence Lipsey

Like the assortment of clothes they sell. They also offer a fair price for what they buy from you too!

Danika Hennings

LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS PLACE! Everything from the atmosphere, the music, the selection, and staff is fantastic. I go here at least 2 a week and always walk out with amazing finds.

Lloyd Scott

People should know, You want to be friendly and smile. Ask question??? I only have dealings with approximately eleven different companies in the Twin Cities... Everyone does this business differently. Out of fifty plus articles +50 Only one item was wanted. "Not everything in your closet is in demand at Buffalo Exchange". I was called by my name and welcomed and thanked!!!

Amara Chambers

Shopping here is fun. I may not always find something that's a must-have, but they always have new stuff coming in. I especially like browsing the accessories and shoes. I also has a great selling experience here. I brought in about 20 items, and they bought about 15 of them. They told me exactly what they would sell each item for and how much I would get. I could make the choice to sell item-by-item. They liked more and offered more than I had expected. This was by-far the best in-store selling experience I have ever had. Compared to some other shops around town, this selling process was fair, and they were candid about everything. There was no snobbery when they turned down my Old Navy jeans, but they were enthusiastic about the items they did take. I will definitely buy and sell here again.

Padee Ly

Great place with fun styles. The employees were fun to talk to and really helpful when I donated clothes, very accommodating as well. You can get 50% of the clothes you've brought that they want to take for store credit or 30% for straight up cash. They tell you this if you are selling clothes. The downside to this though is that they are in a bit of a traffic heavy area and they actually don't have a parking lot.

Heather Hubert

I have had nothing but wonderful experiences here. I found the perfect summer skirt for a reasonable price and even took a chance on selling. The woman going through my clothes made me feel comfortable and we had a pretty good conversation. Ended up with the store credit so I can come back and shop. Definitely a much more positive experience than going to other similar places..

Joc Lourey

Buffalo is one of the only places I shop in store at, and I've been going for years. I can't even explain how much I love it. The environment, products, and overall experience is so perfect for those who enjoy more unique, trendy, and new-york like fashion. If you're selling, you will most likely get a great deal compared to places such as platos closet. As for the products, i have found some of my favorite pieces at buffalo and the associates really seem to have an eye for great fashion pieces that most stores seem to overlook. The service is always great, and they uphold a certain vibe that I believe their customers continue coming back for.

Shay Schreurs

Constantly changing options. Plenty to see and choose from but not ever overly stocked. Very well curated. The staff is awesome. They have a pretty good system if you want to sell or trade your clothes. Another plus is they are minimal waste and donate to good causes.

Lexi Toberman

Came here the other day for the first time. Staff was very nice. It’s a small store so it’s sort of difficult to look through stuff without bumping into other stuff. I found a LYM hat for a great price and was very happy. I especially love that they do not have plastic bags, so they give you a 5 cent token to donate to 3 different charities in the area.

Avery Pierce

Bit of a musty smell but the selection is very cool and eclectic! The staff here is fun and helpful and the establishment has a strong "uptown" vibe. Extremely cool atmosphere and there are some real gems hidden on the racks, but the prices are a little high and the changing rooms definitely leave one......wanting. Still, I've never been anywhere else like this. It's worth a look!

W V

Store isn't bad but the new drop off "system" is far too convoluted to be worth doing. 24 hour advance appointment to drop something off? Driver's license information? Take my phone # and the bag of clothes. Goodwill it is, don't have time to call during the work day and give out personal information. I understand the difficult times we are currently experiencing but it's simply unnecessary for it to be such a p.i.t.a. to bring in clothing.

Shelby Rodriguez

This store is great for trendy finds and good deals. While the prices are higher than other thrift stores in the Twin Cities, I go there with the guarantee I will find multiple items I love. Staff are friendly and helpful. I am ALWAYS asked if I want a fitting room started, even if I only have one or two items in my hands. If they are busy, which they usually are, they will start a 'waiting' rack for me. I really enjoy this kind of service, and makes me want to come back each time. I have not sold here before, although I know that they do buy. If I had to say anything about this location as a warning; be prepared to bring your own shopping bag, and find parking a block or two away.

Amanda Wetzel

One of my favorite places to shop but I’m pretty bummed the prices have gone up over the years. Some of the items they are selling could be bought new for a couple more dollars. Still love shopping here but if you’re going to charge what you do at least find nicer brands

Rachel Domenichetti

Fun, trend focused, constantly updated selection of clothing. Could benefit from a more organized approach in their buying. Maybe by appointment or at give the customers waiting a number? Was skipped over today while trying to sell clothing after I waited patiently. Then I was told repeatedly "it's okay" by the employees when I objected. They were extremely dismissive. Try Everyday People in St. Paul if you want a more friendly experience selling. I always opt for the store credit. Very transparent--they show you a slip tabulating your credit for each item. Eclectic stock though-but great for vintage lovers!

A A

This is a great place to sell your used clothing. They will donate whatever they don't buy if you ask them to. So for me, it's like they're paying me to make a donation. The staff are all really friendly too.

Peter Lamm

Great selection of stylish vintage clothing, footwear and accessories. Attracts a trendy young crowd, business is brisk. Staff are friendly, quick, helpful and trendy themselves even a bit edgy. Fun place to be I think some prices are tad high but then they must pay rent and at least minimum wage salaries

Kastina Morrison

I LOVE or maybe loved this place previously but my last experience brought on a surprising level of disappointment - not only with selling items, but also their selection. I brought in a bag of clothes, a bag of accessories and a brand new pair of heels, still in the box. I dropped them off and was excited to wonder the store (I also have a $50 gift card burning a hole in my pocket as well). As I looked around I was excited to see the accessories - they have a great selection - but then I started looking at the price tags...$11 for a necklace, $17 for a pair of obviously worn shoes...then I saw a pair of sandals, TARGET sandals for $9.50 from two summers ago. Are you kidding? TARGET brand anything, 2nd hand, for over $8 is insane, no matter what it is. I can go on Amazon and get the same quality of merchandise NEW for that - AND fee shipping, AND then I don't have to use gas or my time either! The dresses were the same, many low brand items, priced over $10 and they weren't that well taken care of either. And let me tell you - anything you're trying to sell that has a stain on it - please, don't be pretentious enough to sell it for over $12. Just don't. Then, the nice gal at the front desk politely told me that they didn't want anything I had - which I am typically TOTALLY fine with hearing, no problem - but comparing what I had - many higher quality items, barely worn - to what they were attempting to sell at prices I can get all those items at on a good clearance day...I left confused on disappointed. Over all I have to say this round, I was highly disappointed with what they were trying to sell at the prices they were doing so. I understand that Uptown is growing and changing, but why you didn't want my $120 ALDO heels I wore once for a wedding this year, but you bought someones TARGET sandals, from 2 summers ago, and tried to sell them instead? You have got to be kidding. I do plan to try again in a few weeks - hoping for better luck next time!

Amanda Barrie

I love shopping here for three reasons: the clothes, the prices, and the staff. There is such a fun and tasteful assortment of apparel and accessories here and all very reasonably priced. And the staff couldn't be nicer. They've been so friendly and accommodating when I've shopped there with my toddler.

Jen Andrasko

I shop here frequently for their deals on great clothes. I have to say I’m very impressed by the level of customer service and knowledge of their staff. Every time I’m in there I feel like see them giving their staff little sales exercises and going over new customer service initiatives. Another thing I thought was cool was how the few times I was shopping right before closing they never rushed me out of there and encouraged me to take my time. Great place!

Brandon Davis

Going to a rain soaked state and needed base layers and things for the rain. They did not disappoint! All the employees were super helpful and even found me a brand new marmot raincoat that was Brand new! The coat online lists for $300 they had it for $42.

Ashley Brastad

Only reason I don't give them a 5 is because of their prices. I bought 3 shirts and a pair of jeans for around 53 dollars. For a "consignment/thrift" store that's a bit high, but they can definitely get away with it! Their selection is very unique and I will absolutely go back when I need a standout piece!

Whittney Bartkey

Often overpriced based on the fact it is second hand . Maybe okay for designer prices , but 75% if the items you could buy for nearly the same price off the rack brand new at the store they came from . I️ find items from target , forever 21, H&M, Nike, etc. that I️ could purchase brand new for the same price . Some good finds . Staff is knowledgeable

George Lastlin

It's a crapshoot. On the one hand, you can get a well-made leather jacket for $40 instead of $300. On the other, they sell a t-shirt for $15, that shouldn't have cost more than $10 when it was new. You're also better off burning your clothes to power your steam engine than bothering to sell them here. You'll just end up carrying 90% back out with you, while getting about $1 for every $5 they'll sell of what they took (That reads oddly, but you know what I mean.)

Gage Degerness

Great selection of trendy clothing for men and women. Prices were standard for an upscale consignment shop; ~$11-$25 for mens shirts and pants. Really friendly and helpful staff.

Evan VanHoever

Very fun environment and looks good after the recent remodel. For thrifting purposes, it is expensive, but for shopping it is perfect. I picked up a pair of chocolate dress shoes for 48, full price of 300-400.

Eli Newhouse

A good selection of vintage clothing and accessories for relatively affordable prices for a student's budget. A good place for a theater department's costumers especially if in search of something specific. A fun place to visit with fashionable friends.

Cathy S

I sold a few things here. Dakota is amazing! She was very friendly. The second time I went here the woman who was working was rude and called 3 other people ahead of me. She said she was from Houghton Michigan, cant remember her name. When I asked if I was supposed to sit in a certain spot so they know who is next she said they call people up in any order. Doesn't make sense! Shouldn't it go in order who came first?

Ben Cross

Always a good, rotating selection. Every time I've been in I've found a pair of shoes that originally sold for over 300 dollars that I bought for around 40 bucks! One of the best priced Buffalo's I've been to.

Annie Gerard

By far the nicest staff I've ever stumbled upon in the twin cities. Everyone says hello and it's obvious they hire creative and nonjudgemental individuals. The clothing is a little overpriced, but I'm still giving them 5 stars.

Em Marci

Love coming here to shop for unique pieces but it’s a little pricey. I’ve seen a few items from forever 21 or H&M that they are selling for way more than the actual companies are pricing them... which is kind of a bummer.

Vanessa Talberg

It was very colorful to say the least. I had fun looking around. It was clean and organized and the staff were friendly and knowledgeable. Some stuff in there seemed over price for used/ 2nd hand stuff, but the items were also almost like new, and there were plentiful unique and nostalgic items all over which made it fun to look around.

Kimberly Bell

Decent selection, but sizes definitely favor smaller, young clientele. They used to have more vintage items, but personally, it seems they are moving in a more modern, cheap-chic trendy direction. Losing a bit of the "weird" I used to like there.

Yessica Nova

Its ok, i think other buffalo exchange have much better quality, and it does smell like old in the store.. also it should be a little bit more organized. The staff is pretty friendly tho, awesome staff!

Caleb Timmerman

Buffalo exchange is a great place to get current style for less cash! you can also sell or trade ... as long as your stuff is in good condition and in style! The people who work there are amazing and they will help you find your true self!

Victoria

I go there 4-5 times per year. they offer great price and all staff work there is so friendly and patient. highly recommend! Declutter the closet and then go to buffalo exchange! you wont regret it!

Stewart Parsons

Great place, low prices, merchandise in good shape.

Michael Mullaney

Cute spot, with incredible eclectic style! The staff is super helpful and friendly! Happy treasure hunting to who ever ventures in!

Brittany Miller

You will find tons of steals here. I am a huge fan of fashion and love stumbling upon designer brands for less. Lots of hidden gems in this store!! Also the staff is super helpful :)

Timothy Kelly

Absolutely amazing! A lot of style and very friendly, optimistic staff. I recommend for the best sell, trade, and buy experience all in one. Picked up and sold some nice goods here. #FunFashion

Diane Dulany

Fantastic store, they have really fun styles! The employees are super nice! Great place to sell your used clothes!!!

Martha Gray

I think this place must have gotten a new manager because the selection has gotten sooooo much better; it's not just a bunch of basic girl clothes anymore, there is some actual variety. Much appreciated.

Andrew Meggs

A very cool vintage store, you can sell your old clothes there as well! Every time I've gone, they've had a great selection and great service.

Renee R

Super friendly staff and unbeatable deals - have found many high quality designer items for under $100, and super unique items that have a special place in my closet.

Erica Anderson

I've had some great jewelry finds here, but not so much luck with clothes. The staff that works here is awesome though!

Joshua Merrick

I love this place!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Such nice stuff. Its like Plato's Closet... Except WAY nicer stuff. And cooler staff. They were soooooo helpful and friendly! I can't wait till I'm in the neighborhood again so I can stop in and buy stuff!!!!!

Quinn Cowing

I love coming here! The customer service is amazing and they always have a great selection of trendy looks and are fairly size inclusive.

Lucy Mittag

I brought in some items to sell, felt like they passed up some good name brand good quality items but my guess is that they’re over stocked, workers were nice, would go back.

C R

These people are the best! Friendly, helpful and I got a brand new free people dress for 30 bucks!

Alec Eismann

You can find some really nice pieces here for cheap, but you can also find some pieces that are cheap brands that are marked up way too high for what they are. The selection there is usually pretty nice, you sometimes just have to be there at the right time.

Dylan McKellips

Excellent clothing selection, friendly staff, reasonable prices. I will be returning again.

Donald Luther

Good selection of quality vintage clothing. Prices are fair. Location accessible with street parking. Friendly staff.

Athelia Crosmun (Athelia [she/her])

Packed full with clothes - but can be a little messy because of it. Friendly staff, lots of styles and price points to choose from.

Sarah

Super crowded and alright selection smells like a hippys dirty sock after a four day fest... So I mean it's pretty legit. 😉 …

Paul Jahn

Nice mens selection from vintage t's, coats, jeans, shoes, etc. it's fairly spacious as well so you're not digging though bins.

Pearl McClintock

Cool atmosphere and items but expensive for a thrift store. Their earring selection is funky, but way too expensive.

Aaron Christofferson

They had name brand cloths in great condition for cheap.

jazzy cat

Friendly helpful staff, was able to get in and out decently quickly after using changing room twice. Love this place

Mary Penny

Fun selection, friendly staff. Very reasonable return when selling your clothes to them.

Lily Noonan

One of my favorite second hand stories in the cities. I’ve had some fantastic finds there over the years

Janet

Women's section is huge!

Spencer

Great variety of clothes with fair pricing. A little small and crowded, but friendly!

Valerie Tema

A lot of fast fashion (target, forever 21, fashionnova) and not even for that cheap

Nurturing Nirvana

Love love love this place. Very hipster funk style clothing. Unique and friendly staff!

Lilly Homstad

Amazing gently used clothes selection, really fun and unique styles at reasonable prices

Laura Lee

Great staff. Nice selection. Awesome vibe.

Jeffry Lynn Stolz

Plenty of stock to choose from but overpriced. Buffalo Exchange in Ballard Washington is the best by far.

zack mengel

The staff is friendly and willing to help a regular shopper find some hidden gems.

Grant Matthews

Great place with a lot of selection and good social distancing measures. Shame about the lack of banana bread though

AJ Hans

Friendly and stylish employees. I like that they donate to charity in place of giving out plastic shopping bags.

David Hargreaves

Workers were friendly and helpful. Found a sweet packers flannel for a great price.

Daniel Kunkler

There's pretty good women's selection, men's is boring but I've found girls stuff that works.

Reeca Dae Rettig

Pricey compared to Plato's closet.. but super cute clothes

Alton Gerold

Love this place, get the majority of my clothing here. A great staff and a great setup.

Ella MT

Great customer service and unique clothes! I would definitely come back!

Jake Hasse

Best thrift store in the twin cities. It can get a little crowded but that's just testament for its popularity.

lil strawberry

All of the staff is always so nice!! Omg I always find BOMB pieces here!!🔥🔥❤😈 …

Laura Schugel

Love this place, always has amazing finds!

Digory Anderson

Great clothes, helpful staff and a nice clean environment

L. Marie

Awesome selection of clothes for all styles and sizes.

Anna

The staff are extremely nice and upbeat. I really respect that!

Jesse Preston

Friendly staff, great selection, decent prices

Chris R

Great little thrift store. Plenty of treasures to be found with a little luck.

Forrest Knapp

Great selection, well laid out, friendly staff!

TheTigress333

They are always friendly and helpful. :-)

jori

Quality merch at fair prices+ awesome music

Anna Clarisse

Wow. Sell and shop. Amazing prices and unique finds.

Mick Butler

I always find something I like here! Decently priced!

Jay Elepano

Exactly what you think you'd find in an uptown resale shop. Dig and find your treasures!

Will Sánchez

Great palace! where you can find great buys.

Powertech Corporation

Buffalo exchange rules! The town of Buffalo is great, too!

Mares Anderson-Duggan

Nice trendy clothes. Helpful staff

Michael McGivern

Staff is very friendly, prices are extremely fair.

nathan Wallestad

Great deals. Quality and clean thrift

Josie b

The people there are very nice.

muzeus

Hot fashion, pretty good prices.

Sandi Robinson

Best place EVERY. Loved this shop

CrimsonKey

Cool stuff funny people good prices.

Kristi Striker

New. Used. Trade. Hunt. My favorite treasure spot.

Jessiclaire Wolf

Great prices and friendly staff.

Sean Stovall

The staff are always pleasant and fast!

Mike Nehmzow

Cool store , always find something

Brit Elizabeth

Always great finds here!!

Jessica Loe

Great finds of used clothing.

Thu Tran

Very fast when it comes to selling!

Jane Schneider

Went there my drag daughter

Natalie Peterson

Great selection and service.

Mikolai Altenberg

Great curated used clothing

Richard Moody

Great space for reused, clothing

Vernon Levens

Good experience with good buys.

Jadie Judy

Loved it

Paul Vaillancourt

Great service and selection

Isaac Newtons

Affordable and awesome styles

Dan Branovan

I got a shirt I like.

Tessa Kinowski

Super nice staff!

Polo Garcia

Really good food

jean paul paquette

Ok kinda slim.

Stephanie Hansen

Really great!

Connor McArdle

Not much for mens

Westley Hanson

Best

Tim Kluntz

Great steals!

Joe Homola

Neat little store.

B. Edward

Good selection!

Aji Opakunle

Gems and Gems at this place 💎💎💎 …

Rachel Opare-Addo

shoes shoes shoes shoes!

Seamus O'Halloran

People place and things are all in great shape.

T C

Sophie Wallerstedt

Sarah VanB

TinaP

Joseph Hensel

Allison Johnson

Xerxes Lucius

Morgan Ehlers

Contact

Photos