Reviews of Johnny's Pizzeria. (Restaurant) in Yonkers (New York).
Johnny's Pizzeria
30 W Lincoln Ave, Mt Vernon, NY 10550, United States
Description
Information of Johnny's Pizzeria, Restaurant in Yonkers (New York)
Discover the opening times, the location, contact, popular times, photos and real reviews by internet users.
This place has a very good rate, they treat their customers well and you’ll feel welcome, super recommended
Map
Open hours of Johnny's Pizzeria
Sunday
Closed
Monday
Closed
Tuesday
12:30–8:30 pm
Wednesday
12:30–8:30 pm
Thursday
12:30–8:30 pm
Friday
12:30–9 pm
Saturday
12:30–9 pm
Popular times
Monday
12 | |
---|---|
13 | |
14 | |
15 | |
16 | |
17 | |
18 | |
19 | |
20 |
Tuesday
12 | |
---|---|
13 | |
14 | |
15 | |
16 | |
17 | |
18 | |
19 | |
20 |
Wednesday
12 | |
---|---|
13 | |
14 | |
15 | |
16 | |
17 | |
18 | |
19 | |
20 |
Thursday
12 | |
---|---|
13 | |
14 | |
15 | |
16 | |
17 | |
18 | |
19 | |
20 |
Friday
12 | |
---|---|
13 | |
14 | |
15 | |
16 | |
17 | |
18 | |
19 | |
20 |
Reviews of Johnny's Pizzeria
Trinity Westlake
My mom and I are visiting NY from Ohio and decided to try Johnny’s for dinner. We absolutely LOVED everything about it. The staff was so warm and inviting. Everyone was very kind even with how busy they were. We had the fried ravioli, chicken Caesar salad, stuffed rigatoni Alfredo, pizza and meatballs. They had 3 guys working the pizza oven. One tossing the dough, one topping the dough and another cooking the pizza. The rigatoni tasted like homemade noodles and the Alfredo sauce was OUT OF THIS WORLD! I really felt like I was having dinner at my Italian grandmother’s house!
Ronald Yan
Crust is thin and crispy. Sauce is sweet and tangy. The cheese is just right. They put the sauce over the cheese to keep the dough from getting soggy. All this leads to the best pizza I have come across so far.
They don't do slices, whole pies only. This is so you get the freshest slice of pizza possible. Wait a minute or two before digging in because the pizza will burn the roof of your mouth. I've done it many times.
Make sure you bring cash or an debit card for the ATM machine.
Try the extra cheese pie as well. My friends and I usually get a regular and an extra cheese. It's the best of both worlds.
Danielle Kelly
Pepperoni and cheese pies - muah! Chef’s kiss! One of the best pizzerias I’ve ever visited!
Dine in if you can. Waitresses were cool to talk to and you can order a beer while you wait for your pies. Will absolutely be coming back here.
Traveling Cosmos and Tacos
Who said Cheese has to be on top?? 😂 This is great very thin crust pizza! Great flavor every time I come here! In the heart of Mt Vernon.
Luis Ocasio
I’ve been going to this place for over 20 years and I have never been disappointing. I’ve gone there to celebrate, baptisms, first communion, confirmations, birthdays, etc. with up to 20 and they have never skipped a beat. The pizza is always perfect thin crispy. The sauce is amazing. We just love this place. Personally, I think this is the best pizza in New York.
Raddigan Bros Noise Experience
Great thin crust pizza!
The pride of Mount Vernon.
Definitely one of the best NY style pizzas around.
MAXIMUS DTX
One bite everyone knows the rule... this is my personal all time favorite pizza. I haven't had it in years, went back today and it was just as good as I remember. Excellent sauce to cheese ratio, excellent under carriage, the perfect crunch. 10 out of 10 all damn day.
George Dallas
We came all the way from Nassau County, Long Island for this thin crust pizza 🍕! You can't stop eating it. Worth every mile travelled and every penny spent!
Ben Segal
Dave Portnoy gave this spot a 9.1 - an outrageously high score on his scale - and so I had no choice but to stop in and order a large plain pie. Well - my first 9.1 did not disappoint! It’s literally magic. I’ve been to thousands of local pizza spots - dough, sauce, cheese - nothing different here - but somehow when they open that oven, and pull out your pie, the smell is different. The look is different. The taste brings you back to another time. It’s simply the best pizza I’ve ever tasted. Hands down. It lives up to the hype and more. Just walk in, have cash in hand, order there and eat it there immediately - it’s an experience we should all have. The best!
Joseph Kraut
Best pizza I have ever had. Love Mary, she is awsome
Smita Rangesh
Well worth the 20 minute drive from Scarsdale and also the struggle to look for parking in this area.
The pizza is tasty - the crust is thin and crispy and just as it should be. We loved the bruschetta and the garlic bread as well.
The service is friendly. The ambience reminds me of a warm and friendly neighbourhood diner.
Will be back !
Update : We returned on 8th feb 2020and had as much of a good time and good food as the previous time. Saturday evenings seem to be super busy.
We returned May 14th ! Still as awesome 🤩
Rebekkah Maikisch
Food was delicious and we didnt have to wait for a table. Phenomenal pizza and garden salad. Fresh bread was wonderful.
T Claz
One of the best pizza places in the area, plus they have lots of other great Italian dishes. The wine is horrible though.
Andrea Andrade
This is where it's at. Come ready to eat. Been coming here for over 10 years? Not too cheesy, not too thin, not too saucy, jussst right! Love the memorabilia. Feels like home every time.
Marc Glucksman
Outstanding pizza, super friendly staff! Expect to wait 30 mins for take out pies on a busy night.
Jeffrey Cutler
Nothing bad can be said of this Pizzaria-- it's credentials go far beyond my measley review (and longer than I've been alive (I'm 42))
Super-thin, sauce on top, mix of mozzarella and provolone (for structure I think) this pizza comes out hot, crispy, and straight. A average adult can easily eat a large pie to themselves with enough hunger.
Never had a bad pie in 40 years. The rest of the menu also includes classics done Johnny's-only style (garlic bread to pastas)
The only problem you're gonna encounter is the line/wait.
If you get takeout be prepared to get that pie home ASAP-- JH0NNYS PIZZA EXPERIENCE IS SIGNIFICANTLY DIFFERENT OUT THE OVEN vs 10 PLUS DRIVE HOME-- what I would suggest is to arrive early get home quick
--You won't be disappointed--
Brian Baker
Been looking for the best pizza in south Westchester for awhile, and can confirm that this place is the real deal. My favorite by far. Everyone in there is super nice too. Whole pies only, cash only.
Jack MacLionel
Been eating Johnny’s pizza for more than 60 years. During the past couple of years, I too often am served a pie that is too crispy…it snaps like a cracker. In addition, too many pies now have little cheese and much sauce. As I said, been a Johnny’s fan for many years, but I feel the need to speak up so the high quality Johnny’s has maintained for many years will continue. Thank you.
Vito Conte
Delicious pizza!! One of the best I've ever had. Thin slices and the sauce tastes like perfection. Not a lot of room for parking though.
Belissa Ho
Really good pizza. I did not eat in so we don't know know the eating atmosphere. However parking wasn't great, but where in this area is it?
Giovanni Kelly
I’ve had pizza all over NY and all over the country. Still haven’t found one that matches up to this place. Perfect crust, perfect sauce, perfect cheese. It’s the reference for NY Pizza for me.
Asa C-J
Best pizza in Westchester if you like it thin with a lightly charred crust. Tasty desserts too.
Ferne
There pizza is the best. The thin crunchy crust the sauces flavor and the cheese work well together that you can’t stop eating it.
Mason Beresford
Best pizza of all times I drive two hours for this pizza.
Young Kim
Love this place... can't believe I grew up in Yonkers and never heard of this place...
Thank you Barstool Pizza Reviews... lives up to the hype.
David Hansberry
Top quality pizza, there’s a reason it gets such good reviews!
JEFFREY JOHNSON
Great pizza. Only Cash. No single slices. A bit pricey.
Fran Cutler
Pizza was one of best we ever had
Thin and crispy❣❣
Salad for three could have easily fed more
Kimberly Brown
Johnny's Pizzeria has some of the best pizza I've ever had and I'm born and raised in NYC so that's saying something. Everything is fresh! Delicious sauce, pepperoni that tastes handmade, and a nice crispy crust. Your plate will be empty in this place. We can't wait to go back for some of their entrees as everything we saw pass by our table looked so good. Plus the service was wonderful. We were taken care of for sure! Definitely a must if you're in/close to Mt. Vernon.
Kevin Khederian
Id rather go to a pizzeria that makes you a pizza when you order, rather than one that gives you excuses to why you cant get a pie the night you want one. Dont care how good is was at this point
Dan Livni
The pizza is amazing here. The dough and crust are crunchy and taste great. The mozzarella cheese taste very neutral and the pizza sauce is real good. They put grated mozzarella cheese on the pie. I get my pie without the grated mozzarella cheese.
Vinnie M
Some say this is the best pizza you can get. I eat a lot of pizza and this was okay. Johnny's pizza is more like a neapolitan, rather than NY pizza. Neapolitan pizza is better.
The restaurant could have gotten a 4 star review, had it not been for the 50 minute wait to get a table and then 70 minute wait for our pizza. Everyone in the dining area was waiting for their pizza, looking at perturbed as we were. The appetizers were also pretty bad. Garlic bread and fried hot peppers were not worth ordering. You can usually tell how good a pizzaria is by their garlic bread or knots..
U Knowme
I don't even know why they have a phone to take orders. They never answer the telephone I've been calling for 6 years no answer. But if you're looking for really good 🍕 look no further. Some of the Best 🍕 in 🌎 comes from this Building. TRUST ME! …
Joseph Massaro
I went to Johnny's with 2 friends wanting to try the pizza. I was not disappointed. No flop and crunchy.
chubbs mcghee
This place is always good. We had an extremely long wait today and it was worth every second! This place rocks! Best in NY in my humble opinion!
Tom
Pizza is the best in the area. Got mozzarella sticks as well
Will definitely be going back
Nellie Bee
Consistently good thin crust pizza.
Gerard Visser
Crispy and delicious. CASH ONLY!
You have to call early to get take out, it is completely worth the wait.
Eugene La Pia
This pizza is as close to authentic Italian pizza that is prepared IN ITALY, as you can get in the Westchester NY area.
It’s up there with Di Farra’s in Brooklyn.
I think it’s the simple quality of the ingredients and of course the way it’s prepared. You don’t get slices here - you order small pies. It’s cash only.
Enjoy and savor that crispy delicious pizza. It’s worth the trip.
Ziltoid
There regular pizza pie is the best in Westchester. The Grandma is also awesome. The meals are ok and personally feel they need more seasoning and spices. Parking is terrible.
Julie Vita
Fantastic pizza. All cash business and no slices but the pizza can't be beat. Family owned business still run by family members. Parking is tough especially during busy times but worth the little inconvenience. The thinnest crust pizza around. Live a little dangerously and try some toppings. You won't be disappointed.
Tashina Haywood
This was my first time patronizing this restaurant. The Pizza was delicious!!! The crust was thin, just the right amount of sauce and cheese. I would definitely return.
J A
Best pizza in Westchester county. Possibly best pizza in New York. Super Thin crust. I usually eat a small pie by myself.
Can't argue with Decades of happy customers. Cash only, no slices. ( Pies only) That's how you know it's good!
Rob G
Solid thinny thin. I think it's upside down, cheese to sauce. Long time family owned establishment. No slices, pies only!
Young ko
The pizza is thin and crisp. The bitterness and sweetness makes it the best. If you add basil on it you will have a 9.4
Connor Murphy
Spent the rest of the day remembering the amazing flavor / texture. Insanely good. Literally the best pie I’ve ever had. Thank God my mama wasn’t with me because I woulda smacked her it was so good.
Zachary B.
The best old school thin crust pizza around. I absolutely adore this place. Still Amazing I am re reviewing with a five star again. I absolutely love the staff and, pizza here. This is a must to check out if you are anywhere near Mt. Vernon the best cheese pie I've had In America. Eat inside as the ambience is really nice and, the pizza has to be ate fast.
Elisa Bruno-Midili
I am a pizza FANatic! This is the real thing. MUST GO, plain pie for sure!
Jordan Hahn
Pricey but excellent pizza. The white pie with eggplant may be my new favorite pizza in the world. Just remember that you can't get slices and must pay with cash and you'll feast like a king.
bernadette lovallo
Pizza is the best thin crust ever. No slices pies only and with garlic and cherry peppers you can't go wrong.
Emanuel Ndreu
Would totally go again and super affordable pizza for how good it was
Delfin Cintron
Great pizza! Definitely going back.
mari p
Lovely staff. Pizza Def needs more cheese and sauce needs more flavor. Great thin crust. Definitely NOT NYC pizza but Def more authentic Italian pizza.
Christopher Zacchi
Great pizza, fast service. Grandma pie could have used a touch more sauce for my taste.
Jeanne Kempton
So so good - similar to DeFarra in Brooklyn. Cash only and they get busy. Dine in is best as the crust is super thin and it cools off fast. Also their traditional house salad is great.
Anthony CIOPPA
We tried this joint after watching Portnoy give them a 9.1
I was hoping to be impressed and I WAS!
THIS PIZZA IS GREAT!
It lived up to the hype.
It's a thin, crisp crust, sauced on top but the sauce is kind of baked in with the cheese. It's not a watery sauce.
Totally DELICIOUS!
Overall, it was EXCELLENT!
Jean-Claude Santini
Super thin and crispy, my favorite pizza!
LJ
Place not easy to find...almost no place to park...Can't get anyone on the phone...they don't sell by the slice...they don't accept credit cards...small pie almost $19..inconveniences galore but for one thing...THE BEST pizza I have ever had in Westchester!!! I will be back again and often.
Jess Woolfe
My favorite pizza in the world. I have shed tears on my first bite. As soon as the pizza is ready I eat it in my car. It’s magical. I have waited 2.5 hours for this because it’s worth every minute. Do yourself the honor of indulging in a slice of heaven. You will not regret it!!!!
Jess the Blessed
CRISPY!!!!
I came across this place through Dave Portnoy’s Barstool review and when he said these slices were crispy, I had to come and try it myself. Thin and crispy crust are my go to.
Before coming, please note that this place is cash only and they do not sell by the slice. To be honest, that’s fine. You want the pie. You want more than one slice. They have dine in space which is a nice feel. They have two sides to their dining area. The locale has a ton of memorabilia of their past loved ones so it’s a very warm and welcoming spot. We didn’t dine in so my review is mostly on the service, taste and overall experience. Totally satisfied and I KNOW I want to come back, and will even bring my mom with me, another crispy slice fan so see you guys soon!
Anthony C
So, I lived in Mount Vernon for over three years. never once have I gone to Johnny’s pizzeria, until tonight. For an avg person that is looking for an overall pizza, this is the best pizza you’ll ever have. It’s not too thin, balance of cheese and sauce, and crispy in the right places. If you are looking for a nice greasy pizza, extra cheesy oozing everywhere, this isn’t the place. I am picky and love greasy pizza with big pepperonis lol. This place had super tiny pepperoni and I literally could eat the whole large pie with no struggle or even slight hesitation. Giving it 4 stars because my expectation was different, cash only, little parking and the lady on the phone was a little rushy. I get that though, they were super busy and I understand fast paced environments and how it can affect tone and give stress.
Fadi Khader
Hands down one of the best pizza I've ever had . Cooked perfectly . Amazing
Gern Blanston
This place makes their round pies with a killer thin & crispy crust. Interesting thing is they use sliced mozzarella which does melt differently than shredded, so you will notice the difference as you bite into it. Sauce is straight forward tomato (not sweet) with a touch of garlic powder & salt (at least I thought) with a light amount of olive oil drizzled along the top. Their grandma pie with "basil juice" about the same as round pie although sauce is "striped" along the top of a thicker cheesed square crust, also with good crisp. All in all, the pizzas are not heavy. You can have 2 to 3 slices and not feel weighed down at the end. Personally I wish the sauce had more flavor (sweeter tomatoes, oregano, sage, rosemary, et al) but still gets the job done. You still enjoy the pizza. 👍👍
Richie Zaccone
Best thin slices pizza you will ever find anywhere. if you don't believe me check out barstools review. Plus they have a great house salad!
Gucci
Hands down! This is the best pizza in NY. No one can beat these guys. Perfectly thin, not salty, not sweet just a perfect well crafted pie. I drive from the Bronx to Mt Vernon at least once a week for a cheese pie and chicken parm. Chicken parm is to die for. Our 9 year old daughter says this is the best and she is absolutely right! Call ahead, take the trip to Johnny’s.
M B
Cash only isn't the best, but it's worth it for the delectable cheese pizzas. Beware of roaming prices and ask for them in advance before ordering out.
Michael Borrelli
One of the best pizza places in the New York Metropolitan area. Amazing quality, taste, flavor, and crisp. Other menu items are great as well from pasta, to chicken dishes. But... the pizza has the crown and is absolutely to die for. Only downside to the restaurant is the waitresses are usually rude.
Dave Crunch
The Best Pizza Hands Down & I’ve had Pizza in all the 5 Boroughs , The House Salad and House Dressing is a Must Get and Don’t Forget to Order a Dish of the Chicken Ala Marie , If You are in the Area I highly Recommend this Pizza
Jay Reynolds
One of the best pizzas in Westchester county. Thin, crispy crust. Be forewarned... No individual slices and cash only. Gets busy. Be prepared to wait with a group larger than 4.
James Turley
Absolutely one of the best pizzas 🍕 I've ever had. The thin crust perfect. Recommend it extremely highly. …
Hooks Black coffee
One of the best Pizza pies i have ever had. The Italian dishes are delicious as well. The house dressing on the salad is outstanding and highly recommended.
The pizza isn’t as good the next day it’s a eat it while it’s hot pizza. Good old traditional pizza. I recommend plain.
A bit pricey but you get what you pay for. I’ll pay for good food any day.
Mike Ferrara
Everyone around here knows about Johnny's, the best pizza! My in-laws are from Queens and said this is the best pizza they've ever had. Even better than New Park on Cross Bay. And that pizza is also very good. That's a big compliment!
Chris NYCFastest
nothing special- small, paper thin pie, with little cheese, n little sauce- taste ok. I'd give it 6.9 n definitely not worth $20. I ate 7 slice till I felt satisfied, n I'm no fat obese slob, I usually eat 2 slices n I'm good. it's a $12 pie.
Eli Rivera
It's a little disappointing. The plain pizza wasn't good at all. There was no chewiness to the dough. I've had thin crust that had more bite to it. The service was super slow at half capacity. They were understaffed for sure.
Gary Costanza
We took the pizza home to Bryn mawr. It had cooled off. I think it would have been better to just eat in. The crust was thin the way I like it. I will have to give them another chance.
Nicole Nicole
Really, really good pizza that reminds me of the great classic way pizza was made when I was a child...customer service is superb....warm, friendly and attentive. Food makes it to the table fast. The only downside is how difficult it is to find parking, so be prepared for that. Eat the pizza on-site. It's so much better fresh out of the oven. Noticed that they even have gluten free pizza.
Pierluigi Castaldo
100% the best pizza in the Area of Westchester/Bronx. Simple plain pie is all you need, nothing more. Ranked 9.1 on the barstool scale for good reason.
Vin
Really glad we stopped here.
Pizza is so very different from everything else in NY.
Super crispy crust that tastes like a Thomas English muffin.
Devoured.
Eric Meyerson
Unique unforgettable pizza spot on Lincoln ave in Mount Vernon. A must try. Eat there not to go. Pizza doesn’t travel well. But one of the best slices you’ll ever have fresh. 2 people can easily eat a full pie slices are a little small and very thin but crazy delicious. MUST TRY
Charley Varipapa
This is the best pizza in the world. No matter what anybody says including barstool pizza guy who gave it a 9.1. I give it a 10. It is the benchmark for a good pizza as far as I’m concerned and I wish it was around the corner so I could eat it at least once a week instead of once or twice a year
Larry Bruno
Got a regular pie and a Grandma pie. Both pies were great. Was charged $45. They either need to update the website menu or they robbed me.
Brian Sturm
Excellent pizza with good sauce
Adam Corrigan
Best pizza I've ever had. Thin and crispy. This is authentic. Sauce is perfect. Pies only so bring a friend, although you might be able to finish a pie on your own, since it's so good. Appetizers are great too. Only negative is that they only accept cash. Everywhere in the world accepts cards nowadays so they should get on board. I'm sure they lose a lot if business just because of this alone.
Edgardo V.
I've had a ton of pizza all over NY/NYC. What else do you eat being raised in Queens? There's a lot of good pizza around. But Johnny's makes some "damn good" pizza. I enjoyed every crispy bite I had here. My wife and I (mostly me) finished a large pie b/w the 2 of us. I highly recommend going and eating here or fresh as I don't think pizza travels well.
Frankie C
It's famous but if that pizza ist real hot it's not real good so order 1 pie at a time you will love it
CA170
Best pizza I've ever had, hands down!
John Amato
As reliable as ever. The thin crust pizza with a legendary sauce. Just enough cheese to wow your test buds. The salad served family style crisp with a light dressing to complement your pizza. Attentive service with a smile.
tom paradiso
"This is the best pizza I've ever had" said my 6 yo son as he reached for his 4th (!!!) slice of pie.
I agree with his conclusion.
Light, crispy, not too cheesy with just the right amount of sauce. Every bite had an audible crunch. Not sure how anyone could improve on their pizza.
Niq Silva
One of Westchester's best pizza joints
YourMom VotedForBiden
Outstanding pizza and service!! The one star reviews in a sea of five stars should tell you everything you need to know about the reviewer. This will be some of the best pizza of your life.
C H
No parking! The biggest turn off in the world. My mother says this is the best pizza ever!! Original from Third Street and Fourth Avenue in Mt. Vernon, it has feed thousands of families over the years with great thin crust pizza and southern Italian cooking. Cozy Italian style restaurant. Like home cooking. All types of pizzas. Great salads. Pizzaria and restaurant. Wide selection of foods. Family owned for generations. Rated very high. Decent place. Parking is difficult. Cordial staff. Go during the week. The place gets jammed. Moderately priced. Desserts are good too. It is worth a trip with the family. CASH ONLY!
kathleen SUAREZ
Small restaurant located in a sort of alley way next to a gas station. Not visible when driving by. Limited menu choices. Had the regular pie, which you can only buy pies, not slices. Also had a side of meatballs and pasta fagioli soup. Pizza crust is paper thin with many burnt spots, so it's not a common pizza taste. I enjoyed it. Didn't care for the meatballs although they said they make them fresh theirselves. Soup was good but they used larger pasta. Staff was very pleasant. I walked there so didn't I pay attention to the parking situation. Not much street parking since it's on busy W Lincoln Ave. I believe it's cash only.
MDJAK
I’ve been a customer and fan of Johnny’s for many years, eating there a few times a year for the past 20 plus years. Last night just wasn’t that good. The pies were lukewarm at best. The salad was good as usual.
But, I ask you, should 2 pies, one plain, one with sausage, a salad for 5, and 6 cans of soda cost $80? The prices there are just off the charts. For thin crust pizza with barely any cheese, very little sauce, and even fewer sausage on one pie? Me thinks not. In any normal pizza shop, the bill would be half that.
Paul DeBiase
"This is the best pizza hands down". I live in Hawthorne and was introduced to Johnny's Pizza at a very young age by my family that owns a business in Mt. Vernon for over 30 years. I've been to every so call pizza spot in The Tri-State area there really is nothing better it's depressing. My relatives from Italy say it's better than some places back home but there other places in Italy that are better. I don't understand how that can be possible it's that addictive, so good that I can't imagine something else that my taste buds can handle from pizza.
They are very nice people. To all those that say they are rude because they know there pizza is the best, NOT TRUE. You try running that mad house with all those orders when it gets busy and make sure the pizza comes out perfect every time. My suggestion is if you are looking to feed your cravings and/or addiction of Johnny's try getting there during the day like on a Tuesday or Wednesday with a small party each get a pie, eat and get out or put your order in way in advance so when you get there it's ready to go just be on time. Because you also want it hot and it will just becoming out of the oven, TRUST ME they don't play around with that. It's all apart of the Johnny's experience.
Paul N
Pizza was excellent, large pie finish by two. Nice thin crispy crust with the perfect combo of sauce and cheese. Only issue I see is parking...it's very limited. Don't let that stop you though.
FUTURE SOLDIER
I was on my own and my first time here. They had me wait at least 30 mins for a small pie. People who came after me got served before me. Waitress kept walking past me without acknowledging the elephant in the room. It was exhausting. The pizza was different and good.
spanbeauty35
We live over an hr away but wanted to try this place out. It was amazing! Chicken cutlet sandwiches and spicey chicken were great! The burgers were great! The pizza was delish! Definitely will be returning.
Anthony Lombardo
I was on hold for exactly 20 minutes and 46 seconds before being hung up on...however before being hung up I heard life stories, customer stories, stories...you couldn't even imagine...stories that I dare not say over the phone...pizza was pretty good, it's just a shame I had to call, be on hold for 20 minutes with no result, drive there for another 15 mins, hangout for another 30 minutes for a pizza. If the services gets better, then your good
mango madness
Probably the best pizza I every had,must eat it there,it's good when you bring it home it'd better when eaten hot
Absolute Entertainment
I was having pizza in Brooklyn at a place called DiFara's which is World known. It is some of the best pizza in the country. A woman stopped me and told me that if I wanted even better Pizza that I should try Johnny's in Mount Vernon. I admit I was skeptical. Difara's is the standard by which all others is measured. Johnny's is the best pizza I have had outside of Brooklyn. Thin crust regular pie is awesome. The Char will make your mouth water for days. I would give it 10 Stars if I could.
Jill Kevorkian
Easily the best pizza I have ever had. Gets kinda crowded. We went around 4 and got a table instantly.
Craig Lang
don't go here for pizza, think of an Italian pie. Thin crisp crust, cheese and sauce on top. Absolutely delicious. Don't go if your in a hurry, its very busy on a Saturday night, parking is difficult in that area, but it's well worth it. I will go again.
Kat
Worth the wait!! We were rookies on this visit to Johnny's and only ordered a pie. What we should have done was start with the house salad because the wait for the pizza was lonnnnggggg. We waited about 45 mins for our Original Pie (Christian's Favorite) and wanted to eat our arm off. Definitely a delicious pie but remember to order an appetizer in the meantime.
Salil Mehta
Awesome pizza. Thin and crsipy
Karen Lindsay
Absolutely delicious pizza! Definitely recommend this place. Perfection!
Mark Hirsh
This is a unique place. No slices, cash only, closed Sun & Mon, and for 2 weeks in the Summer, barely smiling waitresses, yet crowded all the time. Why? It's Pizza like you get in Italy, with very slight Americanization. I imagine that this is what Pizza was like when this place opened in the 1940's. It's thin but still chewy, with just the right amount of char, and absolutely delicious.
I split a large with my son and we finish it. That's how thin and good it is, and we try other places and always say "good, but not as good as Johnies' (except for one place in Arezzo, Tuscany, but that's another story)
Not much else worth eating, maybe a soup or basic salad. Go for the Pizza. You'll be hooked.
David Schwartz
I travel all across the country and love Pizza I can’t believe it took me 34 years to find this place it’s hands down the best!!! Extra Cheese Well Done
Thomas Barr
Amazing pizza! A pie is perfect for lunch for two! The atmosphere is very authentic and the staff is always on top especially during busy hours. Would definitely recommend this local hotspot!
Bbqdoc
Real pizza and real people !!!
Happy 80th anniversary!!
Eli Alexander
Amazing pizza!! I would have to say that this is the best pizza in Mt. Vernon hands down. Great atmosphere a great friendly staff it is busy now and then but it is well worth the wait. If you are in the area you should try them out.
Gianmarco D'Emilia
Been going here since I was a baby and still never disappoints. Been so consistent throughout the years. I usually just get a regular pie and the house salad. The house salad dressing is my favorite but they won't tell me what it is.
David Dowling
I drive almost an hour from queens to have this pizza . I eat it in the car as soon as I get it so it’s nice and hot and crispy . No better pizza in New York if you ask me .
JP Loingsigh
The cheese pizza is by far my favorite. It really blows any other place away. I don't want my pizza dressed up with things that are going to take away from the basic deliciousness. Give it a shot, you'll be hard pressed to find better.
P N
Just a outstanding pizza place. Line out the door good. If your a pizza lover and in Mount Vernon you better add this to your list.
Parking is limited, friendly service, plenty of seats.
Robert Martino
Insanely good pizza that's better than anything I've tried in the 5 boroughs (besides di fara that's the best in the state. But this, this is close to it) if you're visiting NYC take the extra steps and come him for some good goo!
Jess Wade
Excellent Pizza..so Delicious
Squid Cena
Super delicious pizza, very good pizza that I haven't had in a long time. It seems that 75+ years of experience makes really really great pizza.
Melissa Fiorello
Simply unmatched. Hands down the best pizza, food & staff anywhere. We travel an hour to meet up with friends who travel over an hour from Jersey & CT, just for our Johnny's fix!
Jim Blinn
Based on a survey of pizza restaurant reviews, we decided to order out from Johnny's. It was really good and worth the drive to get here.
Michael Giordano
Love this pizza. One of the best in Westchester! Always thin and crispy and always consistant. The other food is good too but they are known for the delicious pizza. I've seen other people say that the service is bad and the servers are rude however this was never my experience. They are always polite and friendly to me. I highly reccomend trying Johnny's. It's a must if your in the area. Parking sucks and they are closed Sun. & Mon., cash only.
Larry N
Finally had a chance to eat here. Brought some out of town guests for NY pizza experience. Turned out to be a great choice. Cool hole in the wall atmosphere and excellent pizza. Will return.
Eddie M
THE best pizza, hands down!
Mark A. Flower
Thin crunchy crust, nice balance of cheese, sause and herbs.
Does not sell pizza by the slice so don't ask.
Cash Only!
Bet you can't eat just 1 slice.
Alan Wu
If you want to eat out but trust it like your moms kitchen, this is the place. Cleaner than any kitchen I have ever seen.
Everything is real, it's fresh and made the old fashioned way.
Be aware, this it the real deal. No slices. No credit Cards. No Delivery.
Closed Sunday and Monday. ITS WORTH EVERY MINUTE!!
Nicholas Corrado
This is hands down, the best pizza I've ever had. My Dad grew up in Mount Vernon and once in a while, I drive from Long Island (appx. 45 minutes away), with EZ-Pass in hand, just to get a pie from here.
Tlocs28
Hands-down the best pizza in the Northeast
jose rodriguez
The Food was Great, but the Service was Horrible.. We Waited 35 minutes to get our Pizza. Meanwhile people who sat down after us were Served there Food b4 us..
Drea Molina
Prepare your self for a phenomenal slice of thin pizza. An experience but no slices just pies. Makes sense since you can't have just one slice!
Anthony Defalco
Some of the best pizza you can find. Easily one of the top 3 best pizzas I've eatin. Seriously amazing food. Unfortunately enough it is in a truly terrible area, and the parking lot is tiny, and very difficult to pull out of.
JAMES THOMPSON
Pros: Excellent thin crust pizza, good entrees and nice staff
Cons: no slices, Cash only, which is a disservice to is loyal customers and only open tuesday-saturday.
Elizabeth Ramos-Boyce
Just had dinner here after seeing the review on Verizon Fios Restaurant Hunter with Rob Petrone. THE PIZZA WAS GREAT! I’m raised in the Bronx moved to Yonkers over 20 years ago so I’m always on the hunt for great pizza spots.....AND THIS IS GREAT PIZZA. 🤗💕😝❤️💗 Thin crust that cracks when you fold your slice. DEFINATELY a hidden gem in Mount Vernon.
Ben
Hands down best pizza in Mt. Vernon and can hold it’s own against the best pizza from any borough
Cash only
Mabel G
We've been coming for a few years now and we drive an hour for Johnny's. Love it. Nothing compares. Pizza tastes like it's made in brick oven. Thin and crispy.
marie bumonte
Hands down the best pizza in New York. Forget the city, come a little bit north for the best thin crust pizza. Only negative is cash only and no slices.
Alberto Rosario
The best pizza ever had..
Kenneth Mcdevitt
This place is supposed to be a temple fir pizza. It was good but ill.take a NYC slice anyway. Mount Vernon just a little behind
Mark Reiff
Best Pizza in Westchester hands down. Go pure with the plain pie. Food is also good, but pizza is the main attraction. Staff goes put of their way to make sure you get what you want.
Angie Giannikios Dallas
I looooove Johnnies. Excellent super flat pizza. I deducted star bc they do not have it written that they drizzle peanut oil on pizza. THAT'S GREAT but with the excessive allergies they should be specific about that and not just a handwritten sign that says tell us if u have allergies.
wayne rozanski
Probably the best pizza in Westchester. Cheese below the sauce was on point. Crust was paper think and very good crunch! Loved the Yankee memorabilia.
Tim Rhodes
This is the NY style pizza other NY pizzerias try to be. They don't even come close! Johnny's is absolutely the BEST.
Anonymous Reviewer
The pizza is amazing but they need to have a more modern system for taking orders. It seems like they just leave the phones unplugged when they are busy.
Luke Benjamin
The pizza is amazing but the customer service is horrible. The lady on the phone who takes the order is incredibly rude. Because they are so well know, they think they can treat people in any manner that they want...However the pizza is great! If you can get past the bad attitudes.
Tyler Reilly-Evans
Pizza is fantastic. Thin and crispy crust, with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Great flavor. Best pizza in the area!
Richard Rikk Angelori (Rikk)
If you like pizza 🍕. Wait, let me rephrase that. If you LOVE pizza, you need to try Johnny's. A better pizza in NY you will not find!! …
Oliver McIntyre
If you are ever in Mount Vernon you must visit Johnny’s. The thin and crispy pizza is truly delightful. I highly recommend this place.
Nick Beaton
I’ve made this a weekly spot and think about it daily. Pizza is that good. You won’t find pizza like this anywhere else!!!! Soooo thin, crispy, Umami, consistent...just get the plain and savor it.
Eddie Rojas
Johnnys pizza is amazing. Used to go here a lot when i was a kid but now i live in NJ so every now and then we make the trip to Mount Vernon for some Johnnys. Worth the drive and tolls
Cesar Blanco
Very good old style pizza. Meatball park was to die for. If you are in the Westchester area def worth a visit. Has the old vintage style pizzeria and FYI they only take cash
Shaneale BeYOUtiful
Came here to eat by myself and ordered a lil small pizza and it was HUGE!! I can’t imagine the large pizzas lol.... Great food overall though! Definitely recommend it!
Alejandro Lopez
Great pizza. One pie with a co-worker hit the spot. good service. Also had to take out Chicken Francese and it was great. Cash only and closed on Sunday. Too bad, but great food.
Clara Carabotto
I absolutely love their pizza! make sure you bring cash
Zachary Barden
The best old school New York pizza very delicious crispy cracker thin crust. Cheese and sauce is flipped sauce out cheese under
Martin Millman
Johnny's has been in Mt. Vernon for an incredible 70 years! I have been shlepping there from Astoria, Queens for almost 30 years. Forget about "famous" NYC pizza. Trust me, Johnny's is the finest thin-crust pizza you will ever eat.
Kylene Thompson
Best Pizza can't believe i never had it before. Definitely a best
Douglas Francis (49erBockers)
Neighborhood pizza parlor that sells by the pie. An old school flair and family friendly establishment. The pizza is ok. Again, everybody in this neighborhood swears by this pizza probably because they grew up on it.
Betsy Sutton
Best pizza hands down..Hometown feel with smiling staff. I love the whole experience..
neostefanides
One of my top 3 pizza places! Amazing! It is an upside down style and I love it!
Ma Dukes
I'm not Italian and we purchase a pie once a week sometimes 2 times for the week..we also had other things on the menu and equally as delicious as the pies..I truly wish they were open 7 days a week..
Lisa Ortiz
Delicious Pizza! They are celebrating 75 years in business. I've heard so many good things about this place and I'm glad I finally got to try!!
Nigel Snowdon
Best pizza in westchester. Hands down. Just be prepared to wait well over an hour for pick up on Friday/Saturday nights.
Cristina Conciatori
Love the pizza here. I wish I lived closer because I would go here more often. It's a small, cash only, hole in the wall type place. If you go on a weekend night you will probably have to wait a bit, but it's worth it!
Benjamin Beruh
Best crust on a pie I've had in a long time
Dan Hammond
Best pizza I have ever had. I got a large pepperoni pie & a grandma pizza. Fantastic
Sylvia Santified
Pizza was very good slices are thin. Only thing you have to buy the whole pie. I don't see where they sell a slice.
Christopher Pavesi
Fire
B
hands down best pie in New York been going here my whole life. Family owned and operated by the pie only.
Barbara Picaso
The best pizza my husband and I have ever had! The problem with having it, is other pizza pales in comparison. Go early and expect to wait. The wait is worth it!👍 …
Stanley Shih
Favorite pizza in the world. Unfortunately closed on Sundays. The pizza here loses something when it's delivered, so definitely dine-in. One large pie serves two.
Mike R
Best pizza in the world. I've been coming here for 40 years and I've yet to find better in all my travels (and I travel a lot!).
Jack Kantor
I have yet to find a better pizza pie. I wish they were open on more days, but it's a small price to pay for the best pizza around.
thabadd One
Ordered a medium pizza pie and the crust and sauce was good
Lost on start for lack of cheese..it was sparse. Almost like a cheeseless pizza but it wasn't.
Carolyn Groccia
I love going to Johnny's its always a favorite! The pizza is the best in Westchester, its thin and crispy. It's honestly the best pizza you will eat!
Raymond O'Hara
FABULOUS dinner tonight service was out of sight
leon Gjoni
They have one of the BEST tasting pies in all of NY! It's always on my rotation for great pizza.
Christopher Doyle
Best pizza I've had in the area since moving to Yonkers four years ago. Almost new haven quality.
Kelly Marchena
Best pizza I've had in a long time!!
Michael Brannon
Excellent (very) thin crust pizza. Definitely as good as advertised. Tough to find parking though so be prepared.
Mike M
Great crust, light but flavorful sauce and good cheese, you can tell they use a real hot oven. Amazing crust.
James Watson
I have been going to Johnny's Pizzeria for over 30 years. I live in the Bronx and travel to this pizzeria in New Rochelle 30 West Lincoln Avenue when I want the best pizza in the New York area.
Jared kreiner
Best Pizza in NY hands down.
Joshua Subin
Been going since I was a young child. It is an institution and simply the best pizza around.
aramis gaston
absolutely incredible pizza....every bite has a perfect crunch like....it’s just, wow
Kevin Holland
Nice pie, great crust...nice place wish the parking was better
ltaveras14
One of the best tasting pizza in town. But dont expect expect the same in the customer service.
Merve Arici
One of the best in NY! Everything about the pizza was just amazing.
Marcus Gonzalez
Best pizza in mount Vernon and probally one of the best in Westchester love their salads and pizza
John “Daydreamer” s
Been eating pizza here for over four decades never been disappointed have the right approach to Italian pizza a little bit of a weight always worth the trip
Michael Giuliano
Best pizza in the world, and a wide variety of Italian dishes. Food is top notch, wait staff is on point, and the price is very reasonable.
Josh Williams
One of the Best Pizza’s I’ve had in NY over the past 30 Years living! Can’t wait to come back!
Charles Slater
Old style thin crust pizza. Delicious. Only issue is parking
Scott Eddy
Great food...Better people...
Frank Letizia
Best pizza I've ever had. Literally nothing like it
Ari Loren
A true gem. The best pizza in Westchester without a doubt. Maybe even in all of NY. It's just that good.
Marta Okeefe Pineda
It's "sit anywhere"...I go in between busy times so I always go, sit, and enjoy the VERY BEST pizza!
I live in TN. now and when I come home. Right off the plain and straight to, Johnny's
Ignazio Leone
Best pizza i have eaten in a long time. Very family oriented
Patrick Kavanagh
Fantastic thin crust pizza, the staff treats you like family, looking forward to going back soon.
Robert Fleming
Best thin crust pizza in Westchester. Always a go to place to eat when in Mount Vernon.
George Lee
Thin crust perfection. Family owned.
Bethany Leddy
It's Johnny's no words necessary!
Princess Di
Best pizza in the world....love this place my favorite is the chicken parm w/linqini garlic and oil...ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS
glen dubie
Best pizza ! If you like thin crust and I mean thin!! this is the place for you🍕enjoy. …
Mattie *
Amazing pizza, charming staff, a classic place with a Gluten free crust option that I loved.
Vincent 59
The best pizza ever. Waited 2 hrs for 2 pies to go, well worth the wait!
Pier Cas
Amazing thin crust Pizza!
Annette “Toni” Chrystal
The best pizza not only in town, but in the entire state of New York. Thin and so sweet.
Lisa C
Great pizza. Crispy thin crust. The entire staff greets you coming and going.
JaneAnn Tobin
Fantastic! The pizza was just awesome! Can't wait to go back and try their linguine with clams
C Chez
Fantastic crispy crust pizza. Worth the drive from Queens!
lorenza VALENTI
I don’t know why people think so highly of this place, the pizza tastes like cardboard unless you eat in the minute you get it, I do not recommend it, if you know what pizza is supposed to taste like
Annette Gabriel
Long wait on a Saturday night... but simply delicious pizza... Thinnest crust around!
Chris Ramsey
Really good pizza, friendly staff, decent prices, would definitely go back
Emma Blauvelt
Love the food, and the Family!! And, they just got Westchester Magazine's award for the best pizza in the County!!!
Marty Tankleff
One or the best pizza places I have ever been.
Jordan Uffer
Really good pizza, good but very very very slow service. Almost impossible to go during your lunch hour
Shannon Byrne
Unbelievable, thin crust plain cheese ridiculous, white fantastic, a new pizza "the grandma" square thin, white pizza, hint of red sause, basil drizzle. OMG! Oh and the sausage crazy.
Sonia Rodriguez
Pizza was burnt but ok the seating were too near to each other people behind were literally yelling at each other while be seated next to each other!!
gary l. graham
Best pizza in NY.! A "required" stopover when anytime in the area.
samson jacobson
This is hands down some of the best pizza in all of New York. Johnny’s gives the best pizza joints in NYC some great competition.
Ted Amoruso
Been coming for over 50 years. The best pizza on the planet!
Roberto Rank7
My Condolences AND RESPECT to the family of Johnnys Pizza.....RIP
BEEN GOING TO JOHNNYS SINCE I WAS A KID GROWING UP IN MT VERNON in the 1960s......best pizza in the world.
Simons Lorenzo
Best Pizza hands down in the country. Crust is the best. Really everything is the best.
JD Scanlon
Simply the best thin crust Pizza you can get! And the staff are great too!
Kobe Alomary
Johnny’s speaks for itself, go check them out and be ready to have some darn good pizza. Love coming to this place.
Ruth Harris
Best thin crust in New York. A family favorite whenever we are in lower Westchester.
enrico gargano
Go for the NY style pizza 🍕. No thrills service but the best NY style thin crust I ever had since I moved to NYC in 2000 …
Paul Tano
Incredible as always! Moved away three years ago. Drove an hour today to go there. Well worth the trip!
Nicky Mirks
Some of the best pizza around
Maximiliano Zayas
The pizza is delicious and staff is friendly
Reid Banton
Classic pizza. Way to busy and took forever but worth the wait
John Colandro
Pizza review time easy 9 .2
Otto Pamps
Best pizza in the world and I'm not exaggerating... There is no better pizza any where.
Sagar Setru
Truly authentic NY style pizza. Probably the best I've ever had
John D
A fine example of thin crust (Manhattan?) style NY pizza; reminds me of the Nanuet Hotel in Rockland.
Nino Sidari
We love Johnny's! Always a treat when we get to eat the World's best pizza!
Richard King
Decent pizza other food is just ok...closed Sunday and Monday small parking lot
Charlotte Busa
Hands down the best pizza in USA.
Joseph Arcara
It's hard to find a better thin crust pizza. The best around. Melts in your mouth.
Nicholas Mastrogiorgio
My favorite pizzeria since I was a little kid. Best thin crust pizza I ever had.
Joseph pallandino
My favorite pizzeria. I love Johnny's Pizza
Dominic J Annese
Amazing experience, i came all the way from Florida and was not disappointed. Fantastic service, Amazing Pie, Wonderful People.
C C
Best thin crust in Westchester. On par with Da Fara Brooklyn
Bad Milli
Best pizza ive ever had. Honestly.
Mike Bellofatto (METAL MIKE)
The best thin crispy crust I've ever had in the area.
Nora Berger
Best thin crust pizza anywhere. NY pizza FTW.
Cash only
Michele
The best thin crust pizza around. Family atmosphere.
Darrell Tuttle
Overrated. Pizza is good but not great. All the other food is adequate at best.
Carlos Marte
Best pizza I ever had love going to this pizzeria
You should try it
Todd Hembury
Best pizza I've ever had!
Ralph Vasquez
Great pizza.... No slices just pies
Michael Cronin
El Pres was not lying. Awesome pizza......
Christina mabry
I loveeeee this pizza and the guys who make it are really sweet this is the best pizza hands down .
Maria Di
Love this place. Not the greatest of food but pizza is yummy.
John Goodmen
If you like thin crust pizza, this is the best you can get. Two people can crush a large pie.
Ben Hider
AMAZING!!! This place could not be any better. PERFECT pizza. Love the place
Rei Lem
100% worth the drive from Queens, great pizza
Evan Kent
Food is excellent. Service leaves much to be desired.
William Peckholdt
First time at Jonny, liked the thin crust pizza Friendly atmosphere also
Mark
Best pizza around but the service is awful
Francesca Haverkost
Love Johnny's Pizza but I like it with extra cheese most people don't most people consider it a sacrilege LOL
Paul Clemente
Some slow service issues in an otherwise not so busy restaurant. Pizza was great as usual though
Michael Lillils
Best Pizza in Westchester
Trish Larkin
Great pue! Thin crust with sauce on top of cheese - delish!!!
Matish Doci
Really good it should be more pizzas like this around here. that's the real pizza 👍👍👍👌🙋♂️ …
Harvey Maisel
59 years and counting. That's how long I've been eating here. Best pizza, bar none.
Andy G
Best thin crust pizza in westchester. 10/10.
Michael Belsole
Great "Bronx" pizza. Check when they are open. No slices. Cash only
salvatore dimatteo
The mecca for pies, service is lacking, but as long as the pizza tastes this good, ill keep eating it...
Fireman Trips914
Best Pizza in Westchester! Not up for Debate
Akbar Matin
Salad and pizza amazingly delicious. Good service. Cash only.
Zaire_GMZ
Pizza is very delicious and a good place to eat at for lunch.
75thrangersabn
The best in the U S A. Airbornealltheway
Vince
Very Nice thin Pizza I ate a whole pie myself
Levi Rosenberg
My girlfriend makes me drive an hour to get this pizza once a week. No jokes.
Merikhay Rabiyev
Best pizza in Westchester thin crust and great sauce on the pizza
Philip Roche
Always a great classic pizza!!
Cindi Rodriguez
The pizza is the best! My favorite place to go!
Michael Olivier
Best pizza in Westchester. Hands down!! Have to eat there !
Brett Humeston
Great pizza and atmosphere!
Dick Wolf
OMFG it's great closed Sunday packed sat sometimes long wait but it's well worth it call way before I can be there is my strategy
Samir Hosin
Pizza is not normal !!!! Not sure if they use sauce or crack ( amazing )
Chevy Bee
Yummy pizza but even better customer service
Bianca Lee
Amazing pizza and the staff was super pleasant
Aaron Bacchus
Amazing pizza..well worth the hype !
Dahyah Casiano
The service is great. The food is delicious , everyone there is friendly. A great place to chill and enjoy great food.
Robert DeEttore
Been going there since I was old enough to walk, with my parents and siblings. It is as good now, as it was 63 years ago.
Carmelo Martinez
good pizza, but worst service i have ever seen.
Vilma Alves
Best Pizza in town.
Come over and try it yourself.
Michael Radonis
Best pie in NY, if the US
Hannah Wieder
best pizza on planet earth.
Daniel Torres
The pizza is amazing and the employees are very nice people
kimberly brown
Best ever
Sheila Frazier
The best pizza ever, that's why they are celebrating 75 years!!!!
Lana Ordell
Go to spot for the best pizza
Ross Morgan
I love this place! Not too doughy, nice thin slices!
M. Alex Corrales
Finest pizza in New York. All ingredients are fresh and delicious.
Richard Gonzalez
Great tasting, you pay for what you get, but could use more parking.
Cori Chambers
Terrific pizza. Terrific service.
M R
Best pizza ever? Maybe!
fonz v
Server was really nice and pizza was awesome! Sucks no credit or debit
Paul Gherardi
Great pizza. A place to go out of the way for!
Louis Balsamo
Good pizza . Very little cheese and small pie but good.
tommy fava
Simply the BEST pizza anywhere
Rafael Ferrer
All positive best thin crust pizza!!!
Philip T
Great pizza. Not fast. Cash only.
Steve Raivio
Go there every time I am in New York. Old style Italian pizza 😁 …
Charles Severo
It's just the best pizza I ever tasted !
Morgan Saunders
Awesome let me it family place every time my family goes they say usual and that's what we get.
Mark J Ragone
Great pizza...
propackage
By far, the best pizza I have ever eaten
Layna F
The best pizza ever!
Sidney Brown
Moved upstate 3 years ago. They haven't missed a beat, still the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jose Gonzalez
Great pizza omg tasty thin crust!!!
Eben Thurston
Can't make pizza much better than this place.
Thomas White
Grew up here, best pizza in the U.S.A.
legendenomlegendenjohanfalk
9.1 everybody knows the rules. World class.
Anthony Luceveloche
Awesome Amazingly thin tasty crust pizza !!!!!
Donna Amiano
The best pizza in the world I can inhale the sauce
Robert Marano
Every time we come to NY from Vegas, we stop at Johnny's Pizzeria first! Get the salad and the pizza with a beer!
Joseph G
Cash only. Amazing pizza.
Cliff Bates
The best pizza in Westchester.
debbie winters
Love Johnny's. Great food and good service
Joshua Cohen
My family has been going to Johnny's for over 40 years. It's the best.
Cyril Moore
Fantastic old school pizza.
Pat Hayes
Best pizza in Westchester. Hands down.
Stan Farber
Hands down, the best pizza in New York. Anyone who disagrees should be deported
Dan Reese
The BEST pizza in NY!
Joe Munoz- adspinmedia
Oh my God Chinese is the best pizza hands down
Gabby Diogo
One of the very best pizza places!
Qu. One
Cannot go wrong here. Parking can be difficult, but we'll worth it.
Victor Pena
Great Pizza!!! Consistently great for years!!!
AceMurdera 911
Nice place. Best pizza around the area
Chris Vignogna
Don't listen to any of these losers with one star reviews they are low IQ dumbos
Geremi Santos
***R.I.P***
Maria Piscopo ... I WILL ALWAYS COME BACK TO THIS PLACE.. GREAT PIZZA BY FAR!!!!
David Sabagh
Best pizza in the area!!! Cash only!
Matt Ayers
Great Pizza, Great service!
Anthony Bruni
Simply the best pizza in Westchester.
John Dilinger
Racist...but the food top notch...if ur other than white or itAlin get it to go!
JOSHUA MAZZETTI
Excellent pizza and excellent staff.
Jonathan Watnick
The best.
jonathan castillo
Wow the pizza here was phenomenal.
Jonathan San
Great pizza. Highly recommended.
Nick Minervino
Great Pizza, better then 5 🌟 …
Jorge Ponce
One of the very best pizza ever
Jeff Petrone
The best. Don't forget your cash!
Yira Mercedes
Amazing pizza
howard feigenbaum
This is the pizza you get in your car and travel miles and miles for!
Shaz M
The hype is more, we were expecting out of this world experience
Michael DiNuzzo
Are they open for pick up right now? Anyone know the hours?
Alex Delgado
Great Pizza, excellent service
Eve Lee
No such thing as bad pizza!
Zeynep Parlak
Delicious and original. I loved the atmosphere here.
Robert Cohen
Nothing to say, you want pizza, this is the place and then, there is everyone else
Laura
Best pizza but bring cash!
Matt Pam
Best thin crust pizza.
Gerald Goblirsch
Great well balanced Pie
Damon Warley
The best pizza in Mt Vernon NY
Jarek Oses
Best pizza in Mount Vernon !
Lou Ocasio
Simply the best pizza in NY.
Phyllis Facendo
Always fabulous. THEY ARE MY EXTENDED FAMILY..OX🥂 …