Reviews of Catania's Pizzeria. (Restaurant) in Yonkers (New York).

Catania's Pizzeria

173 Reviews

93 Comments

Restaurant

Pizza restaurant

2260 Central Park Ave, Yonkers, NY 10710, United States

Description

Information of Catania's Pizzeria, Restaurant in Yonkers (New York)

Discover the opening times, the location, contact, popular times, photos and real reviews by internet users.

This place has a very good rate, they treat their customers well and you’ll feel welcome, super recommended

Map

Reviews of Catania's Pizzeria

Blue Flames

They don't treat you very well unless your white. If they have a problem with people of color they should hang a banner outside "WHITE PEOPLE ONLY" Funny one person working behind the counter is dark skinned. Wonder how he got there. Unless he's Sicilian. They don't have a problem with that but his skin is still darker than mine. Bonkers how people treat one another just for the skin color. WHERE ALL THE SAME ONLY DIFFERENCE IS YOUR ATTITUDE NEEDS TO CHANGE OR GO SOMEWHERE ELSE! Your in New York where all migrates come from including your self. Just because your white doesn't make you better then me. Trust me I bet I have more money in my account yet I'm still more down to earth than where you came from! Now down to the food it's great but here and there these people have attitudes for no reason. I wish it would change

o g

Was recommended by a friend, I order a few cheese calzones, crust is crispy and it was good. The only down side is they charge for sauce. Like really? A spot known for calzones and they wont give you any, at least for the cheese one- i understand if they have chicken parm or other fillings dont need sauce. Its like going to get fries and they charge you for ketchup, going for wings and you have to pay for ranch/blue cheese. Anyways undecided if i will go back.

J A

Consistently great pizza but ordered chicken parm pizza today…it was just a regular pie with some diced chicken cutlet thrown on top… so disappointing, would not send it out if I were in the kitchen.

Christopher Layug

Always go there for the salad pizza, had to get a slice to go. Highly recommended.

Stephen Camadeco

Hadn't ordered from Catania's in quite a while and it's better than previous. Larger selections, huge portions, excellent food and very fast delivery. Will be back!

chanetta garner

Pizza is amazing,they have a lasagna slice that makes you feel like you are in heaven. Great place,great atmosphere

Ann Hildreth

Wow. Just like the old days . Meatball calzone , cheese, just like when I grew up. . Wow it's doooo very good. I think the tables got smaller lol They could have been any nicer. Old school. It’s nice to have a staple like this .

concierge pt

My go-to joint whenever im in Yonkers. Classic. Traditional no-frills pizza that is my favorite in the area

mike ryan

Excellent pizza, some of the best in the area. Highly recommend it. Sicilian pizza is great.

se SG

best salad pizza!!!! awesome. garlic bread like of base and stack of spinach and tomato, onion and mushrom with oil and venegar dressing. no cheese no baked no tomato sauce.

sabrina

Its the calzones for me! AMAZING, Mouth watering, and packed with flavor.

Christina Geba

Amazing place. Get the 20$ Sicilian Every time, and it’s consistently amazing. Keep it up guys!

Nestor Encarnacion

Great slices and Sicilians. Finally a place with a decent size slice and great cheese. Affordable prices and great staff. I grab something every week while I’m at work. Definitely recommend!!

Douglas Caridi

I was introduced by a god friend about 10 years ago who grew up around the corner from Catania’s. He told me he’d been going there since he was a kid (and he’s 68). On my first visit I had one of their small stuffed calzones ... Fantastic! I was sold! I haven’t stopped visiting since. Next visit I tried the pizza ... Outstanding! (Both the Sicilian and regular pie are Fantastic! I think Chris is the owner? He’s almost always there (rotates shifts with another family member however). He’s friendly, a perfect gentleman ... treats every customer courteously and respectfully! This restaurant is a unpretentious, tiny spot ... but believe me ... coming from a person whose favorite fast food is pizza ... and I’ve visited 100’s ... probably more :-) ... this place is a keeper! ... in modern language ‘a hot spot’! A must try! They also do take out catering for Super Bowl parties or any other party 🎉 I had them make a few boxes of calzones I mentioned earlier to contribute towards last years Super Bowl. There was a lot of food at that party ... but, hands down’, the calzones were the biggest hit! Try Catania’s! ... One of the best pizzas in Westchester County. You won’t be disappointed ... in fact, you’ll go out of your way to try it again ... just like me! 😉 Doug WP NY

Joseph Grant

Has great pizza. You can get a slice and drink for $4.50. You can call and make a delivery there. The Italian ice comes out in the summer. The service is quick, and the staff is friendly.

Jason Laureles

Been going to this place for years. Great spot to grab a few slices or calzones. Broccoli rab with sausage or chicken parm roll is definitely one of my favorites. Good seating for a quick bite. Staff is really friendly.

Ralph Whitehead

My family has been going to Catania's since way back when it was in little Italy in the bronx. They've kept the quality the same when they moved to Yonkers and the entire time it has been there. They have always had the best calzones and their sicilian pizza dough is light and is great.

Ryan C

Catania’s Pizza has been around for a long time. This small place, has great pizza and also a small seating area (nothing fancy.) If you happen to check this place out, there chicken rolls are amazing.

Patrick Worthington

The best pizza in Westchester county. It's a best kept secret, I personally love getting a pie with onion and meatball. Every time I get pizza somewhere else I always say to myself “I should have gotten Catania”

Linda Mrnacaj

I love there mini calzones and sicilian slices are amazing out of this world . The staff and owner are very accommodating to customers in there pizzeria. I’ve been going to this pizza shop since day one and I won’t stop nor will my family and friends we all love it. Thank you Linda m

Ramy Stein

My cousin used to live near here so we would always order a pie or two from here. Now, well after my family moved, I find myself dragging a friend with me once in a while and going out of our way to eat here. All their variations of pizzas are amazing, but to tell how good a pizzeria is, you have to judge their plain slice, and I say you cannot go wrong with their plain slice. The calzones may look too small, but they are great to snack on. I've seen they will cater a batch of them for parties (dunno if they still offer this though). Possibly the best pizza in all of Westchester. And seriously, how many pizzerias do you know that have gotten a shot out in a comic book? (Marvel Comics' Deadpool: Games of Death #1 printed in March of 2009).

Chris Carbillano

Best pizza + more great Italian food ever. Staff is friendly and very professional. You've just gotta go there and try it.

Anne Conway

Always a friendly face a big hello great prices excellent food they make thousands like nobody else does their pizza and that cousens crust is so crispy he can't beat it and you always feel welcome and you could go in there on your own into the table and feel very comfortable

java mochafrap

Small can + regular slice. $5. Ripoff

Cee Wood

Average eatery with just ok food. Engaging staff but absolutely no restroom. Customers are directed to use the Wingstop or Dunkin Donuts facility.

Marisa Moore

Been coming to this spot since my mom moved to Yonkers from the Bronx, 11 years ago. Great pizza, friendly and quick service.

Abril Mejia

The only reason I give a 5 star is because the worker at the front is very hard working! He deserves a pay raise ASAP!😤😤 …

Its That time

Great tradional pizza, Favorite Chicken parm pie. Always delivers hot as I like, friendly staff when I call and just great food

Robert Zimmerman

Nice assortment of pies, gotta love choices. Everything tastes good and people are friendly. Quick and easy for locals.

Luis Lithgow

Great NY tasting pizza Crust is not to hard, sauce is good and the amount of cheese is perfect By far one of the best pizzas to get in Yonkers

Charlie's Dad

Top notch pizza and calzones. Has that old school pizza parlor feel and flavor that is hard to find these days.

Peter Olivencia

this place has the best delicious chicken ziti parmesan in the area especially with garlic sauce, only one draw back the order is a little small for the price they charge you, howr despite the portion me and my family will keep coming back.👍😊 ! …

Jorge Hernandez

Best pizza around here by far! Good portion for price.. Great sauce!

Amelia Acerra

Just like I remembered it was like when I moved away 20 years ago. Food was on point. Service was great. Loved chatting with the owner!!!

MrADjam5

Excellent mini calzones just like Arthur ave. Friendly workers great place to eat.

Zachary Barden

The best calzones around. I love their ricotta calzone. Their pizza is also very good

Prem Advani

Good pizza.. but the Trump Flag run pretty high here

Cee Cee

I love they pizza one of the best pizza ever!!!! Plus they are sooo respectful

Saori Soto

Hole in the walls sometimes have the best food. This location proves that, they have the best pizza in town.

mike greer

Ordered a fresh extra large pie ,,,and was sent a pie that had been previously made and sitting.

Chozen_Charlie rivera

Love the pizza here, I drive from the bronx just for it. Service is good

Y. Irvine

Best pizza spot in town!Love their meatball calzone.

Anthony Sparaccio

Will stop here if I'm in the area. Good pizza.

paris boy andre

Love their Calzones CHICKEN MARSALA MY FAVORITE GREAT PIZZA TOO ❤❤❤❤

Steve Pannone

Great product friendly staff, and thank God they have ac it's hot outside.

Al Diggidi (Aldiggi)

Best Pizza in town. Love their calzones!!

Gustavo P.C

Pizza is very good here, fast service.

Graca Pinto

Speedy service, good price and even better food. Definitely recommend :)

jakuvded

great food and staff. a neighborhood staple for the longest.

Sergio DaRosa

good food overall. drawbacks that some of the portions size are small and it is a bit pricey

JaneAnn Tobin

Best calzones around!

Chris Buzzeo

Meatball calzones are fantastic !

Stefano Nicoletti

Excellent we always go here every Friday

Dillon Browne

Try the buffalo chicken pizza. It's done right and just legend.

IDig A. Pony

Excellent pizza, one of a kind calzones!

Gregory Guerrero

Customer service and pizza were both good

Oscar Rolon

Good NY style pizza and friendly staff

Jacqui Carfi

Awesome! Best Little Calzone House in Yonkas!!!

Robert Martino

Best calzones you ever have.

Shadman Ahmed

Regular pizza place, good slices

Radames Hernandez

Outstanding service and great food!

Joe Y

Best buffalo chicken pizza around

M Mary

No matter what you select, it's going to be delicious!!

Ray M

Delicious parm calzones!

Fred Basli

Best meat calzone on the planet

Cindy Vazquez

I love their food!!

Jay's Make-up Channel Hola Lovelies

The food and service is good.

N Naaz

Pizza you can eat everyday

Michael AP

The best pizza in Yonkers

Mauricio Atlatenco

LONG TIME FAVORITE....OVER 30 YEARS!!!

Jay

Best pizza in the area!

* “‪Daddyydex‬” *

Best pizza in Yonkers

Michele

Must try mini calzones

Nilda Sierra

Always great service.

Doug Loverro

Best calzones in the World

Kristin Krauskopf

Love the salad pizza

Raul Irizarry

Best pizza on central

Nicole Caruso

Best pizza around!

Camelene C White- Ike

Best White Pizza in town

Tony Paul

Great pizza.

Sir Lucius Squigglesworth lll

Love this spot

Massiel Blanco

Love it

Takisha Moore

Best food in town

Frances Gibbs

Best pizza ever

Ernest Schiavone

Chicken Marsala roll 👍👍👍 …

Paul Allison

Always good.

tyrone dills

Pizza is really good

Alex Eisenberg

Fresh and tasty

Joseph Rodriguez

Love this place

Arben G

Excellent 👍 …

Angel F

Delicious!!!

shelly mugerson

Real Pizza!!!!

Beri Escano

excellent calzones

Contact

Photos