Reviews of NY Times Square Pizza. (Restaurant) in Tampa (Florida).

NY Times Square Pizza

278 Reviews

10 Comments

Restaurant

Pizza restaurant

226 E Bearss Ave, Tampa, FL 33613, United States

Description

Information of NY Times Square Pizza, Restaurant in Tampa (Florida)

Discover the opening times, the location, contact, popular times, photos and real reviews by internet users.

This place has a very good rate, they treat their customers well and you’ll feel welcome, super recommended

Map

Open hours of NY Times Square Pizza

Popular times

Sunday

Monday

Tuesday

Wednesday

Thursday

Friday

Reviews of NY Times Square Pizza

Fred H Photography

The woman server was a breath of fresh air. She was funny and accommodating. Food was delicious. Crust was crispy but not dry. The cheese wasn’t a mess when serving ourselves. My wife who grew up eating NY style pizza was in heaven.

AnthonyandFelicia Williams

It’s an OK spot. The Staff is great! The pizza is average & I’m not sure how they call it NY Style… since the slices weren’t large and the taste was not what we know NY style pizza to be. Again, the Staff was great;-)

kommaja

I requested a pie with a heart on it and they didn’t have any problem making it for me. The pizza was so delicious and my girls were so happy for getting the heart pizza. We are definitely coming back.

Paige Madden (PaiMaddz)

Not only was this pizza absolutely beautiful, it tasted amazing and was named after her mother since it was her favorite! We added some pepperoni to ours, It was fire! 🔥

Haus

This is one of our go to places for pizza. We love the lunch special, 2 slices and a drink! The white pizza with spinach is my favorite and the owner always adds glaric butter to the crust! We have had their cauliflower crust pizza, cooked well, and it is as good as the regular crust pizza. The owner works so hard to keep this place spotless and always has a smile!! Give them a try, you will not be disappointed!!🍕🍕🍕

Ashley E. Chancy

Visiting the area and saw this pizza parlor. Places always claim they have NY pizza, and usually fall short. This place though... Did NOT disappoint! The pizza was super hot, garlic knots were on point, and the cheese sticks actually had melted mozzarella on the inside. To top it off, the owner was so friendly and helpful. She chatted with us about why we were in the area and wished us well. She's fantastic! My only complaint is that this place isn't close enough to where we live! Will definitely be back again!

Gerardo Fuentes

Forget these reviews!! You need to just try it for yourself!!! I ordered the large white pizza. It was absolutely amazing!! Definitely made with love. I’ve been looking for a pizzeria like this ever since I moved from New York.

Lisa M. Raulerson

I have been coming to eat here for years. Her calzones are my favorite, along with her pizza. Honestly, you won't go wrong with anything off her menu. She is extremely kind and gracious. My son has been very sick and she has made his favorite foods to fit his dietary needs for us to take to the hospital. Thank you Essie!

Matthew Bessette

Easily the best pizza in Tampa Bay! We live in St Pete and still come back. The wings and chicken parm sandwich are great too. Honestly it doesnt matter what you order, it's always good. In addition to the food it's locally owned and the staff remember you and always make you feel welcomed. You won't be disappointed!

Robert R.

Update: 12/12/2022. Pizza is still good as ever. Now they have awesome brownies. They have three different types: 1)sugar-free, 2)gluten-free 3)regular I guess. They are awesome. I will be in trouble if I go there and don't bring some home. This pizza is delicious. A personal guilty pleasure. They use the real pizza ovens and not corporate conveyor belt ovens. This pizza is mom and pop made. Some of the corporate pizza chains are decent but this is delicious.

Contact

Photos