Reviews of Magdalena's Pizzeria. (Restaurant) in Tampa (Florida).
Magdalena's Pizzeria
2313 W Linebaugh Ave, Tampa, FL 33612, United States
Description
Information of Magdalena's Pizzeria, Restaurant in Tampa (Florida)
Discover the opening times, the location, contact, popular times, photos and real reviews by internet users.
This place has a very good rate, they treat their customers well and you’ll feel welcome, super recommended
Map
Open hours of Magdalena's Pizzeria
Popular times
Tuesday
11 | |
---|---|
12 | |
13 | |
14 | |
15 | |
16 | |
17 | |
18 | |
19 | |
20 | |
21 |
Wednesday
11 | |
---|---|
12 | |
13 | |
14 | |
15 | |
16 | |
17 | |
18 | |
19 | |
20 | |
21 |
Thursday
11 | |
---|---|
12 | |
13 | |
14 | |
15 | |
16 | |
17 | |
18 | |
19 | |
20 | |
21 |
Friday
11 | |
---|---|
12 | |
13 | |
14 | |
15 | |
16 | |
17 | |
18 | |
19 | |
20 | |
21 |
Saturday
11 | |
---|---|
12 | |
13 | |
14 | |
15 | |
16 | |
17 | |
18 | |
19 | |
20 | |
21 |
Reviews of Magdalena's Pizzeria
A solid 3.5.
We ordered 2 large pizzas and a medium. The pepperoni, 5 cheese and chicken bacon ranch.
The crust and bread was good and the filling tasty. In general, there was too much on the pizzas. They ended up soggy and too heavy on filling.
The 5 cheese fell apart but was good.
Good prices and timing was good
Hands down the BEST pizza I’ve EVER had. The flavors and taste are unmatched and they’re obviously using premium ingredients. Normally pizza will give me some minor heartburn every single time I eat it, but I haven’t experienced that once with Magdalena’s. Their Bocci balls are to die for and their 5 cheese, BBQ chicken and chicken bacon ranch are absolutely unbeatable!
My first time to this establishment very conveniently located 6 minutes from me Forest Hills neighborhood. I decided to give this place a try because a coworker recommended it. I was planning on going to South Tampa or downtown to the city but then I remembered this place and decided hey let me try this place instead. I do not regret my decision the pizza is delicious has so much flavor the crust is perfect to the crunch. The wings so much taste and I got mine mild with blue cheese, I highly recommend this place!
Great prices, great service and most of all great pizza!! Thomas really was amazing making sure we had a great experience and the fries, garlic knots and pizza were all delicious. We will definitely be back the next time we are in Tampa!!
Amazing pepperoni pizza, it’s true that they have the best pizza in town, I love this place
First time here. Love it. Will be coming back soon
Ordered a supreme 18 inch extra mozzarella cheese it was excellent and had some leftover for lunch next day they have a large menu little bit of everything try them out when you get a chance
Best pizza, salads and wings ive had for a long time. Made fresh and taste amazing. Ashley, Jasmine and Thomas are an awesome team.
If you go to Tampa area this is a must to visit spot, absolutely great New York style pizza , customer service was outstanding and the Owners very nice friendly people!!! They make you feel part of their family!!! Really yummy!!!
Buffalo Chicken pizza was delicious full of meat & flavor. I could tell this is an up north style pizza restaurant. The up north mom & pops pizzeria are the best. The wings & Jalapeño poppers are good as well. The portions are a nice & the price is reasonable.
A true neighborhood hidden gem! Worth the drive even if you don't live in the immediate area. From their salads to their pizzas and everything in between, the portion sizes are great, even with the current inflation issues. Their dining area is tiny but if there is room (if it's your first time), I suggest having the first slice of your carry-out pizza while there, just to see how amazing it is when it first comes out of the oven.
One of the best pizzas my wife and I have ever eaten. 100% would always recommend this place to anyone. Thank you so much for the kind and quick service Thomas.
Went with my wife, and we agreed it was great.
I'm not a big pizza crust guy, but theirs was the best I've had in FL
Pasta is excellent and spaghetti sauce is great with lots of flavor. Tastes great and homemade. Garlic knots also very tasty
I have been coming here for years and the food is always fresh and delicious! The staff is extremely friendly and welcoming. I will remain a loyal customer.
AMAZING little find! We stumbled upon this place and couldn’t be happier that we did. Everything we ordered was perfection- from the bocci balls, to the pizza, to the pizza rolls and eggplant parmesan- it was all delicious! The owner was a super friendly guy who truly takes pride in dishing you up a homemade Italian meal. Give this place a try! I promise you won’t be disappointed.
Great food and great staff. Definitely recommend it. The pizza and side dishes are delicious 😋 Authentic NY flavor. …
Pizza was decent but they forgot my salad. I didn't check it in the store bc 4 men were staring at me and making me uncomfortable. I assumed they were waiting for me to leave. I called back and they stated they would refund it but they never did. It was just creepy vibes. No thanks.
My boyfriend raved about the pizza here for months and finally he brought me some. It was the best pizza I’ve had in the Tampa area, and I can’t believe the menu prices. I would pay $5 more for the same pizza anywhere else. It was amazing quality, unbelievable prices, and I can’t wait for him to bring me more, hopefully not in months time!
Visiting Busch Gardens, I ordered Magdalena's for my family based on Google ratings and it did not disappoint! We had a large supreme pizza, a small cheese pizza and the garlic knots and everything was exceptional 👌 10/10 would recommend! …
This place has the best pizza in Tampa! It’s the closest thing to Pizza in NYC! My favorite is the chicken bacon ranch & Meat Eaters pizza.
All my homies and I eat at Magdalena’s 😤💯
Drive all the way from Orlando bc the hosts are so nice, good prices and worth it.
Best pizza in town! Definitely is not only about support local business, is also about the great flavor and the great services that u always receive. U can tell is a homemade salsa, perfect crispy but soft dough. The lasagna is amazing! U really need to try this place.
I really couldn't tell you what the sauce and cheese tasted like i couldn't get past how burnt the crust was thats all I tasted and I hate any food thats burnt. Unfortunately I got it to go and didn't notice until I was five or 10 minutes away and I was working so wasn't going back. I'll try again when I'm in the area hopefully with a better result.
Moved to Florida recently and had given up hope on good pizza until I found this place. Best pizza I ever had! Great staff and customer service! Live 40 minutes away but will be driving here often! 5 stars!!!
My husband and I dined in at Magdalena's tonight. I was craving pizza but wanted pizza that had that fresh dough flavor and crisp. We did a Google search and I am so thankful for picking Magdalena's!
As we waited for our food, I looked around the decor and absolutely loved it. I also noticed how friendly the owners were. They didn't treat the people who came and picked up their orders like customers, rather they treated them like family.
The 4 of us spoke, shared laughs and we absolutely loved every minute of our visit. It will definitely be the first of many!
P.S.
The pizza was fantastic!!!! It was everything I was craving for.
It was good alfredo fettuccine. I liked the garlic knots that came with it and the side salad. I also ordered a small cheese pizza. The crust was crispy and was delicious. Also ordered a calzone but didn't like the ricotta cheese in it. Was too much. Ordered here again and the crust was good thickness/thinness. Not a fan of the garlic knots though.
We love this place. Super friendly workers and just the best food. We also love that it’s a block from where we live (:
Give this place a try, you won't be disappointed! The couple that own it work there and they are so nice and friendly! They even have a few tables inside so you can eat in their cozy dinning room. They have an awesome array of different food options and they are all great!! The lumpia (Filipino style egg rolls) are so crispy and flavorful they are a must try!! Thank you for such a wonderful experience!
Tasty Supreme pizza with fresh and quality ingredients. Cozy neighborhood mom n pop Italian joint. Magdalena and Doug were super friendly and took great care of us. My wife and I enjoyed chatting with them and feel lucky we stumbled upon this gem on our short visit to Tampa. Highly recommend!
Not sure how I have lived a mile from this place for most of my life and have never ordered here before. Thanks to another pizza place not having the items we were looking for we now have a new favorite. The pizza wings and Greek salad were great and the staff is very friendly. I can wait to try other items on their menu
Amazing pizza, my family loves the shrimp alfredo pasta, and the calzones are huge! We've ordered from here four or five times now and it's consistently great food and service.
Miss the old owner may she rest in peace new place just doesn’t have the taste
We had a dine in since we had our kids with us. The waiter/cashier/manager was brilliant. My kids were treated in a so caring manner by her that we can only say Thank You! We had such a great experience! Nice service from beginning to end. And the food? It couldn't be better. Actually, eating Italian food cooked by a real Italian was simply perfect. We recommend 200% and would definitely go back. Oh... One more thing, huge plates served there. Thank you guys!
This is yet another example of a well-run family business, but in the pizza time. we had calzone and strombolis that were truly exceptional. The desserts were also very good - we had baklava and cheesecake. I can't say enough good things about this small and unique little restaurant. Prices were okay but the food was just exceptional. And the Filipino lady who was running it was as sweet as ever. she even had me try a couple other dishes that were knockouts as well. She even made a great suggestion to visit siesta key Beach and that was a great success as well. Very cool little place to stop at and absolutely worth the trip. Please give them your business, they deserve it!
Review is based on a delivery order. Cheese pizza, not sure what made it better, but this pizza was better than most places I order from. Wings were properly cooked. Greek salad was perfect (except for the olives I asked not be on the salad, but since they did not mix them in, they were easy to pick off). Pizza rolls were huge. I think I ordered too much food, but the prices were good, so I had to try lots of stuff. Will eat here again.
First time here ordered pick up for chicken bacon ranch pizza and I have tried many if not all places around Tampa Bay and this place and Madison Avenue pizza in Dunedin are the best in the bay in my opinion!!! This is by far the best pizza in Tampa!! Better then Ed and sams in downtown and all!! Great crust, fresh toppings.. Gem of a place
If I could leave 10 starts I would! We stopped by for dinner after reading the amazing reviews & top rating. It lived up the expectations! The owners are the sweetest, you feel like family! Lemon pepper wings were crispy, the grilled chicken salad was so filling with the homemade Italian dressing. We split a 6” pizza, so good! & the homemade Lumpia the owner makes is delish! We will be returning!
Amazing food! Stuffed shells, chicken alfredo, chicken tenders, Greek salad, green dressing, side salads, and a slice. Holy cow! That red sauce and Alfredo sauce were so yummy! And we ordered on the slice app and it came early, warm from a lovely delivery driver! 👍🏼😍🍕🍝 …
Best Pizza in Tampa! No matter when we order our food is always amazing! We always get a cheese pie with basil and garlic knots! Both are amazing! We love Magdalena and all the staff. You are always greeted with a smile and warm welcome. Thanks!
I wish I could give more than a 5 star review. The food is phenomenal. Cooked to perfection. Pizza, wings and calzones are favourites in our family. Also, the owners are extremely nice and welcoming. You can tell that a lot of passion is put into Magdalena's Pizzeria.
The owners of Magdalena's Pizzeria were fantastic! I called to see if they could accommodate at party of 6 people at 8:45pm when the close at 9:30pm. The owner told us to come in and he would make it happen. The lasagna pizza was unbelievable and the eggplant parmesan was a HUGE portion for the price. Keep up the great work and I'll see you soon for that lasagna!
Been ordering from Magdelena's Pizza, since we moved to Tampa, a few months ago. Pizza is delicious. Lasagna or Ziti with meat sauce are perfect. (Can I order a jug of meat sauce?) Tried the lemon/pepper wings for the first time and they are excellent. Magdalena and her husband Doug are such a nice couple. Nice to buy from a privately owned restaurant. Try Magdelena's Pizzeria....and enjoy!
We love ordering from this place!! We typically get the calzones and they are always sooo huge and sooo good! We got the Stromboli’s this time and they are also so good!! The gentleman and woman who helped us when we went in are super nice and thoughtful. I’d recommend eating at this place 100000%! If you haven’t tried them out, I’d highly recommend it!!
We are always in search of a good pizza spot. This restaurant was a bit of a drive for us but was worth the trip! The interior was nice - it was small with eclectic decorations and had the local, hole-in-the-wall, local pizza shop feel. The service was overall good, friendly and helpful, although our food did take a while to come out. The menu had a lot of pizza options. We went with a meat pizza, white pizza and garlic knots, and all were deliciously authentic. I would definitely recommend checking it out!
This 5 cheese pizza with fried chicken and banana peppers was so good!
Amazing hole in the wall pizza joint - Our personal favorite pie in the Tampa area! Always friendly and quick service, always great tasting pizza.
Came here after picking our son up for a visit. This place has a quaint atmosphere and lovely owners. The pizza was one of the best pies our family has ever had!!!! The ingredients that are used are high quality and the taste was to die for!!! We will definitely be back!!❤️❤️❤️
Oh, and the cannolis are fabulous!!!!!!
Super easy ordering online, they have thee sweetest people up front. They were very welcoming and when they didn't have Flan, they offered us so many other options.
Great variety of choices! Definitely worth the first trial for a new pizza place that's not your regular chain.
Owner and wife were super friendly! Our 1st time ordering here and will absolutely order from here again. Enjoyed both the calzone and stromboli. We like leftovers so ordered the larger portions and got exactly that! We'll be eating leftovers for days... lol.
Ever since the new owners took over I love this place even more.
You can tell they take pride in their food and love their customers I cannot stop by without at least having a 5-minute conversation with either of the owners which I love because it shows their passion for their business and their customers.
The owner's wife is Philippine so on certain days I go there for Italian food and get blessed and get to try really good food that I wasn't expecting.
Not in any shape or form saying this is the best pizzeria in Tampa, but it is definitely the best in the Forest Hills area.
A little ducked off spot with decent pizza. I tried the cheese to compare to other spots. It's a spot of convenience, truly.
Magdalena's is a hidden gem! My friend told me about her little neighborhood pizzeria that had this great menu. On my first visit I ordered the Chicken Picatta. It was to die for. 5 stars all the way. My biggest surprise was that Lumpia on the menu. I ordered it on my next trip & it was perfect! It brought back fond memories of trips to the Philippines. Since that first visit my GF & I have ordered take-out dinner there about once a week and we've loved everything. I don't know if the staff are all family, but everyone I've interacted with was friendly & courteous.I highly recommend this small, unpretentious family restaurant.
Doug is what you call the man and he came through when my pizza was not right so he gave me a free pizza at no cost. Best pizza in town. Coming from an Italian from Italy❤️❤️❤️
Tampa Bay’s most precious hidden GEM! The pizza is OUTSTANDING! Last night I think I had the best pizza of my life. Gotta try the Buffalo Chicken pizza! Also the chicken pot pies could make you cry from deliciousness. The Pasta Rose is life changing. The White pizza is the better than New York City’s. The Calzone’s are insanely large and delicious filled with incredible amount of ricotta cheese. The Greek Salads are fresh and delicious. Magdalena’s is family owned and has the most incredible owners and staff. I am so thankful and lucky that it is adjacent to my neighborhood. This place is the ABSOLUTE BEST! I cannot say enough great things about this amazing place! It’s absolutely INCREDIBLE!!!!!!
Was in from out of state and found Magdalenas through the reviews and I’m GLAD we went. Delicious food...huge calzone (and it was a medium!), pizza was delicious and the marinara sauce was 👌🏻. I’ll take a small family owned business like this over chain pizza or fake Italian any day. On busy days the wait may be longer but it’s worth it. Staff treated us like family and the whole experience was A+. We left Tuesday (we went on a Saturday and they are closed Monday Tuesday ) otherwise I would have gone back again. Cannoli poppers were also good and filled to the max!
We love Magdalena’s! Family owned business that puts their heart in every meal. Everything one the menu is delicious! Great food for a great price.
Latest update: I finally got to try the pizza! A friend was visiting Tampa for her birthday, and she, and another friend and I, were supposed to go out to eat, but she wasn't feeling all that great from the drive(neck issues). So I ordered a large Supreme Pizza, Spaghetti with meatballs and meat sauce, salads, a decadent brownie, and Magdalena's version of a 7 Wonder Bar and took it over to our friends house. Everything was delicious, but I've already reviewed most of the food at Maggie's, except the pizza. The pizza was fantastic! We all loved it . Great quality ingredients, and plenty of them!
Update: I had the Beef Pot Pie yesterday for the first time at lunch time. I cannot really describe how good it was. I over ate ...and I only ate half of it. I hadn't planned on eating that much, but it was hard to stop myself. Then I did the same thing for a late night dinner. I will definitely be ordering that again! But it's one more reason why I've never been able to even try their pizza. Everything is so good I can never get to the pizza!
The REAL DEAL! Everything is homemade. The "sauce" is incredible! Meatballs full of garlic and all the good stuff. Delicious garlic knots. Guy is from New Jersey....his father had a place there for 40 years...his brother runs it now. And we are so blessed to have part of the family here in Tampa now. Magdalena, his wife, is a sweetheart and an incredible cook also! Tampa has no other truly authentic, reasonably priced Italian food like this. I have not had a bad meal here. The deserts are wonderful too! Magdalena makes most of the them herself. Delicious moist Carrot Cake, best brownies I've ever had, and a lot more selections. Oh, and the portions are huge. Yum!
This is the best pizza place ever. We were surprised we saw a negative comment.Someone must've had a bad day and took it out on Crusty's. We eat here at least once a week. We love the quality and most of all the taste of the food. The people there are friendly and awesome. Were gonna continue to enjoy Crusty's pizza
Crusty's Pizza delivered on all levels! (Pun intended) The pie itself was delicious and I could really tell the time and effort they put into their product. The sauce was great and they included extra at my request. The staff seemed very sincere and appreciative of my business. We will be back and this will be our go-to spot for a great pizza in our neighborhood. Thank you Crusty's Pizza!!
My husband, son and I intentionally planned to stop here even though it was a little out of the way from our main destination. We were getting very hungry and I kept telling my husband it better be worth it. IT WAS!!! We got pizza slices because we were trying to keep our lunch light. The pizzas were so good. It’s hard finding good pizza. Well, mission accomplished. My husband and I had also shared a bowl of picadillo soup. That was delicious! We make picadillo ourselves but never before in soup form. We loved it. But most of all, the owner Maggie was such a sweetheart. She told us her story about how they came to start their own business. We talked the entire time we were there. When we were leaving she gave us a send off in the form of hugs. Yes, the food was great, but I think she made it an awesome experience. There are a few things we would’ve loved to try on the menu. We’ll definitely have to return whenever in Tampa and try the other things out. The desserts looked really good too but we were already full. I would also like to mention that the place was very clean. That’s a big deal for me. We were impressed overall with this place.
Why three stars? Unfortunately the crust was a bit soggy which took away from the overall experience of the pizza. Another downside, was the lack of ingredients, they were sparse and I would have liked to have more on the pizza pie.
The staff was very friendly and super helpful. The dining area is small and I would say this place is much better as a take out. They do have an open air courtyard in the back with a few tables, it's a nice space.
About three months ago, my inlaws told us about this place, they order probably once a week from there. We have had the meatball and italian sub, very good and very big subs, we couldn't finish them. Our next visit, we decided to try a pizza, first one was the philly cheesesteak, it was so good, that I've been craving it ever since. Last night my hubby picked up the margarita pizza and while he was waiting she was making her famous Lumpia (Filipino style egg role) and threw in a sample for us, it was the bomb!! So far we love everything there and when we are on that side of town (Forest Hill area), that's the place to go.
I'm not huge on tomatoes... and the tomatoes on mine and my sweetheart's margherita pizza from a couple days back were so juicy and fresh that I wanted to just pick them off and eat them by themselves. That should tell you how good the pizza -- and the food in general -- is here (I also recommend their cheesesteak sub). They have a wide, varied, affordable menu with an assortment of weekly specials, so it won't be difficult in the least to satisfy your appetite here even if you don't want pizza. Come to Magdalena's and they'll take good care of you!
Me and my family have been coming to Magdalen's since last year Dug has become part of the family w were so sad to here when his wife Maggie passed away but they have been family for a long time there food is AMAZING I would definitely recommend them to anyone new to the area
Family owned & operated is a plus. We had a small veggie with ham & pepperoni pizza rolls. Lots of food left for the next day. Pizza is NY style crust but not as much dripping grease. The food was delicious & the owner was extremely helpful with the menu since it was our 1st time. Nice dining area to relax & wait. We loved it & will definitely be back.
Just ate lunch with the family here. Don't let appearances fool you. It's a small place and nothing special as far as looks go.... But the food was exceptional. Very fresh and the owners are really nice, attentive people. We're visiting from out of town for Busch Gardens, but will definitely be back again. White pie was great and so were the wings. Highly recommend it.
Absolutely loved Magdalena’s! Wish it was closer so we could go more often! Great pizza and the owners are the nicest people you will have the chance of knowing. We drove from Harbour Island to go there and will definitely make the trip again!
It was my first time there and they really impressed me. The owner was very very friendly and kind. Went home to eat my pizza and it was still hot and boy was it delicious and freah. The bread was amazing with the garlic butter sauce on it. My family really enjoyed it. We will be back there.
To the owner: god bless u and ur family. I wish u all the best and to prosper in your business. Best of wishes
Best meat lovers pizza I’ve eaten in a while!
Small, family owned and awesome! We found this gem while visiting from out of town. We were treated like family. The Italian cuisine was great, adding some lumpia made it amazing. I love this place and will return the next time we're in the area.
I recently had dinner at Magdalena's Pizzeria with my girlfriend. I wanted to post a review due to the great food and how nice the owners, Doug and Magdalena, were to us.
The Google picture of Crusty's Pizza is in error. Doug and Magdalena purchased the assets and renamed the restaurant from Crusty's Pizza to Magdalena's Pizzeria. The storefront was changed from the Google picture, which needs to be updated. Doug and Magdalena changed the menu, upgraded the food selections, replaced the management with themselves, and generally turned this into a completely new and different pizzeria, starting from their acquisition in November of 2017.
While approximately one-half of the menu is comprised of Pizza varieties, the other one-half has selections including spaghetti with meat sauce, which I had and was delicious, eggplant parmigiana, which my girlfriend had and loved, salads, which were fresh and well-made, sandwiches, and many other authentic Italian dishes. They had some great desserts also.
The owners, Doug and Magdalena, shared with us their dreams of owning and running this first class Pizzeria, recently ranked #1 in the entire state of Florida! I definitely concur with that assessment.
The restaurant has both lunch and dinner, and even delivers to your house or place of business.
My girlfriend and I were both very impressed with this restaurant. This is a great, very friendly and comfortable eat-in genuine Italian Pizzeria. I definitely recommend it. If you come to this restaurant, you will have good food and a good time. Definitely 5 stars!
We stopped in here for lunch on a whim and was not disappointed. We tried a regular cheese, white, and taco pizza. The meat for the taco pizza has a lot of flavor, not just ground beef. All three pizzas were delicious and the staff was very nice and friendly. Will be back to this little gem.
The chicken parm was excellent. Heads above what you get at Gino's and much less expensive. You get a bunch of garlic knots, a salad and enough spaghetti to feed two to three people. The portions are huge. This place has a great menu and I don't think I'll cook again until I try everything on it. Really friendly people. I will spread the word about this place to everyone in the area. I'll try to figure out how to attach photo's to reviews but my take out order looked like it was from a 5 star restaurant.
Wonderful family owned pizzeria with great food. Our first visit here and we were very pleased. We ordered the garlic knots, parm/garlic wings, pepperoni and cheese pie. AWESOME!! We were made to feel at home and even tried a slice of homemade coconut pie...YOU HAVE GOT TO GET THIS!! One of Tampa's finest Police Officers was kind enough to treat my grandbabies to a slice of the rainbow cake! THANK YOU!!
It was a great place and the food is delicious, hot and fresh. You can see the fresh garlic in the knots sauce. We just relocated and are so glad we found a go to place for food. GO TRY THIS PLACE!!
Awesome pizza. Me and friends eat Pizza by the pounds. This place is a front runner. Staff is incredible, its a local business, signature rolls are incredible. Food is always made to order. Price is undeniably great. aside from that its a feel good place. I give it 9.5 on the 10 scale.
Talk about some delicious local made pizza. My husband doesn't eat supreme pizza and he absolutely loves it from this place. We plan to try other items but so far we're stuck on their pizzas!
Great place !!! The pizza was excellent and the homemade coconut custard pie was awesome. The owners are super nice folks and seem to genuinely want you to enjoy their food creations. Will definately be back to try out the Rice Balls and homemade Pineapple Upside-down cake. You won't be disappointed!!!
LOVE the calzones, pork adobo and chicken pot pie too!
I can not say enough good about this place ! I've been there a few different occasions and its becoming our family's spot. Everyone that works there especially the owners are thoughtful,generous, and kind. If you go there and interact with the owners they really are lovely people. One time I went in to their store very upset (had my first flat tire) I had no idea how to deal with it and my mom wasn't available. The owners offered to use their own AAA and checked to see if I was okay . I've never been to a business that's so kind and thoughtful of their customers. I highly recommend their philly pizza and their philly cheese steaks. Also don't be afraid to try their philopeano food because its amazing. If you are feeling under the weather they make awesome chicken soup and their chili is great. Overall I'm a food critique and very picky and I've come to love this place😊😋😎
So an excellent experience this evening as this place is firing on all cylinders. Super nice and genuine people with a passion for serving up great meals. In a world with half hearted proprietors These owners understand that no request from customers is unreasonable and it’s a trait that will set this restaurant apart from all the rest. Tonight we really enjoyed a meat lovers pizza in 18” and an amazing pizza it was. Soft thin crust in the middle with a light and airy crunchy crust. The toppings were fresh and well seasoned. We were given samples of three other dishes that we will soon be returning to get full size versions. We wrapped up the meal with the best flan I’ve ever experienced. After the meal we sat and chatted with the owners and they are Uber friendly. It was good enough that there is a strong possibility we will be back tomorrow to try something different. Don’t just think of this as a pizza joint as we saw chicken pot pie and other comfort foods as daily specials. They even serve curry and Philippino delicacies as well. We saw stuffed shells, spaghetti and meatballs, a delicious butter nut and squash soup, a heaping basket of French fries, and an enormous plate of garlic knots drowning in garlic butter. So much good food options to choose from and the preparation is done right. This is going to be our budget friendly “go to place” for some time to come. Give it a try you won’t be dissapp
Great Pizzeria to get some authentic pizza and hearty good portioned dishes and juicy subs! Basically everything is made from scratch which makes it all the better. Glad I noticed Magdalena's driving by one day and tried this Pizzeria that night. Yummy for the tummy lol
Best pizza we've ever had, hands down! The wings are also very tasty and the cheesesteak was really good too. We stop here every chance we get when we're in the Tampa area.
This place is amazing. Everything I have had here was delicious. They have awesome bake ziti, spaghetti and meat sauce, shepards pie, picadillo, garlic knots, chicken masala, pizza, meatball sub. The prices are very reasonable. The staff is very friendly. Family owned business. You should check them out. You won't be disappointed. You'll be going back again and again.
10/7/19. I had the chicken pot pie today and it was amazing. The crust was so flaky and the pie was so tasty. Well worth the wait. Can't wait to try the beef pot pie. My friend Charles had it and loved it
I LOVE this family restaurant. The owners are fantastic. Our supreme pizza was so fresh. I also noticed the dishes other customers had ordered. They looked delicious!!
We loved our meal and the service was ultra friendly, we look forward to returning
Wow finally a place to eat , excellent pizza out of the 9 years here in florida finally found a place that has fantastic pizza can't wait to try the rest of the dishes they serve truly new york style
Thanks alot
My wife and I were going to Chop Chop Shop, located next door, but they were closed. Luckily they were, because we instead went to Crusty's. My wife had the spaghetti and I had the Chicken Alfredo. I am now taking time out of my day to let everyone know...GET THE CHICKEN ALFREDO!!!!! It was one of the best Chicken Alfredo dinners I have ever had. The price was 9.99 for a generous portion of Chicken Alfredo, a large salad, and garlic bread.
I recommend you pay a visit to this restaurant soon!
Really nice staff and amazing food!
I remember the first of many times we ordered from Magdalena's my husband came home and said, "Ummm, she's not Italian this should be interesting." His mother came here from Italy and he is extremely fussy about italian food. We have never been disappointed in anything we have eaten from here. We order about once a week. Pizza, ziti, meatballs, sausage, lasagne, and her specials have all been outstanding.
We were visiting from out of town and found this gem. The atmosphere was a quaint restaurant with a homey feel. For appetizers we ordered mozzarella sticks, lumpia, and a "small" Greek salad. The Greek salad was a generous size, the vegetables were fresh and it had warmed pita bread as a side. The lumpia was delicious! For our entrees we had two "small" calzones and a pizza. The crust was perfect and the marinara sauce was out of this world. The calzones were large and enough for two people to share. The owners were delightful and caring. All the dishes were made fresh on site and she offered to make anything we wanted off menu. The owner gave us all hugs as we walked out the door. What a lovely experience!
After visiting the zoo Tampa we went to Magdalena pizzeria and let me tell you this small place is awesome fresh pizza everything is home made delicious flavor and the staff is super humble thanks from the Morales mercado family we will come back..p.s. i was the guy talking to the owner...
Best pizza and cannolis in Central Florida! I would drive an hour just to eat the pizza. The owners are the nicest people too. You won’t be disappointed. Don’t let the plaza discourage you, just go inside.
EDIT: they changed management and now the pizza doesn't taste the same as before. I am so sad. Please bring back the real Crusty's!
Wow this place (was) amazing!
Not only (was) the pizza the best I ever had, the wings and salads are fantastic. My (old) favorite nearby pizza place.
OMG - amazing food! We had pizza, salad and cannolis for dessert and everything was delicious. The staff are so friendly and welcoming. Will definitely be back!
This is some seriously good pizza. If you have the opportunity to try this place out, definitely take advantage of it. Magdelenas doesnt just serve pizza, they have ever rotating specials and more. #PizzaLovers, this place is for you. Its a place you can come eat with a small family or have it ready to be picked up. (They have delivery options too)
Today was the first time I've ever been here. We ordered a large taco & cheese steak pizza. They were both very delicious! Best pizza I have had in a long time.
Delicious wings, pizza, egg rolls, and the chocolate and carrot cake are to die for. The owners are very friendly and have excellent customer service. We will be returning to try something new on the menu.
Cheese Steak was delicious!! BUT!! it needed more steak (meat), little too much bread, I will definitely go back because they're pizza is killer. Next time I order a cheesesteak I will order double meat..
I am a certified pizzaholic. I literally at least once or twice every week have pizza for dinner. I had this for the 1st time today and this was by far the best pizza I ever tasted. Also you can not beat the lunch special prices anywhere in town. if i could i would give em 50 stars
I ordered through Amazon, and for the first time they canceled my order. I was personally called from crustys pizza and they made sure to take care of my interactions and got me my food through their own method.
Not only was the food good, but I'm happy to know a business cares for their customs.
Better than the forest hills place down the road imo.
First time i came here i ordered a large calzone for myself, i have learned my mistake, will come here again owner is lovely and "Hehe BizzA"
This isn’t JUST a pizzeria. She makes everything you would eat at home too. Check out her specials, it always changes by her, and recommendations from customers. I love the vibe here, every employee is all love.
Food was great and the owners where the best. Will go back as often as I can.
My boyfriend and I love this place. The owners are really really nice, I've known them since they have moved into their place. Very friendly, great food, great customer service on the phone when ordering and also in the restaurant. I would highly recommend this place!
Awesome. Was looking for a place with a good chicken parmesan sub and now I don't have to look any further. Sub was very tasty and cheesy and the garlic knots were delicious. Definitely will be coming back to this pizzeria
Best Pizza in Town, I suggest the White Pizza with fresh basil. The Hot Italian Combo Sub was very tasty.
Friendly and Quick service. Magdalena’s Pizza is truly a neighborhood pizzeria
By far the best pizza in The Heights. Everyone we have taken there have loved it. With so many pizza joints in The Heights I'd have to put Crustys at #1. Never a disappointment when we order from them.
Amazing pizza and very nice people. Best pie in Tampa bay I have ever had. Check it out, you will love it!
Lumpia is not in the menu, but ask for it because the owner’s wife makes it herself and it is delicious! The wings are terrific too.
The owners are wonderful folks that are easy to talk to and make the environment inviting.
Greek salad, love it! Wings Teriyaki, love it! Wings Medium, love it! Meatlovers, love it! Will order the rest of the menu over time. My favorite pizzeria!
Awesome! Great food abd the owners are super friendly. She has daily specials that make me wish I lived closer. Highly recommend.
THE best NY pizza in Florida! Omg. The sauce, the cheese, the crust!! Expansive menu from pizzas to calzones to eggplant parm dinners. You name it. Delicious salads... Something for everyone! Amazing $5 lunch specials. If you haven't been there yet, you've gotta go.
First try. The small strombolli is huge... and tasty. The white pizza is pretty good. The folks at Ginos (like, next door) said it was good and that place is some of the best food around :) I am sure I'll be back !
We love this place!!! They are very busy because they are so good!! Keep that in mind and if you can pick up your order it would be faster just my experience. Food is awesome have had many things and everything has been great!
Visiting from MN. Read the great reviews so decided to try it. The pizza and wings was delicious. The host was super friendly.
I ordered from Magdalena's after learning they donate meals to local hospital staff. I'm so glad I did, the food is amazing! Definitely my new spot.
Came here on a whim after work. The pizza was absolutely amazing, some of the best I've had in ages. The service is wonderful-- the staff is kind and helpful. I'll absolutely be coming here again.
I got garlic knots and a small calzone. I was able to get 3 meals from the calzone. It was delicious and cooked to perfection. I also received a free slice of baklava.❣️
Delicious pizza and I got the pizza rolls which were amazing. Ready to go back!
Awesome food great owners. Guy came himself and delivered amazing lasagna and buffalo wings hot and on time despite the rain and terrible driving conditions. Hats off to you Magdalenas Pizza!
Best wings in Seminole Heights! Their buffalo wings are on point, and they're only 7 or 8 bucks for 10 of them. Staff is very friendly, and orders are ready real quick!
We love this place, by far the best pizza shop in SH due to price, quality, and amount. The owner is super nice too. Get the spicy garlic wings!
We have ordered several times, love the lumpia, have ordered quite a few things on the menu, Magdalenas you got my 5💥and just know Forest Hills Pizza has nothing on you..trust me. 👍 …
Not that it has anything to do with her delicious food, but I went in there for lunch. Mag started talking to me and we both realized that through prayer, we were meant to meet. She not only fed me but provided nourishment for my soul. God bless you. I will return.
Magdalena's pizzeria makes up pizza that is reminiscent of Sal's pizzeria just North of Busch on Dale Mabry that we used to get with a one time friends dad took us for pie when we were yutes! It's the thin crust from the old days like old-timey school pizza! They make custom dishes and have even offered Lumpia and Pancit, which are both Philippine dishes as Magdalena is Pinoy herself
Love this place. Been coming for years and it never dissappoints! Keep in mind: They are busy and make everything to order, so be prepared to wait at least 30mins for food.
I love this place. I order it when I work, I order it when I'm home. And magdalene is always the sweetest. And says she loves my name and that her name and mine sound so nice together!! I love love love this placr
Went to get some pizza after a day at busch gardens nearby, great owners and great food, keep it up! 👍 …
Don't let the outside looks fool you...the food in this place is the best we've had ...chicken parmesan was unbelievable and the philly steak and cheese fabulous.. can't wait to go back and try the rest of the menu. Highly recommend!
Best pizza in Tampa Bay! This little spot is a small family owned and operated place always a smile and so hospitable...best of all yummy food!
Amazing pizza! Finally found our go to for pizza! Excited about trying rest of menu. Service was outstanding!
Ok the pizza is perfect and the lemon pepper mix with buffalo is crazy good! Not to mention the owners are very friendly and it shows in their food
Pizza was delishhh!!..... Fresh ingredients....Tastey sauce.... Perfectly baked.... I ordered a margarita pizza with sauce instead of tomatoes and it came out awesome! Owner was also very friendly...
Great 5 cheese pizza! Crust is just like I like it, not too sweet, not bland, and with a nice texture!
Great pizza and service. Very friendly place with good options.
well I can say I ordered a medium Meat Supreme Pizza and then get to eat one bite but my boxer decided to take it off the kitchen counter while my husband are working in the yard and ate the whole damn thing onions and peppers and all so I'm giving you 5 Stars just because my box right the whole thing will try this again maybe next week for me and my husband
Great food & great staff. We order from them at least once a week & they deliver fast. The delivery staff are always friendly & professional.
THIS is an awesome place to eat lunch or dinner with friends and/or family. This food is homemade & delicious. Restaurant is small yet cozy & Maggie makes you feel right at home.
If you want the BEST pizza in the state of Fla let alone Tampa Bay the go to Magdalena's and see Maggie. You'll never go anywhere else.
I stopped in the other day for lunch and I had a Italian sub. It was delicious! Extremely friendly staff very clean environment. Will go back soon
prob one of the best pizzas in tampa if not Florida the owner was nice and treated me like ive been coming in for years my new favorite pizza spot for sure
It's our favorite neighborhood pizzeria.
Great extensive menu. good prices. Very Happy with it.
A great pizza place with Awesome pizza! The Owner is Super Duper nice and knows how to make a great pizza. Bottom line is, Crusty's pizza is Outstanding!
This pizza is a five star the crust was crispy, the sauce was awesome and all the toppings where amazing! Yes sir full and happy!
Delicious food, fair price, friendly staff. Can’t go wrong.
The owners are really good and nice people. Pizza is great! They also have some Filipino food like Lumpias!
The owners are so friendly and the food is delicious. I’ve tried many items on the menu and their food is awesome, never disappointed One of my favorite restaurants.
Not consistent with their hours. I've gone twice when they were supposed to be open and no one was there. But the one time I did get there while they were open, the pizza was good
The pizza was high quality! The dough balls and canolli were very generous and delicious! I will be a new regular.
Food was absolutely perfect.. Presented well. Plentiful and the best tasting shrimp scampi ever. We will be loyal customers.
Holy crap is this place awesome!!!! Literally my favorite place for pizza and calzones.. I would say it is original.. not New York or Chicago styled pizza... a new awesome fusion maybe? Check this place out
Great food! Friendly staff. Big portions!
As close to homemade as it gets. Quality pasta dishes at very good prices. Excellent pizza as well.
Best pizza I have had in a long time. Wish this place was there when I lived in Forest Hills and Old Carollwood area.
Had the Supreme and the white pizza, both were good. The white pizza being the better of the two. Pizza was good but wasn't anything that stood out to me.
I've been ordering pizza in this neighborhood for quite a few years. This guy wins! It's good, just order it already and quit reading all the reviews!
Great calzones! And the canoli poppers were soooo good!! Small place but great food!
Food is great and the staff truly care about the quality over the quantity. Would definitely recommend the pizza and rice balls!
Great little place, they make a great pie! (Pizza) for those not from the northeast. Great wings and great owners.
Dudes are awesome pizza is great.. I'll be back for sure
Delcious and amazing Italian pizza. Cozy place with super friendly and attentive owners
Great food, great prices, and polite owner.
They even made something that wasn't on the menu for us!
I will definitely come back!
First time there... Our pizzas were awsome !!
Always EXCELLENT food! Our employees order at least once a week and everything we order is amazing.
Ordered pizza take out, was awesome flavor, quality ingredients. Definitely going back again soon.
One of the best pizza places in Tampa hands down. Staff is awesome and the sauce they use is amazing.
Family-run restaurant. They care about the recipes and it shows in the food. Varied menu that can please everyone in the family or group. Not fancy but delicious.
The food was amazing! And the people were so friendly. Great with my family. Definitely a must try.
A delicious mom and pop restaurant! Make you feel like family immediately! One of my favorite Italian restaurants!
Everything is amazing, you get great food for a great price. Come hungry, and you'll still need to go boxes.
The owner is really nice, the menu is surprisingly comprehensive, and the food is both delicious and generous in portion.
The food is excellent! However the one thing that stood out was.how friendly the staff was. Great experience! 10/10 would recommend!
Very good pizza. All the ingredients tasted fresh. Super friendly owners.
I took my mother and her friends and the owners were so welcoming and very friendly the pizzas were great the large dinner salad fed the 4 of us and the only thing I can complain was the sign was not big enough for us to see and drove right by it
The food is delicious and the folks are friendly. This was my 2nd visit and I now consider myself a customer for life!!!
Some of the best pizza you can get! Great pastas and more! Very friendly owners and staff. ☆☆☆☆☆
Everything was delicious and the owners are so nice and helpful! We definitely look forward to eating from Magdalenas again!
Came to visit from NY! Great Service good pizza.
Great crust, fresh mushrooms, but I like a tad more sauce on my pie. All in all, good!
This HAS to be the best pizza joint in Florida. By far!
Omg! I had some Chicken Buffalo pizza rolls last night. Amazing! I will be using these to bring to pot lucks.
Definitely the best little pizza place in Tampa Bay area. Worth the time and drive to find this little jewel.
Food was amazing great price excellent customer service.
Delicious food every time. Owners are kind, engaging, and interesting.
Was at the local ice cream shop and stopped by to check out somewhere new to us. Definitely happy we stopped by for great food and even better service!
Great food great people. Local small business! Highly recommended!
Wow some of the best pizza small mom and pop style place. Will definitely be going back
Awesome test of kebab
So good! Amazing crispy wings and great pizza!
Awesome pizzeria and Philipino egg rolls the owner Maggie really nice will make what ever u want
It may seem pricey, but the quality and service exceeds the price! Support this amazing small business
Great food and awesome service! We love every visit and every bite!
Great pizza and garlic knots! Fantastic value and personal attention.
Great Mom and Pop pizzeria really good taste hope they make it cause it's a tuff business 🍝🍕😀 …
Enjoyed. The caprisy salad pizza was great service excellent owner was mavelous
Ordered a cheese pizza. It was pretty good. Definitely ordering again.
Always good, and they are very accommodating.
Awesome spot! The food is consistently AMAZING and so is the customer service! Try the eggplant parm! Thanks guys! 🍕 …
Best pizza and wings in all tampa bay, great staff and awesome prices
Best pizza that I have ever had. I truly recommend it.
OMG you're going to love this place
Great lunch special. 2 Cheese and a drink for $5. Friendly staff.
Amazing food and very nice people! Will definitely go back again.
Pizza was delicious and the owners are very nice!
Very good food. You will leave full. Pizza N. Y. style yummmmm
Best flavors, excellent Pizza and super friendly service
Great food and friendly staff. Love their wings and pizza:)
The hospitality and the service and the food is amazing highly recommend best pizza in Tampa
Fresh made dinner s..I had chicken parm..enough for three people..price was quite reasonable
I love this place best pizza spot in tampa! best staff ever!
Best place ever ! And Maggie made my Christmas Eve dinner with my family the best I could ever ask for
Awesome pizza. Mostly take out but has a few tables inside.
Great calzones. And fried mushrooms are great too. Super friendly.
Just great, the food always hits the spot. Friendly owners and great quick service
Awesome Mom & Pop Pizzeria that has good food at a decent price.
Great FOOD BEST PIZZA I EVER TASTE IN YEARS AND NICEST People there
Pork Menudo was out of this world, pizzas are excellent, great little neighborhood spot
Best pizza and pasta ever! Its our standing saturday night date!!!
Extremely friendly and helpful staff. The pizza was perfect.
Got takeout from here. The supreme pizza I had was some of the best I have had in years.
Always fresh. Fair priced and owners are very friendly!
Sometimes most of the items in the dinner menu run out by 7 pm
Very good food, fast and friendly delivery. I'll order from here again
Great NY style pizza, lots of menu options.
Really great local place. People are nice service us Good food us especially good.
Love this place definitely our go to spot for great food in tampa!
Delicious food, nice and quaint location, and fantastic service!
Pizza, wings and subs are AMAZING! Such a sweet little place!
Amazing food, friendly staff and owners. Highly recommend.
Best place around! In love with the single serving stromboli!!
The food, atmosphere and the owners are awesome. Their food is awesome!!
This place is a little hidden gem. The food is outstanding is so is the price
Extremely good food, most unrated pizzeria.
Great pizza by the slice, great wings, reasonable prices.
I love this place every time I go the food is great and the customers Service is awesome!!!
Ziti is Amazing, Great Garlic Knots, and the Pizza was perfect!
Great love it real good food friendly owners..
Great food..awesome staff..I will keep coming back!!
Love this place! Great food and service and owners are very friendly
Rest In Peace served love in every slice
Super friendly staff and great pizza!!
Excellent specialty pizza and cannoli poppers
Great NY style pizza! Friendly staff.
Awesome food and owner is super nice and inviting
Best calzone I've had, it was huge and cheap!
Delicious pizza can't wait to go back!
Great food!!! Deluxe Calzone is my favorite!!
Best pizza in all of Tampa
Best people, food, service and they love the community back.
Best pizza ever!! The magraita pizza.... To die for!
Sooooooo gooooddddd whatever you do don't ask them to alter the way it's baked they got it down packed.
Food took forever to make, and what came out was not worth the wait, the only saving grace was the cannolis
Wings are delicious, the staff is great and it is overall a great place.
Best pizza in Tampa.
Love the food and the owners more!
Amazing! Delicious food, great service!
Nice owners. Great food.
Amazing pizza and service is excellent
Friendly service and excellent food!
Best pot pie and garlic knots ever!!!
Great food and Maggie an staff are friendly
Great food and canoli poppers are the best!
Great pizza...super great service
Great Baked Ziti...Hugh serving & good service!!!
Always so good!!
Pizza was great...service was great
Best margeritha pizza ever.
Best pizza to hit tampa in YEARS!!
Best White Cheese pizza in town....
Good food and customer service is good
Excellent Pizza and custommer service
Excellent food, friendly service
Get the garlic knots and thank me later.
They are great!
Great food, service, delivery!
Pretty damn good pizza.
Best pizza in town ever
Wow this place is legit!
Great food, nice owners, great food, great food, get it, great food.
All the food is delicious 😋 …
Literally so good!!!!!!!!!!
order if you have not before!!!!!!!!
Buffalo wings bursting wit flavor
Love the homemade lasagna
Delicious!!!
Wonderful
The best
Great place, good staff.
Excellent pizza spot.
Food is exceptional.
Pizza is very good.
The foods good i like this place
Great pizza!
It's not the same no more
Had to wait for someone to pay.
Best pizza ever
If you only knew
Excellent pizza!
Always good
Great
Delicious
Always on point!!
Really good
Fresh made food
Delicious homemade food!!!!
best pizza ever
Fantastic pizza.
A hidden gem!
Great food !!!!
So delicious!!!!
Good pizza and good Atmosphere👍🏾
The pizza is so good here that I legitimately just order a cheese pizza. Obviously their other pizzas are amazing too. I'm the type of person to throw away a crust or at least eat it with ranch but this is like the one place where I eat the whole crust plain.
(Translation) Very good 👌
(Original)
Muy bueno 👌 …