Reviews of Theo's Neighborhood Pizza, Magazine. (Restaurant) in New Orleans (Louisiana).

Theo's Neighborhood Pizza, Magazine

317 Reviews

170 Comments

Restaurant

Pizza restaurant

4218 Magazine St, New Orleans, LA 70115, United States

Description

Information of Theo's Neighborhood Pizza, Magazine, Restaurant in New Orleans (Louisiana)

Discover the opening times, the location, contact, popular times, photos and real reviews by internet users.

This place has a very good rate, they treat their customers well and you’ll feel welcome, super recommended

Map

Open hours of Theo's Neighborhood Pizza, Magazine

Popular times

Monday

Tuesday

Wednesday

Thursday

Friday

Saturday

Reviews of Theo's Neighborhood Pizza, Magazine

Candace

I wandered in from the cold weary and hungry. I left revived and warm. Friendly folks guided through my first visit with the menu. I got a lunch special. The prosciutto and mozzarella sandwich is definitely worth a repeat. It kisses you with fresh taste at first bite. I’m regretting that I didn’t get the sweet spinach salad. I’ll be back!! Thank you.

Wendy P

Pizza and wings were good. Pizza sauce needed a little more seasoning but it still had a great, crispy crust. This place is a family favorite.

Alexa W

FOOD WAS SO GOOD WE STARTED EATING BEFORE I COULD TAKE PICS Food was delicious!!!! Very friendly staff and good for kids. Staff was great with them. I can't say enough about how good it was. It was a little loud but I think just because acoustics of the building. But the crust, toppings, sauces and cheese was full of flavor kudos on crunchy crust!!! We had the 14 inch meathead and son had 10 inch pepperoni and we got cheese bread.

Alyse P.

You can not go wrong with their lunch specials. The value and price are well worth it. It is a cozy spot on Magazine with solid quality of food, good portions, and a polite team behind the counter.

Adam Rogers

Great pizza, good flaky crust. I heard Theos Pizza was really good and they didn't disappoint!

Jon Miller

Just happened upon this place by chance and y'all, the food and service was incredible! Pizza was filling and delicious and the crust had a perfect crunch! The breadsticks were just as delicious as were the caprese and ceaser salads! The $8 special was a great deal and topped it off with some $1.50 domestics! Great atmosphere too! Will definitely return!

Maryanne Cerise

Everything was great. Staff more professional and crust on pizza was perfect. If I had to choose our of either Magazine location or Veterans location, Magazine is the best.

Liam Masterson

Pizza was really good. Real stuff. Ambiance was alright, but we went around lunch so if we went around dinner time it would have been crazier. Shout out to them for the arcade machine. Got to level 12 on Galaga. Nice.

Sandra Oz

The best pizza I've had! Great beer! Great service!-- parking can be limited due to metered parking and within a neighborhood but a must. Family friendly.

Brett Moore

Pizza is always on point. Nice, little collection of beer and wine. Lance took wonderful care of us and recommended the best stuff. Great dive for some local pizza. Never a disappointment.

Andi Papoutsis

Great service, friendly and very clean. The pizza and wings were on point.

Nicole Coleman

Service was superb! The Gluten Free crust here is delicious, so are the 'naked' wings, which are also a great option for people with who need Gluten Free options. Thank you for being so accommodating and getting my order out so quickly!

Crissy Bushman

Kid and family friendly! Ms Packan machine too! They have a great thin crust pizza and excellent salads (even though they are basic and nothing fancy) They are usually very busy so you'll have to wait a bit, but it's definitely worth it! The staff is always very friendly and helpful when you need something. This is a great locals spot!

Ashleigh Sosa

Maggie just took care of me and she was awesome! Super friendly and great customer service skills- definitely an employee worth holding on to. I got there fast and had to wait for my pizza to finish and we had great conversations the whole time. The food here is great. Local New Orleans born pizza place I highly recommend.

Deanna Pritchard

Service was great. Loved the spontaneous karaoke that was happening.

Sam Drew

So friendly, great pizza, great price. I don’t think I can give it any negative criticism. This place is a great family spot or great food for your next birthday or office party. I cannot count the number of times we’ve been, and have enjoyed every single one. Also highly recommended the Canal location, usually not slammed.

Linda Trujillo

If You ever make it to New Orleans? Insurance stop by Theo's neighborhood pizza place the food is amazing the prices. Are very good. The service was wonderful. I'm not crazy about pizza, but I Would eat there again. The pizza was amazing. Best I have ever eaten.

Miranda Walker

I go here often because my brother is a huge fan. Pizzas are good, especially the buffalo chicken. Plain pepperoni is my favorite pepperoni pizza around. You seat yourself here, but staff is super helpful with anything you need. There are a few tv’s if you want to watch a game in a quieter atmosphere, which I often see people doing.

Theresa Ortego

Best gluten free pizza I have tasted. The crust is oiled on the bottom before it's cooked, adding a layer of flavor to what is usually completely without good flavor when it's gluten free. Fresh squeezed lemonade makes a great pairing. Highly recommend!

Juan Cervantes

The meathead pizza was delicious!

Tave Fitzpatrick

Pizza’s great but don’t discount the subs and salads. Highly recommend the club sandwich and the super soaker salad.

Jeff Wayland

The pizza here is fine. For the price, we kind of expected a bit more but it was decent pizza. They also have a good beer selection but not as much on tap as I would have liked. If you can, get one of the two tables outside and watch the world down magazine street

Claudia Garcia

Very surprised! Had visited other locations in the past and they were ok. This visit the pizza was amazing and the cheese bread to die for! Definitely giving them another try when I'm around the neighborhood.

Rob Reynolds

I eat here about once a week. The staff is wonderful and the pizza is great. Meg is especially kind to me every time we see each other. For the best pizza in NOLA, come here.

Christine Fitzpatrick

Theo's has been a staples for us for years! The pizza & salad are so good! And the best ranch!

Damien C

Good draft beers. Good pizzas. Probably my favorites so far (in new Orleans). I'll be going there again when hanging around with friends.

Joe Gerrity

Best buffalo chicken pizza anywhere uptown and the rest of the pizzas are good too. It's a bit pricy, they don't deliver without using a 3rd party service which makes it even more expensive, and sometimes they're pretty far off in estimating when to show up for a pickup. Still delicious though. I ate there last night in fact.

Bumble Bee Productions

Love the sweet salad and vegetarian pizza… great place

Jeff T

I don't want to tell you about this place. I want to keep it to myself. Thin crust pizza was cooked to perfection. I enjoyed every bite. I would have got the special which was very nicely priced, but I wasn't alone.

Mary Lichty

We are visiting from San Francisco where there is an abundance of amazing food—-and we love good food! We decided to lay low and just get some pizza tonight and ordered the Meathead and the Arti-Garlic. Both were amazing! All 6 of us procaimed this some of the best pizza we ever had. Come and enjoy some damn good pizza!

Erica De La Rosa

Good pizza, casual atmosphere and friendly staff. I wouldn't always opt for a buffalo chicken pizza but theirs was delicious. Check out Theo's when you want a Good neighborhood spot and not mass made delivery.

Andrew Kovach

My husband and i have been visiting nola for several weeks now, enjoying the people , music and food. We love it here and have eaten at alot of restaurants. The one restaurant we have enjoyed most is Theos pizza. The staff is so refreshingly friendly and go the extra mile to make you feel welcome and comfortable. On top of all that the pizza is fantastic! As far as im concerned great pizza in a fun warm welcoming environment beats the heck out of high end over priced eats delivered with an attitude i.e.cochon. thank you theos for a great experience!

Tegan Jones

Food is decent, but don't try to pay with cash. Even if your bill is $50, they won't take a $50. :/

Theboredand busyhousewife

This place was surprisingly very good. We had never heard of it, but it was open on a hot day and we had got off the street car too early so we lucked out! LUCKILY! Small, good service, great pizza!

Allison

Good pizza, different ways to customize your pie and you can build your own. Gluten free dough is available, though there is a high chance of cross contamination so I do not recommend it for people with Celiacs and serious allergies. The chicken also contains gluten, I am not sure why but I believe that is also a cross contamination issue as the chicken is shipped in pre cut. They do not have vegan cheese, but you can easily have a pie made without cheese, just make sure to specify no cheese. The drink cups are huge and they use pellet ice. This particular location is quite small so not for large groups.

Lacey Harris

Best pizza in the city! We always have a great experience here. Thank you for the excellent food and service.

John Foard

Pretty much never disappoints. Super thin crust. Wednesday night can get heavy with children as parents wash down half off bottles of wine. If you venture, just indulge.

Bryan Davis

Theo's has some of the best thin crust pies in the city. During the recent Pizza Wars excursion, I tried a number of pies throughout the city. Even after ten forays to separate restaurants, Theo's was the best all around pie. The crust the right chew, the sauce has some spice and substance, and the toppings are bountiful. The appetizers are ok, so just focus on pies. Delicious stuff.

Robert Oakwood

Pizza was ok. Mardi Gras special offering by the slice (cheese and pepperoni only). Service is amazing. Plus I accidentally left my hearing aid at the table. By the time I realized, they had bussed my table. But they had secured my earring aid and had it waiting for me at the counter when I ran back for it. A special thanks for looking out!!!

Joseph M

Drove from houston texas, with sinusitis, a stye on my eye, taste buds weren't working....a disaster mix for my weekend at New Orleans. .... then I came to Theo's.....and God said...."Smell the pizza and the awesome Greek salad...taste the ingredients and be happy and be fruitful my son" and so I did. Great place, great people, epic pizza...so epic it returned my sense of smell and taste ;)

Aikido of New Orleans

Our usual spot for takeout pizza. Yummy crust, well spiced sauces and a gluten free option for my GF 👍🏾

Lee J Pedesclaux

Theo's has great pizza and everything! That picture is from a church around the corner. The Crow and it's flock are everywhere in Nola! Like a Hitchcock movie!!! No worries 1 L❤️ve

Valerie Bouldin

This was the first warm meal that I had after Hurricane Ida. I am so grateful that they were open and hardly remember what it tasted like.

Del Dejean

Most often we take out. Good pizza, good veg options. Thin crust but not as thin NY style thin. One of the family faves.

Cassi B.

I love pizza and this place delivers. Great atmosphere, delicious pizza, many choices, and a decent price. Next time I'm in Nola, I'll definitely eat there again!

Stephanie Phelan

Pizza was amazing. Love the eclectic decor and layout inside. Friendly service and great beers too. Worth the stop

Sam Hughes

Made my own pizza with extra mozzarella and shredded parmesan. The absolute BEST pizza I have ever had. 1000/10 I will deffo come back next time I'm in nola

Joes Boat

Love Theo’s. Very good Caesar salad and the pizza is always chock full of high quality toppings. Best thin crust pizza in town.

Maitê Silva

Great place with an amazing pizza and the best waiter I’ve ever had! If you’re in doubt, do yourself a favor and get in, you won’t regret it!

Vinnie M

I had the gluten free pizza.. wasn't horrible but definitely not one of the better I've had.. a bit overpriced for what it was. soggy crust.. generic sauce.. but overall edible enough.

Marshall “Griff” Griffiss

Awesome pizza. If you are in the area looking for something to eat. Stop by Theo's

Patrick Bordnick

Wonderful local pizza joint. Great selection of wine, beer, and soft drinks. This is our families go to place for pizza!

Peter Gervais

I wait 11 months out of the year for the Thai shrimp bahn mi pizza. 11 fkn months. I said the same thing, "well if it's that good it should be year round!" Y'all talk to manageMENTaah.

Thomas Krajewski

This is a good pizza joint, they have enough alternatives for non pizza havers and during busy mardi gras they go to pizza by the slice. the pizza is good not great.

Chris Thayer

Really good pizza. Small, but interesting selection of beers. Very friendly staff.

Gary LaKemper

Great friendly service. Good selection of pizzas. I eat here every time I am in Nola

Monique Perry

The crunchy thin crust Pizza and naked, well seasoned wings are amazing.

Jonathan thomas

Great wings. 5 stars izza 3 stars. Would be 6 stars if galaga worked

Eyelizabeth Davis

Can Eye just say .... The staff is absolutely AMAZING. Atmosphere is divine and as far as the 🍕 Oh My Stars Eye could eat it EVERYDAY …

Paul Askew

This is the best pizza around , I've looked for some time and I haven't found any better. Nice job guys.

Pat Harris

The pizza was great, salad was excellent and the server was friendly and helpful. Great neighborhood place.

Maudie Massey

Blackened shrimp pizza was very good

JIll Reed

Great thin crust pizza, salads were good size with homemade dressing and friendly staff ❤️

Deanna DuPont

What can be said that hasn’t already been said. The pizza is addicting! The pizza is fantastic! THE PIZZA!!! It’s my fix!!!

Beau Cass

Meathead pizza (I add pineapple for max belly satisfaction), their all veggie is real good, their naked wings are so good

K LeBeouf

Some 9f the best pizza in town. Love their crispy crust!!

Bert Loftin

Great service and stellar pizza!

Carolyn

Classic no-frills pizza. Friendly and helpful staff but a bit pricey for the quality.

Jim Henschel

Casual pizza joint with very good pizza. Nice, clean place. I would recommend!

Jumbo Fretts

I'm from Kansas City and The's is the next best pizza I have had.

Anna Anderson

Very good service, pizza is excellent and the atmosphere can't be beat.

Christopher Flurry

Fantastic pizza and service. The Pac-man machine is cool too!

Frank Garcia

Friendly and attentive folks, they cook up some very tasty food. Enjoy sitting in eating, talking and listening to the music.

Jason Starrett

Best pizza Uptown! Great service and price as well.

Shae Murders

Great service and my favorite caesar and pizza!

Karen Norfleet

My favorite pizza joint in NOLA. Great sandwiches and salads, too.

Gary Gerson

Great pizza with the freshest of ingredients, and a great salad. Neighborhood treasure!

Trinity Rogers

Super friendly staff and great pizza!

Melissa Capps

Very sweet staff and great food! Nice, chill atmosphere as well.

Pamela Semken

Great lunch spot while walking Magazine street. Food is fresh and well prepared!

Kevin Lynn

Great portions and friendly staff!

Todd McHenry

Friendly neighbourhood pizza place - a very unique base (crispy and flaky)

Samuel Bel

Fun and comfortable atmosphere. I just wish the pizza would be a little better.

Jennifer Inberg

Love this place, the best crispy pizza, delicious!

Meda Mccombs

Just the best pizza in the city.All good.

Gino Gisondo

Quick and easy. Really high quality pizza.

Kraig Richard

Imagine a really good pizza with a lot of stuff on it....then imagine. A pizza maker putting on even more

Sandy de Bie

Yummy pizza and beer Can't go wrong here.

Bryan Briggs

Hawaii 5-0 add pepperoni and jalapenos is my jam.

Erika Buxton

Awesome service, great atmosphere, great food!

Isaias Torres

Awesome service and food!! Great first experience!!

Scott Dunbar

They do gluten free!

Connor John Sullivan

Best hot wings in Nola. Great price too.

Dwight Payne

Not a pizza guy but the staff makes it pleasant.

Jenn Johnson

Great sandwiches

Robert Blackwell

Fun spot! Friendly people with a comfortable feel.

Jose Antonio Mahmoud LLanos

excellent service and the pizzas are spectacular!!!

Chris McMorris

Friendly service great pizza

Kat McCann

I am picky about my pizza. Theo's is about the only pizza I will eat!

Mark Gunnell

Fantastic pizza! Great service!

Sumit Bhatia

Awesome friendly neighborhood pizzeria. Thank you guys!

Kent Simmons

If it don't smell like Theo's, I ain't eatin it!

Cain Walls

The restaurant have great pizza

Ninja Mbita

BEST pizza in New Orleans !

Daniele Di Crescenzo

As Italian I must say that this has nothing to do with pizza, but others may find it OK.

Carmen U

I love the Bacon Bleu salad!!! Its my obsession

Karan Sethi

Good pizza but slow service

Perry Linares

Good service, good staff, clean, nice ambiance, ok food

Michael Bauman

Great slice

K I

Great service. Delicious wings. Booyah!

Sarah Daigle

Always delicious. Great staff.

Michael Berry

Many people told me to come here. The pizza "got the job done".

Scott McCoy

The pizza and the Personnel are always excellent.

TheDoughman123

Good pizza and good atmosphere.

Andy Hernandez

Amazing service and UNBELIEVABLE FOOD, AMAZING PIZZA

Kenny Temple

Cozy environment and the food is pretty good.

Jess B

I love Jordan, Peggy and Andrew!

kim peterson

We love Theo! Great deal!

Dov Glazer

The hippy pizza is the best!

Ashley Drewes

Pretty good food and quick service.

Howard Williams

Intoxicating smells before walking into the door

Robert McElligott

First time going there OUTSTANDING food. Service

ZarkTiny

Pretty nice neighborhood pizza joint

Coach John

Hands downBest PIZZA in NOLA!

Jen Smith

So good

L. C. Devereaux

Yummy pizza..over priced a bit

Tommy DeHart

Great neighborhood pizza place. Recommend.

Meg Smith

Great Pizza ! Thin crust!!!

Michelle Kospelich Shellabarger

Never never disappoints and the staff are amazing!

Jordan Kay

Why you close at 10p on a Friday night?

Terri Tahvildari

Gluten free pizza available.

Keith Loughrey

Best Spinach salad in town.

Kim Noffke

Best pizza in NOLA

Redo City

Great Pizza

Mae Chapman Casting

Love their Spinach Salad

Kacin Perret

Fantastic pizza in cute setting

James Artus

Best pizza in town

Addison Tackaberry

Caprese pizza is the way to go here

Jonah Dismukes

Good pizza, good service

Davensor Nava

Awesome place with great music.

thong doan

Great fresh pizza.

Nam Nguyen

Best Pizza in New Orleans

love the music

A must stop when in nola

Patricia Pankey

Always super... food, service

Sean O'Grady

Great Pizza!

Sandhill Land Services

Tuesday night pint night

Jrs “RS” Rs

Always 😋 …

Ben G. Green

good spot for a slice

Cherie Nobles

Great pizza!

George Richard Jr

Great Pizza!

Cobwat

Good

Wanda Blansett

Good Pizza 🍕 …

Anita Jorgensen

Pizza was awesome

Dov Glazer

Pizza the way it should be done!

O.G. Original Gentry

Great pies!

Steve Porter

Excellent pizza

Sheila Cooper

Great pizza.

Anakaren Garza

One word: AMAZIIINGG!!!!!

Lori Fonseca Bennett

Very Yummy!

CHERIE Call

Great pizza.

Igal Fatelevich

Great pizza

James Richards

great pizza

Melanie Wilcox

The salad was really good and we got a pizza to go . Everything is expensive here but this was worth it! Staff was really friendly !

Paul Seyler

Always reliable and impressive. Great ingredients, served steaming hot, and a crust that you can't get anywhere else.

Thomas Bretin

(Translation) The food is very good as well as place to take away. (Original) La cuisine est très Bonne aussi bien sûr place qu' à emporter.

Ruxandra Perez

Doug Christensen

Michelle T

Mike Hill

Patrick Reed

Contact

Photos