Reviews of Rosati's Pizza - Milwaukee Bay View. (Restaurant) in Milwaukee (Wisconsin).

Rosati's Pizza - Milwaukee Bay View

260 Reviews

121 Comments

Restaurant

Pizza restaurant

145 W Oklahoma Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207, United States

Description

Information of Rosati's Pizza - Milwaukee Bay View, Restaurant in Milwaukee (Wisconsin)

Discover the opening times, the location, contact, popular times, photos and real reviews by internet users.

This place has a very good rate, they treat their customers well and you’ll feel welcome, super recommended

Map

Open hours of Rosati's Pizza - Milwaukee Bay View

Popular times

Sunday

Monday

Tuesday

Wednesday

Thursday

Friday

Saturday

Reviews of Rosati's Pizza - Milwaukee Bay View

Maria Hernandez

Good pizza! Chicken Alfredo was okay, I didn’t like the chicken itself but the flavor of the Alfredo sauce was good. The tenders were okay too, they were just breaded tenders there was nothing outstanding about them. We went a couple minutes before they closed and the staff was still very friendly and we didn’t feel like we were being rushed at all.

Ozzy Falcon

I’m new to Milwaukee, and am a pizza lover! Rosati’s Pizza definitely met my expectations when trying to find the perfect pizza shop in town to satisfy my pizza needs. Staff was so nice too, there was an order that never got picked up, that they offered me for free instead of having to throw it out! I of course took the kind gesture! All in all, great food and a great experience! Highly recommend!

Janet F

First time. Was it the weather? Barely over 2 miles to get home. The vegetarian deluxe pizza wasn't hot when we started eating it. Had to heat it up. Nice crust, nice presentation with tomato slices on top. But expensive. 3 ingredients. No green or black olives, extra cost. It had mushrooms, onions, and green pepper. Good cheese. So a mixed review. Maybe we'll try their Chicago style deep dish. Nice if we could find a coupon.

Nicholas Whitehead

I have always been a fan of Rosati's. The pizza is good especially for a chain. Plus I love the slice and a soda deal.

Jim burke

Stopped for a slice at lunchtime. Pizza was great. Staff was very friendly. Highly recommend!

Michelle Schoofs

Rosati's Pizza is excellent. Getting a jumbo slice of pizza and a 20 drink for $6 is quick, easy and delicious. Love their sauce on the pizza. For a real treat, their deep dish pizza is a Must! This is a small location/store front. They have 2 small tables along their windows if you want to quickly eat, or in warmer weather, there is an outdoor table as well.

jason winkler

Somehow I didn't know there was a Rosati's in Milwaukee until I drove past. Finally I can get some proper Chicago deep dish here in town! The crust is thicker than Lou Malnati's, and the sauce is chunky. Both pluses in my book. Takes 45 minutes to bake so plan ahead.

Sophia Broomfield

Excellent customer service! Excellent pizza! Love Rosati’s in Bayview 😁

Santos V

Changing my review thank you very much to the New manager for fixing n making up for my order they screw up the first time today on spinach and canadian bacon Calzone n got it correct the 2 time..so thank you very much n looking forward to ordering from yall again more..

Carla Menominee

I had Rosati's regular pizza before and loved it. I was looking forward to the deep dish... I got the pick 4 (sausage,mushroom,onion & black olives). I only ran across one of the "4" here and there. Where are the toppings? After 2 pieces must have hit only 5 small lumps of sausage, 4 slices of mushrooms! It was all crust, about an inch, and tons of tomatoes. Definitely NOT worth $25.49. 😕 We also bought a thin peperoni pizza and that was excellent!

MANUEL MALDONADO-VILLALOBOS

It is more for carry-out. The staff are very friendly and attentive.

Annabelle

Love Rosatis this location disappointed. 1- we were told our order was going to be ready in an hour and ended up waiting almost 2 hours for a 12 inch pizza. 2-we specifically ordered parmeson and peppers on the side and it didn't have any 3-we did the delivery option, did not realize it would be door dash. Tracking the driver it was clear they were doing other orders and dropping then off which leads to 4- pizza was not hot. Honestly would not even care much about the wait or the forgotten parmeson but the fact that it was not warm was disappointing. The quality and taste of Rosati is good but I don't see us ordering from this place soon I understand businesses are short on workers but maybe just stop doing deliveries if you are not able to deliver a quality product and you are losing customers...

julio cano

Pizza is great... the service ...so so

Nicole E Jacobson

Holy pasta. Huge portions but little flavor. I didn't realize til after that there were meat options I could have added. IDK Lasagna without meat sauce baked into the dish would be??? Great price, huge portion, single order would feed a family of 4 but little offer in flavor profile. If you are looking for simple, you will be satisfied. Take out only. Or delivery Not really a "dine-in" option. It is a pick-up counter with a few barstools to perch while you await your order.

Tammy Ross

My food came very quickly but some items were missing, I called and spoke to the manager she corrected my order and re delivered it with 25 minutes!! impeccable timing ! This was excellent service to me ,the food was hot and delicious 😋 we will definitely order Rosati’s again. …

Jennifer Mahon

Delivery was fast and food was hot! Tasty as always.thanks

Maria Farias

Came in here for the first time to try something new. The jumbo pizza slice was good and served warm. The manger was very sweet and informed me of the Friday special half off their geab-N-go deep dish pizza (which it delicious). The manager even treated my daughter to their cinnamon stick also served warm with a cream cheese frosting dip. First impression are everything and this place made a great one. Polite staff and good food.

jessica gerbing

1st off customer service is excellent however we ordered a take out pizza got it home and all the toppings slid off we waited in store for 20 min for it my kids were starving they were nice and gave my son a cookie he was waiting with me. I called them and asked if I could have one delivered they said no prob. Very kind. I even tipped the guy I felt bad I opened the box and same thing with this pizza most of the pizza had zero toppings they all slide to the right like the cheese didnt stick to the pizza or the sauce was thin dont know how that happened. Again i do want to say they had amazing customer service. The pizza was just not right somehow?

Mark P. Behar

Good pizza, but it seemed different from the now closed North & Farwell location. Tasty, but not in the same universe as Zaffiro's thin crust. Lots of different styles of pizza to choose from-- Milwaukee thin crust is my fave, chicago deep dish is also pretty darn good.

Tall Mark

We tried Rosati's for the first time (ever) last night from their Bay View location. We were very impressed with their monster pizza. It was cooked perfectly and was made within the 30 min. they said it would be ready for pick up. We were also pleasantly surprised to see a ranch dipping sauce with our side order of jalapeno poppers. The price reflected the quality. We will be having Rosati's again in the future.

Holly B.

So happy there is a Rosati’s close by. We love their pizza. Deep dish, thin crust it’s all good. Plus they offer Italian beef as a pizza topping...my favorite (few places do). We’ve only ever gotten delivery. Delivery is always quicker than expected & driver’s are always friendly and courteous. Happy customer.

Kaitlin Gainer

After giving this location a 2and chance due to a mix up of orders I decided to try their calzone last night and it was DELICIOUS not too greasy and the cheese was perfectly melted. Marinara dipping sauce was good too will be back in the future

Daniel Morales

Amazing service 👏 and delicious pizza 🍕, fries and wings. Customers service so excellent 👌 .

Kira Hagquist

I am thrilled to deliver the news that Italian beef and pineapple should indeed go on a pizza together! Onions, pepperoni and olives, too. I am equally thrilled to tell you that Rosati's makes a damn fine pizza! It got a little soggy toward the middle after a while but it was huge and wet, what do you want!? I'm like way too excited about this pizza.

vania aguila sanchez

I love this place everyone super friendly and the best wigs ever

Che S

Just wanted to leave a great review for delivery driver JENNIFER! She’s always right on time, friendly, and eager to point out coupons for our future orders! We wish she could be our driver all the time! (The food is delicious too!)

Cole Adam

Sauce, crust and cheese are all on point. A little more greasy than I usually go for, but hey it's pizza. Sausage is better than their pepperoni. Gluten free crust was great. My wife is gluten free and I am not, I don't usually care for GF crusts and I was pleasantly surprised.

Craig Burbey

I tried the 5 buck lunch special and got a slice of cheese and sausage. I could have waited a few minutes to get a slice out of the oven but opted for what was available. It was lukewarm when I got home so a minor nuke was all it needed. It was flavorful and the slice was good sized. Can't wait to order the deep dish and Italian beef.

Maria

Always the best fresh food pizza

Shanda Mm

This pizza is beyond pizza dreams. So pretty I had to IG it..Thin crust sausage pepperoni x cheese with wings & a salad. OMG even the salad is phenomenal nothing here is basic. Also they have their own delivery in house fast and hot...I love this place.

Lisa Kauffman

Disappointed. Ravioli was almost inedible. Way too much garlic and very oily. I usually order the ravioli, it's my favorite. This time it was just bad.

Jon Christiansen

Pizza is very good, but they never seem to have more than a slice or two available. If you want anything more than cheese or pepperoni you have to wait...and each time I've been there it's been very busy with a ton of people waiting in the VERY SMALL public area. It's a new place and whomever is managing it doesn't seem to have grasped how to make enough product available during the very busy lunch rush. When and if they get that problem solved they could be 5 stars. My 3 star is for the taste of the food only.

Karl Walesch

Really good food for a fast pizza. Beats Dominos or Toppers any day. I've ordered from here 4 or 5 times now. Every time it was good, but every time it was wrong. I mean, the food is still good, and they always fix it, but every single time the order has had something wrong.

Brandi “McBooty” W

Was doing uber eats delivery- slooooowww. Tons of orders coming in, behind schedule, long waits. Smelled delicious though

Kev south

I love everything they make ! I am from New Orleans and I moved here recently temporarily for a project at jci. These guys have excellent flavor on everything I have ordered which has been now and including tonight and never a disappointment.hreat job guys even when I push the delivery time close to closing u always come through. I love flavor of food raised and lived in a city that embraces great taste !

Nichole Schwartz

Im so glad i finally tried this place! We ordered an 18" mushroom and italian sausage double dough and a couple of appetizers and everything was amazing! The whole family loved it. The prices were very reasonable and the guy on the phone was really nice. Great job you guys! I will definitely be ordering from you again soon.

Patti Liston

This is the second time I order a calzone with extra cheese and no oregano, and received very little cheese and loaded with oregano. The person who took the order wrote it correctly, but....evidently the cook does what they want. 🤨 and it was barely warm. …

Karoline Bayer

Just ordered from there first time. Great flavor,but our 18inch was not cooked through in the middle of the pizza. It was hard to pick up and very doughy.

Noneof Yourbusiness

Been coming here ever since they opened. I’ve tried every pizza around the area and have been disappointed. This place knows how to make deep dish or any other style pizza. They have many options to choose from the menu and I’ve had many delicious items off the menu. It’s a must try experience!!!! Soooo good!

Pugs Paik

Speaking as a Chicago Native, the stuffed pizza is NOT a Chicago-style stuffed pizza. It has more to do with a calzone than stuffed pizza. This was basically regular pizza with pizza dough over the top and sauce on top of that. This does not a Chicago-style stuffed pizza make. A Chicago style stuffed pizza should be made in a pan, which this clearly was not. The pan should be buttered and then have regular thickness pizza dough pressed into the pan. A layer of pizza sauce is spread on the bottom, then toppings, then cheese. On top of all of that, a paper thin layer of pizza dough is placed. On top of the top layer of dough, a chunky marinara is added. This was not that.

B Grizz

Don't know about the bad reviews - this is the 2nd time we have ordered delivery from Rosati's on Oklahoma in Milwaukee. Both times food has arrived hot and absolutely delicious! We certainly will order again. And again. And... :) 1st time we got chicken parm dinner and a thin crust pizza (came with green olives instead of black, but was still great) 2nd time we ordered the Cheef sandwich and a double-dough pizza with fried ravioli side. I ate twice as much as I planned, just couldn't stop Looking forward to trying more menu items. Thank you Rosati's!

Patty Zastrow

Good no frills Italian food, not pricey. My son loved the chicken parmesan. The chicken was cooked well. We we're supposed the ravioli was deep fried with sauce on the side.

Cano Alicea

I love this pizza.but today I go there and I ask the lady if there any slices pepperoni because I don't see none and she says no..then I ask are they making any .and she says no..it look like the owner was there giving a interview to.. that was very sad.. Prolly won't ever go back..

Glen Hutchison

Food is good, when they have it. Tried to order two items, they were out of both because their "truck wouldn't be there until tomorrow". Now, in fairness, this is a newer location. If my next experience is better, I will revisit this review.

Matthew Mache

Friendly staff made my experience a great one! The pizza is very fresh with a ton of veggies on my thin crust pizza!! I will definitely be going back to try the deep dish!

Lasha Beaton

They have a lunch special with a slice of pizza and a soda for $5 😍 it was definitely worth it. I also love the bread sticks. They have there own garlic butter sauce that's amazing 👌😍🙌 …

Bradley LaRosa

They were so busy, but the two people working where the best! They handled that place well. Raise and promotion definitely deserved!

Jeanette Hohnke

I love this pizza. $5. For a jumbo slice and a Coke. I've also had delivery to my home The staff is courteous and prompt. It's become my go to pizza place.

R F

Consistently Friendly Manager and Team, spotless restaurant, delicious deep dish. Speedy and hospitable service! Wonderful experience.

Andrew Maslanka

Friendly staff and very tasty pizza.

JM Aubrey

This place is so popular it has pizzas flying around to every corner of the city. Its high end for pizza so u will need to have a little extra money.

Cody

This is one of the best pizzas I have ever had. I am so happy that they are opening a Bay View location. I can not wait until they open. Again best pizza I have ever had.

Lunessia

Customer Service-very friendly Food - Large slice deal and pizza a while back, both largely disappointing. Highly bland. Does not serve amazing pizza like the menomonee falls one

Mike Topping

Good pizza, but very inconsistent have had undercooked and also burnt pizza from them, they resolve it but need to get better consistency. Pickup times are never right, always 10-20 minutes past quoted ready time.

Angela C

Ordered parmesan chicken the first time it was good so I decided to order it again since it's close got it the chicken was chewy you can only get like two or three bites out of the whole chicken breast cuz it was all stuck together and chewy so I wouldn't recommend it

Debi Burzynski

Love the deep dish and thin crust....thats all weve yried so far. Sausage and sauce are delicious. Our go to pizza place now!

Ali Maddox

Im giving 5 stars because of the amazing Delivery Driver I got, Jennifer. I love her personality and how compassionate she is about her job and her Customers.

Senia Bravo

The $5 deal is good but when I got an 18" it was undercooked &the wings were so tiny. I've never seen wing so tiny lol

adrienne scholfield

Clean lobby. Pizza is so good.

David Junior King

This is my favorite place for pizza because I love deep dish very original.

Tom Valentine

One of the best high end pizza places on Milwaukee south side. Great pizza..... And cannoli.

james hill

One of the best pizza places in Milwaukee.

Brad Gray

My pizza was fresh and delicious! I got the $5 special , a slice with a bottled soda!

Joel Rivera

Good deep dish pizza, crust is nice and sturdy, online ordering needs a pay-in-store / pay driver cash option.

Anayelly Macedo

AMAZING CUSTOMER SERVICE ! MADISON IS GREAT SUPER FRIENDLY AND ALWAYS MAKES THE BEST PIZZA !

ME vs ME KING

Coming from Chicago, thay have been 1 of the best place for a pizza. I would recommend

Marie Burrows

If you like deep dish Chicago style pizza, this is wonderful!

Nan Lann

Chicago deep dish and calzone! Both were outstanding. Got it delivered - very friendly staff.

Samuel Colon

Never had a bad moment from here. Worth your money, good pizza.

Faby López Franco

I was a bit disappointed with their grilled chicken sandwich. There was more lettuce and onion than chicken. Was not worth its price to me.

Andrew Sawyer

Awesome service great Chicago style stuffed pizza

Toni Marunowski

Not too bad for a Chicago chain. If you like that sort of thing

Scott Espeseth

Great pizza and you can’t beat the $5 Lunch special!!

Rick Picoldi

Ordered a small pizza 🍕.pepperoni,black olive.very good. …

frederick marshall

Pretty good food their stuff Pizza very close to the best

Kelly Kurpiewski

Great food and service.

A GARNER

Pizza was great 👍🏽

John Duchac

Very good pizza and wings! Great customer service!!

Diane Thomas

Very nice & friendly

Maria Russ

Very expensive quality is not bad quantity not worth it for the price

Timothy Paez

big portions for the price, made fresh and tasted fresh and good customer service

Greg Ahl

Pizza by the slice..... pretty tasty!

Destinee

Best deep dish in town and the fried ravioli is amazing!

Ch Smith

The employees are amazing, the pizza is delicious!

Melissa Bush

I have never tasted food so good! I am 100% serious!

Consuelo-Anya Guerrero

Breaded mushrooms are absolutely delicious!!

Isaac Klein

Good pizza and fast service with good employees.

Rhonda White

Good pizza,Nice version of Chicago style....

Cyd Liechty

Amazing Chicago style pizza...

Raymond Kalski

Great taste for a nice price 👍🇺🇸 …

MisGo Getta

Love their $5 deal

Mrs Sara Ninham

Delicious as always!

Shawn S

Bread sticks are good.

Mohamed Habeb

Great angel good taste

J. J. Flores

Tasty!!

Ollie Heath

Lasagna was so delicious!!!

Nayda B

It's okay high priced though.

Antonio Stevens

Great food and great service

Victoria Wall

Best pizza EVER

Mary M

Nice tasty pizza

Tracy Daddario

Pizza and lasagna are fantastic

Jeremy Schoeberle

Good food great staft

april smith

Great pizza!!

Sarah Ruiz

awesome pizza

Cristina Rodriguez

Bay View, the best.

Peter Balistreri

Excellent pizza!

Mitchel lee

Yum

Brian Kucaj

Decent food

Chris HFE

Clean Restaurant

Jose Mendez

Excellent place

Ray Potrykus

Always high Quality food and great portions and prices are fair for the high standards ….. Just wish they had their own delivery drivers…..

Indializ Agron

(Translation) Excellent today, very rich and delicious pizza, freshly made, warm, excellent time, excellent service, to watch a movie with my family 😍😍😍 (Original) Excelente el día de hoy pizza muy rica y deliciosa recién echa calientita llegan tiempo excelente servicio para ver una película con mi familia 😍😍😍

Erica Cruz

(Translation) Very good this pizza I recommend it (Original) Muy buena esta pizza la recomiendo

Santiago Salgado Talamantes

(Translation) Excellent flavor! Personally I love pizza without a doubt a very good option. (Original) Excelente sabor!!! Personalmente me encanto la pizza sin duda una muy buena opcion.

Mario Ramirez

Milwaukee Moyet

JCITYMKE29

Gina Gruenewald

Bryan Dellis

Tamika Burns

nikorr1

Contact

Photos