Reviews of Eddie Martini's. (Restaurant) in Milwaukee (Wisconsin).
Eddie Martini's
8612 W Watertown Plank Rd, Wauwatosa, WI 53226, United States
Description
Information of Eddie Martini's, Restaurant in Milwaukee (Wisconsin)
Discover the opening times, the location, contact, popular times, photos and real reviews by internet users.
This place has a very good rate, they treat their customers well and you’ll feel welcome, super recommended
Map
Open hours of Eddie Martini's
Sunday
Closed
Monday
4:30–8 pm
Tuesday
4:30–8 pm
Wednesday
4:30–8 pm
Thursday
4:30–8 pm
Friday
4:30–9 pm
Saturday
4:30–9 pm
Popular times
Sunday
16 | |
---|---|
17 | |
18 | |
19 |
Monday
16 | |
---|---|
17 | |
18 | |
19 |
Tuesday
16 | |
---|---|
17 | |
18 | |
19 |
Wednesday
16 | |
---|---|
17 | |
18 | |
19 |
Thursday
16 | |
---|---|
17 | |
18 | |
19 | |
20 |
Friday
16 | |
---|---|
17 | |
18 | |
19 | |
20 |
Reviews of Eddie Martini's
Eddie Martini’s wasn’t on our radar until a few weeks ago and I’m sure glad that we tried it out! It was such a great experience, across the board. We were able to get a seat in the dining room and had a filet and a dry aged rib eye. Both were incredible. We also had drinks to match the name of the restaurant. The staff did an amazing job and everyone was incredibly hospitable and accommodating. I would absolutely put Eddie Martini’s up against all the other steak houses in the area.
On a whim my father suggested we go here. At 5:10 on a Monday night we got the last available table, so plan ahead! The food and drinks were fantastic - as a long time martini aficionado I ordered the Eddie Martini and it was exquisite. The lobster bisque was outstanding, and the filet mignon was divine. There's no official dress code but most customers were in business casual or beo. The service was excellent (despite our lack of style), and if you're looking for something special we highly recommend it.
Great ambience, friendly staff and excellent food. Good for a family outing or for business lunch or dinner. Was here couple of times and they even have the wagyu beef steaks which is awesome. I am a raw oyesters fan and one of the best oyesters I have had in a while. They do not have oyesters in their menu so you have to ask specifically. The crab cakes were also delicious. Tasted real and not like any fake meat.
Food and waitstaff were excellent. Food came out fresh and delicious. Bartender was consistent with drinks and service.
We were at Table 21 which is great for bigger groups. Wonderful service and the food was excellent from the seafood tower to the steaks and the deserts. Excellent place. Highly recommended.
What a special surprise this restaurant was! From appetizers to dessert to drinks to service, five stars! Shout out especially to Amber and her co-workers for providing an exceptional dining experience!
I have not had a bad experience here in the last 10 years. Everything is always cooked to perfection. We always get the brussel sprouts. The service is always on point. I enjoy the atmosphere and I love that everyone working is wonderful. They're more than willing to let you drop flowers or anything of for your table ahead of your reservation.
The service here is top notch!!! To start they actually call you to confirm reservation! Love it! All the staff is friendly and courteous. Your water glass never goes below 2 fingers gotta keep hydrated with the strength of their cocktails. That brings me to the 🍸.the glasses our pre chilled to ensure a perfect drink. I'm a big stoli fan and they our the only place I have found stoli gold served thanks Dr. Bob?😁 Seafood tower is a great way to start your meal no longer served in a big martini glass but stil delicious !! Steaks our large and cooked to perfection. Overall it's pricey but well worth it.!!
This has been my wife & my favorite restaurant in any city or state - hands down!
Lobster Bisque, Filet (& scallop side) & their fish specials cannot be beat. Even their bread and butter is worth bragging about. The consistency of their drinks, ambiance and service make this our 'every special occasion restaurant'.
We were seated right when we arrived which was a little earlier than our reservation. Tried a new app this time, Tempura Shrimp. Went really well with the sriracha aioli. My filet was cooked perfectly. Mashed potatoes were a little too garlicky, but ok. Grasshopper was a nice finish, but tasted a little off/bitter. Probably due to the cosmo prior since my husband said it was fine. Overall the food and service were fantastic!
I've NEVER had a less than amazing dining experience here. The food and service are always impeccable. We both had the macadamia encrusted halibut. The veggies that accompanied the entree were perfectly seasoned and perfectly cooked al dente. I highly recommend dinner there in the near future! A+ 5 stars.
Wonderful experience! Incredible atmosphere, very classy and cozy. Relaxed staff, no pressure and amazing food! If you want to have a memorable night out, you should be here!
Nice little cozy environment. Both wife and I got steaks and I added lobster tail to my dish. Both steaks were ok but nothing to brag about. Garlic mash potatoes were blah, little flavor and very dry. Green beans were good and the Brie plater was just ok too. Nothing really WOW’d us except the service or it would have gotten a lower rating. Just thought for the reviews and the price for the meal it would have been something more to remember.
I enjoyed the experience yet there was a slow start but the appetisers made up for it. I did have crab cakes and Bruschetta. I did have a Caesar salad was greatAnd then I had wine with dinner which was amazing! I had a great time celebrating my sisters wedding she is getting married this weekend! They also had great lobster it was the best Maine lobster I had in a while but was worth it !
Glade we did it and went there! The dessert was great to! Anything you order here is great even people like myself who are on diets for gluten free!
Yum! The filet was cooked perfectly and had great seasoning. It also had crispy edges, which I love. The mashed potatoes were great as well. I will definitely be back!
This place was amazing. The decor, and the bar, in this awesome old house converted to a restaurant are all 10s from me. The waitstaff was quick, courteous, professional and knowledgeable. Had a perfect Tito's vodka martini... dirty dirty of course, and an amazing house cut filet mignon that was to die for. This is a little on the pricey side, but the beef is to die for! So eat up, cause you only live once!
First time going to Eddie Martini's. We arrived a little early for our reservation, so we were seated at the bar, which only had 4 barstools to accommodate for social distancing. It made me feel very comfortable. The bartender was friendly, and our drinks were poured just right.
Once we were brought back to our table, we noticed all of them were well spaced apart. I ordered the double duck, and my partner ordered the New York strip. His steak was cooked and seasoned perfectly. It had a melt in your mouth quality, which is always what we look for. My duck came with one leg and sliced breast. The leg was delicious. I will say the breast was just slightly dry, but still tasty. We ordered 3 sides: asparagus, mashed potatoes, and the Maine lobster mac. The asparagus and potatoes were wonderful. My only complaint about the lobster mac is that there wasn't much lobster in it, but the flavor of the pasta and sauce was delicious.
Our waitress was friendly, and checked on us just the right amount.
All in all, I'll be back.
I have to say this was the best service I’ve received in any restaurant and at 41yrs old I’ve been to quite a few! Such a friendly environment! Thank you to Wayne, and thank you to our servers... To top it off the 8oz Kobe I got for myself and the 6oz Kobe shown in the picture that my wife had bar none best steak we’ve had! Excellent Pinot noir paired with our steaks and overall just an exceptional experience!
First time here, everything about it was so good. Our server June was amazing & Wayne was very accommodating. Will be back! 10/10
From the time you walk in the door to the disappointing time to leave.. is filled in between with a memorable culinary experience...fit for royalty. I ate the best steak that I have ever had the pleasure to introduce to my palate. It was the largest cut Rib Eye steak I ever witnessed. I literally succeed in cutting this steak easily with my butter knife. Honest!!!! It was tender, succulent, and tasted as if it had been infused with butter. Worth every dollar I spent: and that is saying a lot!
I Went here for my birthday dinner with my parents and everything was perfect. Amazing service, fantastic food and a great atmosphere. I highly recommend it for any special occasion.
I need to start off saying that I am used to cooking my own steak, almost always prime or better grade. Eddie Martinis service was excellent but they quality of my NY strip seamed to be choice at best, a bit more chew than I expected for $60. They do offer higher grade steaks for a price of course. The potatoes were delicious, and presentation was very good. My wife had seafood which was mostly good except the extremely overcooked inedible shrimp. Overall we enjoyed our visit and our interactions with the staff were overwhelmingly positive.
Went here for our anniversary. Service was excellent. Overall food was good. My husband liked his steak and lobster. I had dry aged NY strip. Mine was just ok. Garlic mashed potatoes were also just ok. The place seems a little dated to me. They gave us a complimentary dessert which was good. I wanted to love it. I probably won’t go back.
I had the filet, house salad and the table shared corn. My entire party had an amazing meal. We loved it! 5 star service, ambiance and food. Make a reservation!!
Amazing food, service, and drinks. We got drinks before dinner at the bar, delicious steak dinners, and dessert for my birthday.
One of the best dining experiences I’ve had in the city. The staff and waiters made my night magical; They were very attentive, accommodating and had the best manners. If you’re looking for an exceptional dining experience, I HIGHLY recommend Eddie Martini’s.
Disney’s Epcot gives you more scallops than the $38 plate…. Which gives you 4.
Friend across the table last night 10/7 party of 7 didn’t receive the proper cooking of steak. Servers were slow to remove excess plates. Sub par service for “Fine-Dining”.
My filet was juicy and tender. The wait staff was attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. The staff was welcoming. I will be back.
We have never had better service! From the host to the server and all employees we encountered during our visit. Also, our food was perfectly prepared and excellent...melt in your mouth!
Wonderful, attentive, friendly staff. Vintage supper club feel. Not fancy, reliably good, easy to like, recommended for dates and business dinners. Easy parking, cordial coat room. Not so fussy that you're unwelcome if you're not dressed up, totally fine and fitting if you are.
Always exceptional service and great food in a relatively quiet setting with some good music in the background.
It’s a literally a little gem my husband found for us and we go there for our birthday’s and anniversary’s it’s just amazing and elegant with professional service
Delicious food and drinks, and very professional, courteous wait staff. Nice place to celebrate an anniversary.
Dinner was fantastic. We've been here a number of times before over the years but on our last two visits (over the last 3 months), the food preparation has gotten even better. The steaks are phenomenal and the appetizers and desserts do not disappoint. Even our 10 year old found something to love - the lobster mac and cheese.
This place deserves a 10 star. Great food and good ambiance. Staff is very polite.
Lobster bisque is a joke. My lobster dinner was chewy and dry. Could not have been 6oz tails as they said more like 4 oz. My son and grandson had 10oz steaks looked more like 8oz and nothing to brag about (my opinion as I did taste it). Service was excellent But will not be back Waste of money and time
I am going to say right off the bat, WOW!! I had heard such great things about the food and service at Eddie's over the years. But I never got to experience it till last night. It was by far the best dining experience I've had in Milwaukee. I grew up in the Milwaukee area, so I knew the restaurant had never had a chance to go. But wow, the service is impeccable, the steaks are great, and they are so welcoming and inviting. It's definitely a gem of Milwaukee. I would have to say I will be there again someday. This place is a formal dinner or a special occasion kind of restaurant, and so worth the price.
My wife and I went to Eddie Martin's to celebrate her new job. Service was excellent all around. We arrived earlier than our reservation to get drinks at the bar. Cocktails were great - I had a Manhattan made with top shelf liquor and house-marinated Bada Bing cherries. My wife had the Eddie Martini. For dinner, we started with escargot, very good. Main course, I had the dry aged NY strip and my wife had the smaller filet. Both were cooked exactly how we ordered. We were both extremely happy with everything. I ordered the baked potato w/ everything as my side - highly recommend. We were celebrating, so we definitely indulged more than normal, but it was all worth the price. We've eaten at several other high-end steakhouses in the Milwaukee area, and this might be our favorite now.
Always an exemplary culinary experience. The food and more importantly the staff are top notch. Highly recommend.
Amaaaazing food great atmosphere. We had a lovely experience, pricey but worth every penny. Highly suggested for special occasions
Superior service. Creative menu options. All food top notch. Truly a wonderful experience as it has been for a long time. Nice to see.
Outstanding Food and Service As Always!!! This is one of my favorite places to go dine on a weekend. Always left a very happy customer!
Absolutely the best service and food in the city. 100% 5 star.
Had one of the best sirloin steaks I have ever had. It was an 18oz 45 day dry aged steak that was cooked to perfection. Additionally the drinks are strong and the staff is very attentive without hovering. This is a great steak house with a great steakhouse price.
My husband and I were looking for a nice place for food and drinks. His friend is a renowned food consultant and recommended Eddie Martini’s. He mentioned that he’s never been disappointed so we took him up on the suggestion. And I’m SO glad we did! Although the restaurant was fairly busy, we were seated right away. Our waitress was friendly and very knowledgeable about the menu. We both had the lobster bisque. For an entree, my husband ordered the halibut and I had the prime rib. I would have to say it was the BEST steak that I’ve ever had. It was seasoned to perfection. The meal was more on the pricey side but worth the money!!
Eddie Martini's has the best service I have had in Milwaukee thus far. Every person that visited our table was friendly and knowledgeable while maintaining an unobtrusive, seamless dining experience. Will go back for the service experience alone.
We called to place a carry out order for pickup. I had the pleasure of speaking with Wayne, who was extremely polite and gave excellent descriptions of their specials. He guided me through the process of ordering and using a gift card I had. The food was ready to pick up in just a half hour and Wayne came out to my car to give me my order - great service.
The food all traveled well on the way home. Everything was still hot and delicious. I'll definitely be ordering from here again in the future.
The host and wait staff was great. Drink were very good. Took a friend there and it was our first time. My steak was requested rare and was great, my friend wanted medium rare and it was hardly pink. The spices tasted a lot of pepper, over powered the steak and musgrooms
First time going here. Food is fantastic and service treats you like a king. Ill definitely be going back!!
Some of the best food in Wisconsin!
Eddie Martinis never disappoints! The entire staff is friendly and works hard to make sure you have a great experience. Best steaks in Milwaukee
Had a great evening here. We started out with lobster bisque, then steaks, and creme brulee for dessert. Great spot. Service was on their game.
The best place ever. Staff is amazing and Wayne is amazing too!
It was spectacular as always. Our waiter was exceptional! The food was perfection. We were celebrating both my husband and my birthdays with family which we have a blast with. Thank you Eddie's
My boyfriend and I were visiting Milwaukee from Nashville. We were planning to go to Cheesecake factory but the wait was too long so were went to Eddie Martini's instead. The drinks here are delicious and strong. I had the salmon and it was pretty good but it’s a steakhouse so I wasn't expecting a fish dish to be as good as the steak. My boyfriend had the dry aged ribeye and he loved it! Our waiter was very nice and we had a great conversation with him. The atmosphere was very relaxing and we had a memorable night.
Ate here for the 2nd time last night, and had a wonderful dinner! The service is excellent from the moment you walk in the door. I had the Dry Aged Prime Sirloin and a Caesar Salad, both were very good. My husband had the Warm Spinach Salad and an off-menu special of 45 day dry-aged NY Strip and it was EXCELLENT. I was definitely jealous! Of course his steak was double the price of mine 😉
You definitely get what you pay for here- great food and exceptional service.
Talk about a place to treat yourself. After dinning here you realize how good service is hard to come by as this place does everything right. I dined at the bar and felt perfectly comfortable. The steak I had was among one of the best ones I have eaten in my life. They have a great selection of spirits and was surprise of there beer selection. Not for a casual diner, but definitely a most do or a perfect place for drinks, romantic night or or business meetings.
Really great service from all staff members we encountered! Beef Tenderloin was cooked just how I wanted and my other party member's NY Strip was perfect. I didn't like the fact there were two stripes of anchovies on my ceasar salad; I know most ceasar dressing has anchovies in them but that doesn't mean I want to see two long stripes of them on top of my salad without warning. That kind of threw me off. Other than that I really enjoyed my time here.
Our daughter and her husband gave us dinner at Eddie Martini's for our 37th wedding anniversary. We arrived approximately an hour after our reservation along with other diners stuck in traffic for an hour because an eight wheelers had turned over blocking all lanes of traffic on the highway. When we arrived, we were greeted as if we were on time and treated to a meal served by professionals that made us feel like we were their only diners. The meal was delicious and well worth the hour that we spent in traffic. It was the perfect place to celebrate your anniversary, ambiance, great food and fabulous service.
Not the Eddie Martini's I remember. Shrimp cocktail served on a plate not in an iced martini glass. Entrees served warm but not hot except for the creamed corn which was hot with steam streaming from it. My piece of filet was cut into slices not served whole. A virgin Bloody Mary served in a double rocks glass not a traditional pint beer glass. I understand the times are hard just sad the quality was not present on this visit. We had a 7:30pm reservation and didn't send food back as it would have kept us there way too long.
The food and staff were amazing. One of the best places for food and drink in Wisconsin.
Always fantastic. Absolutely one of the best restaurants in Wisconsin. From the food, ambiance and service. Don’t wait for a special occasion. Just go. David was amazing. Will go more now because of him.
Have been here many times and will keep coming back. the salads, steaks, sandwiches and everything are incredible. the chocolate cake on the dessert menu is probably one of my favorite in the city! servers are amazing!
Not use to this kinda of treatment. Very high class... From the moment I arrived I felt like first class, Food was good especially the lobster tail. I will be back. Only advice I have for them is to get a ATM machine. Didn't have enough cash and I prefer not to use credit cards especially in restaurants!!!
If I could give 6 stars, I would. My wife and I had a beautiful time this evening for our anniversary. The food was unbelievable. I tried the Kobe Filet Mignon (special) . Out of this world! Worth every penny. It was simply a delightful evening. We had absolutely no complaints. Our waiter was wonderful. We will be coming back!!
Excellent as always. Jesse is simply phenomenal as a server - he’s worked there for almost 20 years!! Will always request him for any visit. Wayne, the GM, is pure class as well. Thank you for another great dining experience.
Fine dining, 👌 "It was the creme brulee" …
Myself and many of my family members have had dinner at Martini's on numerous occasions. Several times we have been the loud boisterous group really having lots of fun! Have NEVER found this place "stuffy" in any sense of the word. The food is always excellent and specials are creative and delicious! Steaks rank right up there with the steaks from other top steak places in the Milwaukee area. Great bustling bar and funny bartender! Here's a secretlunch is a great deal.....same good food, lower prices. My husband and I like to do a lunch there a couple of days before Christmas. Decorations are nice, puts you in a festive mood. You MUST have the Bourbon Bread Puddingbest in the world!
Food and drink was delicious! Service was tops. Only 2 things - we arrived at 4:40 for a 5 PM reservation and the hostess and bartender were overwhelmed due to a staff meeting until shortly after 5. Also, the creme broulett should be served warm instead of right out of the fridge.
While this restaurant definitely has the vibe of an "old boys club", I have been here multiple times for business meals and they always maintain the highest quality of hospitality. The service is impeccable, and the food is stellar. This quality is reflected in pricing, but not to an egregious extent. It's well worth a visit.
Simply the best place to dine in the Milwaukee area, let alone elsewhere. The drinks and food are always stellar, and you can never go wrong with one of the specials. The service is also unbelievable, and second to none. Once I timed how long it took from when my wife got up to go to the restroom for them to deliver a new folded napkin. 7 seconds! This may not be something to specifically expect of course, but it didn't surprise me at all given my experience with the staff at Eddie's.
If you want a place to go to be treated like royalty, and given food worthy of royalty, this is your destination. There is good reason for why I chose to propose to my wife here years ago, and why we still make sure to get here for any special nights out. If you haven't tried it, and/or you have company to impress, just go here. You will not regret it.
Great service, delicious food! The duck & pork chop were fabulous. Others in our party had filets which were also scrumptious. The desserts are to die for and easily sharable. Never a bad meal at Eddie's.
My friend and I traveled to Wisconsin for a girlfriend weekend. We wanted a nice place for dinner, initially looking for a restaurant who specialized in steaks. I was a little turned off when we arrived shortly after opening and the host reacted as if he was irritated because we hadn't made reservations. But our waiter John, made up for it. He was funny, attentive and went above and beyond to make sure we enjoyed our dining experience.
This is our go to restaurant for special occasions or even just a dinner out. Their food and service is excellent. The staff’s professionalism is exemplary. The restaurant’s ambiance is welcoming and unhurried.
Reserved the private room for 10 (Table 21). Service was outstanding and the food, as usual, was outstanding. Steaks are their bread and butter but this time I choose one of their specials, the pan-seared halibut and risotto, and I was not disappointed. The halibut was light and seared to perfection and the risotto was creamy and delicious. The staff and food made for a wonderful 85th birthday celebration for my mother.
We had a group of 8 for New Years Eve and everyone thought the food was great. The steaks and crab cakes were some of the best I've ever had. The duck appetizer was the only item that nobody seemed to like.
Nobody from our group liked our waiter. He was not accommodating at all and was condescending and somewhat rude. Drinks were slow and we had to ask for them multiple times. We had another server who helped with drinks and water. She was excellent and almost made up for our primary waiter. I have been here twice before and the service was always exceptional so it was disappointing to have such poor service.
Went for a birthday dinner and couldn't be happier. We came early and had drinks at the bar, then on to dinner which was fabulous. Wayne was our waiter with Rachel assisting, so attentive, answered all our questions and took great care of us. Brought Birthday dessert, we ordered more with coffee to end a spectacular meal. We'll definitely be back!
Absolutely love Eddie Martini's! My wife and I have been coming here for years and the food and service are always first class! Jesse and Courtney were fantastic! Couldn't ask for a better place to celebrate our marriage!
What a wonderful experience. They sure know how to celebrate an occasion with you. All our meals were excellent. My scallops melted in my mouth. My husband had the veal and it also melted in his mouth. We are planning on going back soon. You will not be disappointed.
The service and food were outstanding. Our first time there, and the experience was total first class.
Got married on the patio, (August 2015 - this was an unexpected venue option) we were the first to do so there. We also celebrated my my parent’s 30th wedding anniversary the same evening-double celebration. Was the best, as usual! The staff was wonderful; served my party of 15 with all the grace and elegance a bride and groom could have desired. All of the courses were perfect, and the wine selection was divine. My wedding party said I was the happiest bride! We all had a beautiful evening! Thank you Eddie Martini’s! Great job!
That was awesome! Thanks so much for some local friends for recommending this restaurant. On a snowy February night, I got enjoy a great treat.
First off, love that they took everyone's coat at the front door! That was awesome on a cold snowy night. Second and most especially, the food was amazing and the service is excellent. I got to enjoy appetizers ranging from the foie gras, scallops, and brie... delicious. For a main course Gluten Free, all I had to do was request to leave off the fried onion ring on top of the steak. I had the bone in fillet mignon and it was folk tender delicious. They serve the steak simply with "steak butter" on top and it's perfect. For sides I had a baked potato and asparagus. Everything was perfect and out service was truly excellent.
If you're in the area and want a really nice, cozy place with excellent service and food, I would highly recommend Eddie's Martini's.
Sister and I went there. We were both very impressed with atmosphere, presentation of food and service. We had a 5 course meal, the lobster bisque presentation was the most fun! They brought the bowl with the lobster in it and the broth separately. I wish I remember the server's name so I could give her a shout out, but I don't.
Eddie Martinis was wonderful. I had not 1 but 2 servers. Hot hand towels in between appetizer and main course, which was fantastic. The ambience was beautiful. I had the most wonderful experience. Wayne, Kelly, and Jessie were lovely.
My first bad dining experience, ordered the 8oz tenderloin med rare cut first taste and got a mouthful of sodium, thought it just might be the outer edge but it was too objectionable. I told our waitress to have a chef try it and upon her return she said that I could have a different steak if I desired I turned it down she then mentioned to me that my entrée cost would not be charged. The explanation was the butter reduction on the steak during cooking or after that caused the heavy salt content. Otherwise everything was great as usual great service great drinks great company the appetizers were fantastic the shrimp and the escargot are outstanding. Still our favorite choice to dine
Excellent food, even better service. Great place to have a semi-formal dinner with friends. Chicken was not on the menu and they were more than willing to provide me with a special chef's choice or a vegetarian option. Highly recommend it.
We have flown up from Kansas City twice in the last 3 weeks as our first grandchild is in the NICU at children’s hospital. We just happened upon Eddie Martini’s on our first visit and had an excellent experience in every way. We ate there again on our second visit 2 weeks later and had the same great experience. The service and quality of the meal was top shelf. It’s not cheap but to me worth every penny. Not many places like this anymore where you feel like part of the family. Plus my granddaughter is doing very well.
I ordered the lamb chops and they were delicious... but the exceptional staff is the reason why I've been raving to everyone about going. 1 they carried out my special request by printing a personal "Happy Birthday" message on the menu. 2 all the staff throughout dinner came over to say happy birthday including the host. and 3something i've never had offered to me was my martini reshaken. I had an absolute fabulous experience.
There is no better dining in Milwaukee. You receive first class treatment from the time you arrive to your departure.
The food is always fresh, delicious, excellently prepared, and presented.
For the time you wish to treat yourself, to a time to celebrate that special occasion .. this is a must place to go.
4-22-21 ... Update:
All of the above review remains the same. Still the best in SE Wisconsin.
The Mgr.- Wayne Bartz is one of the best in the business. He is an exemplary leader & host in the hospitality industry.
I cannot say enough good things about the service here. They take care of you from the moment you walk in the door until the moment you leave. The food is fantastic - especially if you're looking for a good steak! Great for celebrating an anniversary or a nice date night.
Nice old school supper club atmosphere! Well stocked bar. Menu items include a variety for everyone. Drink prices are higher than I expected. Definitely a must see when you are in town.
Best steakhouse around. Highly recommend coming here over any downtown Milwaukee steakhouses. Outstanding service. Prices are reasonable for the quality and taste of the food. Definitely coming back.
Everyone in our party thought the food was delicious. Service was good. This restaurant has an upscale feel to it and the pricing reflects that. It's somewhat small, but was still able to accommodate a group.
Service was top notch. My steak was done to perfection and the side of brussel sprouts was absolutely delicious. Our VP from Germany always requests that we dine at Eddie Martini's. I have lived in MKE most of my life and have to admit I have never been there before. Now I understand why our VIP guests request at least one meal while here in Milwaukee to be at Eddie Martini's!
We have family gathering at special room for 11 pax. They arranged it beautifully, the food and service are excellent.
Excellent dinner with a great steak. I left fully satisfied and very full. The service was great, and ambience was relaxed and light. Try to save room for dessert if you can!
Enjoyed a drink and apps at the bar.
Enjoyable evening with friendly severs
Great French onion soup.
The brussel sprouts were a bit sweet, but okay. I didnt enjoy my shrimp pasta as it qas a little dry. But the martinis was on point
The pinnacle of steakhouse dining. Best of service, best of food, best of atmospheres. There is no better restaurant in the city. Attentive staff, charming hosts/captains, thoughtful servers - the list goes on. This is an EXPERIENCE, and the best.
My wife and I have been going here for our Valentine's Day dinner for years. It is always a treat and the food is amazing. Service is top notch and you couldn't ask for a better atmosphere. Would highly recommend to anyone looking for good steak.
In the tradition of the classic supper club. Eddie Martini's has a style of its own! Fantastic food, menu, and service. Not to mention their world-class desserts. You could dine on a special occasion, business function or just a relaxed dinner. Seating varies from a private room to cozy booths. Reservations strongly recommended!
If you want to experience true 'fine dining'? Eddie Martini's will be a very pleasant surprise! Their food is Beyond Amazing! It's only upstaged by the service & the 5-star treatment you're given from the minute you walk through the door. Treat Yourself to an evening of luxury dining at its Best!
We come here regularly and have always found it to be amazing. I usually go for the filet, bit recently tried the prime rib and it eas melt in your mouth. Lovely relaxed atmosphere w superb service. I see a recent review w 1 star here from a Mark Lambrecht. The ownership has NOT changed, if this Mark had reached out to owner Chris Murphy I know he would have made things right. I also see most of Mark's reviews are 1star...perhaps not the restaurants.
It was my first time there. The food was amazing and our server Ashley was awesome. Would go back in a heartbeat.
From the outside, this hidden gem looks unremarkable with its martini glass sign alongside the main road. That all changes when you enter. This is by far one of the best restaurants in the Milwaukee area. From the moment you are seated, your drink orders taken and quickly delivered, the house specials recited, and your appetizers so artfully displayed, you really get the feeling that you are experiencing upscale dining. Each consumed course is as good or better than the previous, culminating in a choice of several delectable desserts. This type of top shelf service doesn't come cheap, so bring the big "piggy bank" and enjoy this memorable experience. I have never given a restaurant 5 stars before as I believe there is always room for improvement. That being said, I will give them a 4.9 out of 5.
Always Excellent Food! Always Excellent Service! This is where we go when we want the best steak in town. Always treat us like royalty and never rushed.
The best dining experience! I cannot say enough positive things about how kind & attentive every staff member was. The food was out of this world! I will definitely be back!
Perfect COVID protocols allowed us to totally enjoy our fantastic meals with awesome service. This place is magnificent for so many reasons not the least of which is their concern for the safety of their guests.
Eddie's always has amazed my family and I. I have never had a disappointing meal. Every meal I've had has been cooked to perfection. My wife and I go there every year for our anniversary. Wayne, (I like to call him the King of wine) will listen to your questions reguarding wine selection. He will not disappoint with his expansive knowledge of wine. You owe it to yourself to have dinner here at least once a year. Best meals I've ever had. Thanks to all who work at Eddie Martini's.
A classic steak house experience. Exquisite service, with high attention to detail. The cuts we had were flavorful and perfectly prepared. Worth a trip out for a special occasion.
We have and have ALWAYS had an amazing experience here. recently I tried the prime rib after being a filet fan for years. Melt in your mouth good. I do see a 1star terrible review from a Mark Lambrecht here who say's ownership changed- Not so. Chris Murphy has been the owner since 2018 and does am amazing job. Maybe Mark should reach out to Chris instead of posting his complaint here.
I noticed almost all of Mark's reviews are bad...perhaps it not the restaurants!
Great place to dine and wine, food definitely delicious and service also excellent.
We had a great time and the food was beyond good. The staff and their level of service are second to none. We has the Seafood Martini, it was over the top good. We would strongly suggest that you take the time and stop in if you get the chance. You will not be disappointed!!!
This restaurant is rated 5 stars for a reason. It's an upscale restaurant with everything you would expect from it - impeccable service with superb food. It's a great place for a special occasion.
A smooth and comfortably paced dinner.9 oz. Fillet was tender and perfectly prepared.
Service very attentive but not intrusive. And a complimentary chocolate moose to celebrate our 44th wedding anniversary.
Amazing food amazing atmosphere amazing service
Food, service, wine...wverything was fantastic. Prices are worth the quailty and flavor of the dishes.
So amazing! Our group came in, slightly obnoxious, after a long day celebrating the 115th. Not only did they make us feel welcome, the food was beyond amazing, and our server June...spectacular! Can't wait to come back!
Beautiful atmosphere and great food and service! Best steaks around!
The whole experience, from the food to the service, was excellent. A great place to celebrate any occasion!
Awesome steak, sea food and drinks. Nice ambiance and impeccable service. All the dishes were made to the perfection. We enjoyed our food thoroughly.
Amazing first time experience. Everything was on point, food was spectacular and the hospitality was outstanding!! I would definitely recommend this place for date night, special occasion you name it. We will be back!!! (:
Eddie Martini's introduced my wife to her new signature drink- the Moscow Mule! We had dinner here with friends and the food was amazing. It's a nice place to go for a special occasion with family and friends.
Amazing service and food. We went to for a work event and were not disappointed. Awesome steaks, great seafood and delicious appetizers! Would gladly go again and again!
We always have a great time at Eddie Martinis! The seafood tower is fantastic and steak is always the best! Not too mention the bomb dirty Martinis!
Our favorite upscale place to dine. Service exemplary. 1940s atmosphere. Never disappointed. Steak lover? Try their bone in.
Just down the road from the hospital.
Great Milwaukee staple for a steak place. It is very quaint and nice for a small outing. The lunch steak Cesar is excellent. The soups are great also for lunch. For a dinner cut, I typically get the ribeye which has always been cooked perfectly. I wish they offered more specialty cuts more often a Kobe, Wagyu or other specialty cut.
Great dinner spot for any occasion. It has never disappointed.
The food was delicious. I had scallops in an amazing sauce. We ended with a drink at the bar and the bar tender was funny and very engaging.
Great atmosphere. Service was excellent. Food was very good. Our first time eating there, will definitely be back.
Best steak in Milwaukee Metro area. Service is unbelievable, food is amazing and drinks are on point. You will pay for all of that but for a special occasion it is worth the price.
Very good streks and awesome customer service.
The waiter is amazing and my steak are so perfect. I haven’t had a steak is so long and it was so tender and the drink is just amazing. Thank you for the good food
I had the halibut special and it was spectacular! Party of 6 and everyone was happy. The ambiance, the service, 5 stars!
Did and drinks were great. Definitely make a reservation.
Definitely a bit on the high end of the price scale
Service beyond all expectations. The food was full of natural flavor. Our first time here, came on our anniversary on a recommendation. Will not be our last visit for sure.
Excellent steakhouse with a reasonable selection of seafood options. Very knowledgeable servers providing attentive service.
Every bit of the experience was excellent. The service is on point at all times, the food and presentation was delicious and even after a issue with the bill the manager made extra efforts to correct things promptly.
Delicious, great service, waiters are dressed in what looks like medical student lab coats! They were very accommodating to my dietary needs and their steak, potato and veggies were great!
Great bloody Mary, service fantastic, food is great.
Amazing Service! Fantastic Steaks! The bone in rib eye was everything the red meat lover in you desired! Great atmosphere.
I went with a group, and that was good. Eddie Martini's has been around a long time and they do a very good job. It is pricey, but if you like steak, it might be for you.
The service and their attention to detail was above and beyond what we expected. Our food was prepared and presented perfectly. We felt like Royalty from the moment we were seated.
Our favorite place to go for a relaxing dinner out in a peaceful, elegant atmosphere!! The specials change with the seasons and are delicious as well as unique. We absolutely love this place!!
Excellent short ribs and great service
Bravo!!!!!! Thank you Wayne and staff for your OUTSTANDING service, food and overall dining experience. Professional and very friendly. You know what your doing to make not only your patrons delighted; also your staff. Thank you! Ava
Dinner was excellent! Best Filet. Service Exceptional from all staff. Celebrating my birthday, surprised me with delicious Flourless Cake!
This is our special occasion restaurant. Food is phenomenal, service is outstanding. Bring money lol also John the bartender is fun and funny.
Great staff, great atmosphere, great food and spirits! A five star always in our house! Everything is top shelf! Want to impress - go to Eddie Martini's!
Reasonably priced, the staff was great! Everyone's meal was done to perfection! All around a great experience!! Will definitely be back!
Way over rated. Among Milwaukee restaurants... Just ok. Do not get hype. Reputation built in the past. Now no better than any run of the mill mid steakhouse with stupid prices.
Stellar service and best steak. Celebrated my mom's birthday and the staff did a great job making it a memorable celebration.
No reservation but we were treated so nicely anyway. Food was fantastic.
My first time here,and lived up to all people said about Eddie's! Amazing staff,incredibly delicious steak and sides. Definitely will be back!
What a restaurant the service the employees were top notch and the food was out of this world the crabcakes were excellent with a bouquet that lingered and that was just the appetizer. A must try restaurant.Milwaukees best steak house.
Excellent steaks, melt in your mouth! Great atmosphere inside. Excellent service by all staff. Well worth the price.
First time and highly recommended! Impeccable service, great drinks and fantastic food.
Awesome spot to take your girlfriend/wife out to dinner, Lobster Mac N Cheese is out of this world, and the steaks are to die for. Wonderful staff and great drinks too.
We celebrated my parents 50th wedding anniversary at Eddie Martinis staff and food was unforgettable, table 21 was perfect for our celebration.
Great food service atmosphere and drink.
Always a classy meal with attentive service. Excellant bartenders who.know how to make classic cocktails.
Absolutely perfect! Delicious.
Drinks at the bar is a must do. Steaks are average. Service is superior. Wine list is fantastic. Lobster thermador a must have.
We enjoyed our dinner at Eddie Martini's. The food and the way we were taken care of was wonderful. The meal was not rushed.
Great lunch at a reasonable price!
The lobster and halibut were excellent, my fiance and I love going there because the service and food is always ama,zing!
Great Service and fantastic food. The staff, particularly Wayne, were top notch!
Food and service are consistently exceptional....'nuff said 😉
Great atmosphere, service and food. Best place to celebrate.
Eddies never disappoints. Service is so attentive and food seems to get better with each course!
Even during a pandemic, the service and food were impeccable.
Best steak experience out there.
Nice traditional higher end restaurant. Seems to attract the older set. Simple elegant decor. Bar area gets busy.
Best steaks in Milwaukee. Service is unmatched. Great date night any day of the week!
This place is amazing. I used to rate it as a five star but they decided to pull bacon potato hash from the menu and it just isn’t the same
First time there. Enjoyed the atmosphere. Staff was attentive, welcoming and genuinely focused on making our experience special.
Awesome as always! Atmosphere is fun and the dinner was excellent! Wayne our waiter made our night!
Old school steak and seafood. Great for a special meal or a business lunch. Attentive professional service and a reasonable wine list.
What can I say that more than likely already hasn't been said. If you want the best meal of your life with the best service get a reservation today.
Service, food atmosphere excellent as always! Everyone that took care of us was amazing!
Great food, awesome drinks. Want a Vesper? They can make it. One of the few places with kina lillet! Says a lot about the class of this joint!
One of the most consistent great restaurants in Milwaukee. Great seafood, steaks and the service is friendly and very professional, the best in town.
Wonderful food and elegant ambience. Excellent staff. Expensive but worth it ! A special occasion place for us.
Just had the Miso glazed salmon....Dinner for 3 take out, awesome! Great value, really good food, thank you!!
From the moment you walk in, this restaurant just welcomes you. Great service and even better food!
Food was great service was great. Everything was top notch. Will definitely come back.
Great service, great food, you always feel special there. Thank you Jesse for making a birthday perfect.
Excellent food in a nice setting, with above average service. Not cheap, but everything is delicious.
Great dinner, nice atmosphere. First class service!
Excellent food and top service. A bit pricey, but worth it as a treat for me and guests or colleagues.
The food is outstanding and the service is even better. We had a lovely dinner.
Everything was great!
Service was excellent. Food and presentation were very good.
It never disappoints!!! Great staff and food.
Excellent service excellent food cannot comment on the cocktails as I do not drink but otherwise definitely five stars would give six if I could.
Prices are high, very dark atmosphere, nice staff, and the steak is just okay.
The food and staff was wonderful. I would definitely recommend this restaurant to my friends and family.
Wonderful experience here for a business lunch. They treat you well and the food was delicious.
Great food, excellent service as usual. Highly recommend for an enjoyable night out.
Top service, atmosphere and of course - The Menu and Food.
Service was impeccable. Food was excellent. Will be back
Great food and service, prices not as bad as some say..You get more than you pay for in my opinion
Easy for your eyes to overdo food ordering.
The bone in rib eye was One of the best steaks I’ve ever had. Also one of the most expensive steaks I’ve ever had but worth it
Some of the best food and service I have ever experienced. I can't wait to go back!!!
Service is top notch, but the food is really just average. Capital Grille has nothing to fear here!
Always a first rate experience. Excellent food with wonderful service. Enjoy.
Best steak I have ever had. Very high class meal and services.
Beautiful place to celebrate any life's events and milestones. Anniversary, Birthday, Graduation.
Melt in your mouth steaks. Atmosphere, food and service are spectacular.
Amazing, great staff!
Food was fantastic and the service was just as great. I had difficulty finding parking.
Amazing fine dining experience. Excellent steak!
If you want to impress someone take them there
Anniversary dinner was awesome and great service. Thank you to Chris and his team.
Ordered take out and the service and food was fabulous! Highly recommend
Great food and service
Mushrooms and onions were amazing. Not the best steak i ever had though...
Food and service are second to none. You will love the ambience!
Good food, great atmosphere. A bit on the pricey side.
Bone in filet and pomegranate martini. Very delicious. From kitchen to bar to wait staff ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Easy 5 star
The best steak in Wisconsin, impeccable service and a perfect dining experience
Simply outstanding. One of the four best restaurants in Milwaukee.
Go there for the martinis, stay for the delicious food and amazing service.
The place was excellent the service was great the dinner was perfect
Lovely experience, great food. Planning on coming back so.
Always impeccable service, which is only out done by the food. We love it!!
Always Great...
If I could give it 10 stars I would. Service and food were amazing!!!
Ask for Wayne as your waiter and enjoy your dinner. Place is great.
Always a fantastic meal. The entire menu is delicious!
An outstanding atmosphere mixed with delicious entrees and pleasant staff
Nice meal. Very friendly service
Very good food. Better than anything I could make. Moderately expensive.
Only had time for drinks and appetizers I will be back for a steak to give it a 5 star.
Great food and service
The food was excellent and service great. A little spendy though.
Food was fantastic! The waitstaff was very professional and attentive.
Amazing food and service. Had a wonderful dining experience.
Great food and service! They also have stoli gold!!!
As always service & food was over the top. Best restaurant experience in MKE.
The ginormous seafood appetizer is worth the visit alone. Very classy joint
Great service, great food but pricey.
Great service and food as always.
Old school charm if you like that. Likely you will with the service. You have to shoo them away at times. I'll go back
Fabulous food and & phenomenal service.
some of the best steak's in greater Milwaukee area.
This is our anniversary tradition. Great staff, food, and atmosphere.
Great service and Steaks were cooked to perfection
Great service, delicious food. Cannot wait to go back.
Excellent location for a lunch business meeting. Nice and quiet, good for conversation
Very welcoming staff! Excellent atmosphere and food. #Milwaukeeclassic
Excellent service. Expensive but worth the service you get here. They cater to you the whole time
Just had lunch and I highly recommend the veal scallopini, it is fantastic.
Best steak in any town. Cooked to perfection.
Great food, great service and a fantastic scotch selection.
Solid steakhouse vibe - great service, drinks, and food.
Fabulous service, great atmosphere , outstanding meal
Service is top notch and the salmon salad was great.
Great service and meal for our family birthday dinner
Very nice experience. Wonderful steak.
Very nice ambience...a little bit pricey though!
Best food of my life. Service was impeccable.
Great steaks and martinis. Service top shelf
Amazing service. Great food. Great atmosphere.
Christ, stuff is cheap in the midwest. Great food and service for the price.
Love going here for super special occasions. Pricey but lovely
Always great service. Very good food.
Pricey but the best steak in town.
Excellent food. Classy. Highly recomend this place.
Always great food and great service.
Service outstanding, food delesious, atmosphere unique
Scallops are ok but the steak was great
Great food, drinks and service!😊 …
One of the best true steak houses in the area.
Great ambiance, service and phenomenal food
Amazing food drinks staff tock star!!!
Always a wonderful gastronomic experience with superb service.
Great food. Excellent pace of ordering.
Awesome Food! Awesome Service!!!
Great food great staff great executive chef
Amazing modern supper club dinner.
Always excellent food and great drinks!!
Very good. Sometbing different, more European. I loved it
Always a treat! Love the seafood martini!!
Great service and food every time we visot
Steak was excellent and double duck was delicious.
Classic and amazing! Staff is best I have ever seen.
Expensive? Yes. Worth it? Yes. Literally melt-in-your-mouth filet.
Excellent food & service as always!
We will definitely be back. Very very good.
Great service and outstanding food.
Martini - tenderloin w/lobster risotto - oh my!
Fabulous food, superior staff and service..
Excellent food and service. Wayne is fantastic!
High end place and treated me with respect. Thanks for the class act team!
High quality service for a special occasion, just like we expected.
Great atmosphere, service and food!
Service was excellent, along with the food!
Very nice place. Food is awsome.
Great steak. Great service.
Great Food & Fabulous Service!
Best steak house in town!
Great food, service, old fashioned.
Fantastic atmosphere! Delicious food
Classic , but you will pay for it. Pretentious wine list
My favorite restaurant in Milwaukee hands down.
Great food, high prices
One of Milwaukee's best steakhouses.
great,they treat you like a rock star
Just Fab!! Best steaks and fish
Delicious and awesome service ! A++
A bit disappointed in the food. Order not correct.
Awesome service, excellent scallops
Great meal and Great service.
My favorite steak house in the United States.
Superb flawless dining
Great food and great service!
Excellent food and service!
Great steak, great service!
Excellent!! Cant wait to go again.
Excellent service and high end food
Top-notch food and service
A great place for a special night
Best streaks around. Period
Great server, great food!
Eddie Martini's was beyond Fantastic as it always is!
High class, fabulous food!
Outstanding food and service!
Always a special occasion when dining
Stellar service and wonderfully Crafted food
Food and service was awesome
Just a FABULOUS experience!!!
Great. Great. Excellent! Very pleased.
A great place to eat!
First time here and really liked it
Outstanding. Best place so far
Great food and drinks!
Excellent Service and Food!!
Huge steak cooked just right
Awesome food and service. $$$$$.
Great steak & service
The food was great.
You are not going to find a better deal. Period.
Awesome!!
Great food great service
Huge steak cooked perfectly
It's everything everyone has ever bragged about and more!
Great and friendly establishment
Staff and food excellent
Excellent food and service
Good place, not excellent!
Great food & service
Came in and thought it would great it wasn't.
A perfect anniversary experience.
Upscale dining in northwest Milwaukee
Great food and service
Very good food
Awesome..! Great Service..
Excellent food as always!!!
Always five star!
Fancy
Martini Appetizer is amazing!
A treat each time
Over priced. Friendly staff
Food not so great
Good food. And services
Great food!
Classic!
The best
The service here is awesome!!!
Excellent steaks!
Always top notch !
Perfection on so many levels
Upscale excellent food