Reviews of Jersey Mike's Subs. (Caterer) in Portland (Maine).

Jersey Mike's Subs

325 Reviews

189 Comments

Caterer

Sandwich shop

550 Gallery Blvd Suite C, Scarborough, ME 04074, United States

Description

Information of Jersey Mike's Subs, Caterer in Portland (Maine)

Discover the opening times, the location, contact, popular times, photos and real reviews by internet users.

This place has a very good rate, they treat their customers well and you’ll feel welcome, super recommended

Map

Open hours of Jersey Mike's Subs

Popular times

Sunday

Monday

Tuesday

Wednesday

Thursday

Friday

Saturday

Reviews of Jersey Mike's Subs

Hailey Peck

The best gluten free sandwich!! As a person with celiacs disease they went above and beyond to change gloves and clean the tables before making my sandwich. The gluten free bread was delicious and separated from the rest. They also will make any request when getting extra toppings.

Jared McCaw

Cut cold Italian was top notch, fresh, tasty. Bread was fresh and soft but not squishy. Location was dirty, ingredients all over the counter and debris on the floor. Cleanliness took away the 5 star. Food and customer service were excellent.

Creepylil Panda

The food is always good. Staff always looks and acts SUPER stoned. It's kinda awkward walking in to order cause they all don't really know what they're doing. They don't seem to know what "Mike's way" means. I'm not mad about it, just makes going in to order super weird. I'd rather order online and not have the super unwelcoming attitude when I'm ordering my food. 🤷 Ah well. Foods always good though so, it's kinda worth it.

Edward Simpson

Serious sandwiches only! No turkey based meats and skimping on the vegetables to make a profit. Stop messing around with $5 sandwiches, pay a little more and treat yourself to a real sandwich that's going to satisfy the appetite. Cold cuts are sliced right in front of you, fresh veggies and toppings. There are three different sizes, the mini, regular and giant. Yes they have vegetarian options as well. No, there is no excuse not to go.

Tammy Lee

The sandwiches were really good, but the store experience wasn’t too great. The manager was very nice and had a great personality, but (some) of the staff was very rude. Blank look, very monotone and asking me to repeat myself several times. It was packed but the line went really fast, even with people ordering hot sandwiches. It was 30 for three regular size sandwiches. I’ll go back but maybe right when it opens.

Craig Blackwell

Blown away by the Scarborough location! We reached out about quite a large catering order and the manager assured me it wouldn't be a problem, and it wasn't! Super grateful for Dido and his team - our event was all the better because of the delicious subs! Thanks again!

Chaos Gaming

This is the to go place is you want all your ingredients fresh. Currently under new ownership and can't wait to go back and see the changes the owner is making. By the way the big Kahuna is the best hot sub.

Suraiya Gobeil

Jersey Mike's was one of our corporate sponsors for Scarborough Football Boosters and was instrumental in helping us get funding needed to help run our program. They also supplied us with delicious sandwiches for long road trips. So glad they have opened in Scarborough and have given back to the community.

Coco's

We ordered our crew lunch from you guys today. 50 lunch boxes. Order was ready on time and it was PERFECT. Not one mistake not one missed sandwich. You guys killed it!! Thank you so much!! Port Harbor Marine.

Thomas Edgar

Although it’s almost always busy here ….definitely worth it. Sandwiches are consistently great. Locally owned - hard working staff. A great alternative when you need a meal out.

Ian Clark

The young men staffing this place are doing an excellent job. They work quickly while maintaining sandwich quality. I will be back more often than I’ll admit.

Emily Prosser

julia theta and logan are some of the kindest coustomer service workers i have ever met, they all deserve a raise. i’ve never been treated with as much respect by workers in my life, they also make amazing subs!

K T

I'm giving this location 3 stars because it's a great chain restaurant to get lunch at. The meat and cheese gets cut fresh to each sandwhich, and the ingredients come from Boars Head. The sandwhiches are great sizes; there are lots of options, and the prices are decent. That being said, this location has always had trouble with staff, cleanliness, and organization. I've been here many times and waited 40+ minutes because the "computer wasn't printing orders" or only two people were able to work that day. I have witnessed what others have said in terms of cleanliness. Staff are not changing gloves or sanitizing between hot/cold items or from the register to the line. The counter is a mess, and sometimes the lobby is, too. The parking lot is small as it is shared. Avoid peak times as lines are out the doors, and online ordering often gets shut off.

Skip Peacock

Great Subs. Huge sandwich for the money! A recommend from me!

William MacCallum (Mac)

I must admit that I was skeptical of a chain restaurant selling hoagie but Mike's Subs are great. I grew up in NJ and the subs are far superior to the "Italian" sandwich available here in Maine. Mike's subs are awesome!

Scott Anderson

Food was good. Best sub I have had in a while. My issue was with customer service. I placed my order online and was given a pick up time of 30 minutes. I arrived at the exact time and went in to get my food and had to wait an additional 20 minutes beyond what I was told. Another customer who waited less time than me was given an apology and complimentary coupons for his next visit by the manager when his sandwich was done. The manager gave me an attitude when I asked where I could get the soda that came with my order. Really?! As if all that wasn't bad enough they messed up my order too. Good food like I said but they need to get their sh*t together

Brian Liberty

First time I've ever been to a Jersey Mike's. One of the best submarine sandwiches I have ever eaten. Fresh sliced in front of you meat and cheese, awesome bread choices and fresh toppings. Also was super excited to try the agave cream soda that they had and man I was not disappointed. If I could give this review more stars it would get more stars. Closest Jersey Mike's to me is an hour and a half away and I will gladly make the drive for another sub.

kara fallon

The subs here are delicious. Fresh cut deli meat and ingredients. However the wait time even when you place an online order is way off. This is the 3rd time my husband and I have had to wait an hr for a sandwich even after the app told us 30 minutes. The accuracy of the app needs vast improvement. Some people don’t have an hr to wait for sandwiches, if we knew that in advance we would have chose a different place

Joe Donahue

It was very good. This location had just opened so there were a couple of minor issues. The food was very good and the staff was very nice. A very small dining area but takeout should be no problem. Will go back and try another sandwich. I got the steak and cheese.

Matt Brock

Part of a large order for work tonight. Amazing Chipotle Steak & Cheese from an amazing company. I've been enjoying Jersey Mike's food for the last 25 years, and tonight's order was amazing too. Thank you for all you do!

Mike Mayo

Love that they're here in Maine. Sandwiches are great. Although so far the service isn't. First time there we ordered online ahead of time. Still waited 25 minutes outside for our food past pick up time. Someone said they were working on it like 3 times. Second time we went it was snappy but they got one of the sandwiches wrong and we discovered it only after we left and arrived at our destination. Hopefully they'll work it out. Food is worth it though.

Trevor Murphy

Great sandwiches(unfortunately the best in maine(cold)). Great people working there. Super nice and understanding. Grab that juice on the side if you're driving home.

Lynn Smith

These subs are not premade! The meat and cheeses are cut right there and are exceedingly fresh. There are bread choices, and a selection of chips as well. The sandwiches are made my way and they are delicious!

Jeff Needham

Missing free delivery - for a long time, delivery wasn't an added expense, and we used to order at least twice a week at work. Just can't do it anymore. 2.99 delivery fee plus another three or four bucks for "fees"? And a tip for the driver makes a 15 dollar lunch into a 32 dollar lunch. I can't justify the cost. What happened to free delivery? A great sandwich, but you priced me out of buying lunch when I'm at work.

Tracy Dickinson

The sandwich itself was pretty good, but behind the counter it was a mess. I was afraid one of the kids working back there was going to slip and fall on all the food on the floor. Be prepared for a hectic environment, quite a few workers behind the counter, but tasty sandwich. The bread was fresh and the filing was the perfect ratio.

rico suave

rico love jersey mike. mike was very nice, i meet him and his friend Joe. they give me sandwich and make it taste good. 5 star , never coming back again

Mark Gedicks

The giant Philly steak and cheese was pretty good, plenty for my wife and I to split. The arguing staff (right in front of multiple customers) - was also plenty for me to stomach. First time eating there - might go back, but not sure.

Chris P.

Perhaps the best sub I've had in the Portland metro area, and yet... Like several other reviewers, I had a pretty lousy experience with the wait time, having ordered an hour in advance online, showing up on time, and still having to wait almost a half hour for my order. It looked as though there were at least 3 or 4 others in the same boat, too. The staff all appeared to be working very hard, and were very nice. One very patiently put up with a customer who was high as a kite, taking his mask off while he tried to negotiate for a free sandwich. There just seems to be something wrong with the logistics of how orders are processed and/or they may be understaffed. I think one improvement they could make is an order tracker, like Domino's and some other chains have. That way, people could get a real-time idea of how long it will take for their order, instead of an apparently often inaccurate estimate. They could also have the option of waiting outside or in their vehicle, instead of in a small and crowded interior space. I plan to give them another shot. I think this location has only been open for a few months, so hopefully they are still working out growing pains.

Joshua Carver

Subway is in trouble if this shop shows up in your area. I wish we had one closer by. Fresh cut meat, made to order soups.

Danielle St. Pierre

I'm not a fan of chain restaurants in general, but this is my favorite for sandwiches. It's like an elevated Subway sandwich restaurant. They slice the cold cuts fresh, the veggies are always fresh and the bread is delicious.

Bonnie Emerson

Great subs!! Clean place, friendly staff

Tony Youells

Our local Jersey Mike’s opened recently and I placed my first order using the app just a few days ago. I recommend going through the app since it’s very user-friendly and easy to navigate. I thought the sandwich was a little pricey but I did get a giant size with extra meat. And then I pick that beast up. This sandwich was a monster. There was a weight that told me I was going to be in serious trouble if I try to eat the whole thing. I tried, and I succeeded, but not very easily. Now I’m basing this review on one sandwich, and I intend to try more, but if the rest of the menu is even half as good then there should be a rating above five stars. Order the giant, and be warned. This thing put me in a food coma and I was able to skip breakfast and lunch the next day.

Andy Martin

I love the online ordering. I did takeout on this visit. The store appeared clean and the staff was friendly. The sandwich was tasty however its priced fairly expensive, if there would have been more filings it would be a solid sandwich. I will most likely return and try other sandwiches.

Patrick Davis

We came in just as the dinner rush started, and were blown away by how efficient and polite the entire team was. Our food was made quickly, and it was so good! This was our first trip into a Jersey Mike's, but it certainly won't be our last.

Nick LaMartina

A delightful juxtaposition of New England tastes with the comfort and consistency of a chain. The subs are eminently fresh and thoughtfully assembled; generous amounts of meat, but not overflowing, making them safe to eat on the couch or in the car without making a mess. The lettuce is always fresh and crunchy, and they keep well in the fridge without getting soggy.

Jonathan C. Fenton

I got a giant chipotle steak sandwich. The bread was tasty and held up well. The sandwich fillings were fresh and crispy. It was so filling that I needed a forklift to get into bed after dinner. Definitely going back.

Karissa Hannifan

These sandwiches are amazing. They are expensive, but a large is more than enough for two people! They always have friendly service and get my order out quickly.

Renyi Family

This store never disappoints. Staff is incredibly nice and honestly matches the quality of the food. Looking forward to seeing more stores run like this throughout Maine. My go to for lunch and dinner on the run.

Lisa Carlista

Sandwiches are amazing. Best in Maine! Do not place online order unless you want a sandwich in an hour 20 mins. Go in person. Last online order was lost last week. This week placed an hour before pick up and still had to wait 20 minutes standing in parking lot while all the walk ins can go right in and walk out in 5 mins. Understand new business; however online ordering has glitches. Be prepared to hang out in parking lot for a long time for online ordering. Still a great sandwich and friendly staff!!

Joyce Allen

I just had my first Jersey Mike's sub from Scarborough ME and I was not disappointed. We picked it up and drove 15 minutes home and it was perfect, no soggy bread or anything like that. Love that they use all fresh ingredients. I'm a Jersey girl and this made me feel like I was there. Thank you Jersey Mike's

Christina Mason

Foods OK but not something I’d go out of my way for. My first thought was that the prices were a little high but the regular sandwich is very filling so it’s worth it. Service is slow but that’s not the workers faults. They can only make one cold sandwich at a time which is crazy when there’s 20 people waiting outside. I think they need to add another meat slicer and sandwich area

alan barker

I've been here multiple times and used in store and mobile ordering and so far every time has been excellent. Food is hot, fresh and tastes good and the customer service is exceptional. It's definitely a place I will regularly grab lunch.

Jeff

I recently had an experience with Jersey Mike's that I'd like to share. A mixup in ordering produced an order for a store that wasn't open due to ongoing virus problems. But the manager Joe was quick to jump in and rectify the situation, even called me back so the order could be waiting when I arrived. Excellent customer service 👏

Rob Ripley

Good food at a decent price. Prefer them to subway. The online ordering is easy, but confusing when you get to the store. Sometimes you wait outside and they bring your order, sometimes you have to go inside....

Bruce Marstaller

The process of on line ordering is very fluid with the items all bagged and ready for pick up when we arrive. Cold sandwhiches are very similar to Pizza Joint which I have always enjoyed.

Anna Munson

Easily one of my favorite fast food places! Food is really, really, good. Bread is always fresh, subs are, consistently, good. As is always true with Jersey Mikes, the staff is super friendly!

CJ Knight

Pretty good sandwiches overall however I've been really disappointed with their app. Every time I order ahead I end up waiting in the lobby longer than if I ordered it there when I showed up.

Branden Keller

One of my favorite places for a sub sandwich. They slice all the meat and cheese after you order so everything is as fresh as possible. Make sure to get it "Mike's Way"!

Brock Holmes

Can't go wrong with the #8 and #13 Mike's way. Cold subs are definitely their specialty. Hot subs aren't anything special but aren't bad either.

Donna Alexander

first time and it wont be the last.the sandwiches were unbelievable and so fresh. excellent service cant wait to try them all. oh yeah wait till you taste the bread definate poker night meal.

Sharon Binette

Had the Philly steak sub..its was very good. Generous portion. The rosemary parmesan bread is AMAZING.

Jacob B

Blows subway out of the water - worth the higher prices.

Lynné Montoya

Delicious subs! Seasoned meat! Worth the money! Excellent and friendly employees

Carrie Dyer

I was so happy when I said no cheese and they offered to put extra meat on it in its place. I have never been asked that and it made my day. Amazing!

Justin Romeo

Sub places in Maine are so bad, most serving their skimpy, low-quality meat subs on hot dog rolls, that a halfway decent place stands out even if it's a chain. Jersey Mike's is just way better than subway or most local Maine places.

R B

Didn't have online order option. Staff seemed stressed from lack of employed staff. Took longer than usual, but enjoyed the food just the same. Thank you

Megan h

Words cannot Express how satisfied I am and was with the experience at jerseys!! Between the food, the taste, the freshness, the accuracy, the manners, and the other customers even, I am FLOORED! 5 stars all day every day!!!

Robert Bolster

Very good food. Friendly service from the staff. Food was ready when promised. Very efficient staff.

Kenney Jones

Oh man this food was so good it was that sandwich it looks like right there that's steak and cheese sub bomb was it just filled me up and it was delicious like a deli sandwich I think it's in the mayonnaise there's something about the mayonnaise that or there's a taste that you cannot get at home that you get at the restaurant I got a grill I have all the utensils but I will need to know the secret in the mayonnaise which sets the sandwich off or whatever little secret they got I want to know but the food is the bomb it's good go there I recommend them highly

Ivory McDonough

Jersey Mike’s took the time out of their day to deliver a box of sandwiches to the Scarborough Maine ClearChoiceMD urgent care! Not only are the sandwiches delicious but it was such a thoughtful thing for them to deliver these for us! Thanks again Jersey Mike’s!

Margie Harfst

Very busy place, food is awsome

Heather Haslam

Fast very fast food is outstanding good

Andrea Tims

Loved Jersey Mike's for years living in NC, moved to Maine and had to go without for over 10 years. They are just as good as I remembered. Thank you Jersey Mike's for coming to Maine.

Caitlin Adams

Very good tasting, quality Italian sub. Will definitely return to try other sandwiches.

Mike Mitchell

The best sandwiches around i love Jersey Mike's check it out

Steve Lawrence

They make the most delicious sandwich I think I have ever had. Very friendly crew.

Judith Dettore

Best sub I've had in a long time. Thank you for taking me back to my Jersey roots and very happy to know I can get another without having to go hours to find a good sub. DELICIOUS!!!

B S

Amazing subs with a wonderful variety. It was very busy but given the quality of the food it was to be expected.

David VanLuke22

Best subs around! Can't stand subway! Just wish there was a Jimmy John's somewhere in the state!

Conmanrules

I just wanted a toasted mayonnaise sandwich. I was Denied my sandwich. The “Tommy” kids treated me badly. I wouldn’t recommend Jersey Mike’s subs to anyone who would like a toasted mayonnaise sandwich.

Mindy G

Fast service even during a crazy busy lunch rush. Excellent food with fresh cut meats.

Jennifer Campbell

I say ham and cheese with mayo, lettuce, and tomato and the guy immediately starts placing onions on my sandwich. Not a good start.

Jacob Frost

The subs are great and the prices are good. They have a great system for picking up your food so there is minimal contact.

Lanette Enman

I love Jersey Mike's and so does my family!! I'm from New York and this makes me feel like I'm home. Thank you Jeresey Mikes for coming yo Maine.

Jennifer Lemay

Food is so good. Best sub around. Easy online ordering and no contact pickup. Food was ready on time.

Brent Capener

Amazing Subs! A popular place as they have a lot of dinner traffic but ample employees working well together make for great food and service!

Terry Brearley

Thrilled that Jersey Mike's has come to Maine. Best subs ever!! Loved them in North Carolina! Welcome to Scarborough!

Lindsey Mcphee

A couple mistakes were made but I completely understand as they were training multiple people, and it was made up for without even having to ask! Highly recommended! Great job guys!

Ang B

Great service, Great food!!

Jacob Hutton

Service was a bit slow. The food was extraordinary!.

Ed P

Very generous portions. Subs and tasty and fresh. Staff is very friendly.

Matt Espeaignnette

Very good sandwiches cut the sandwich meat right there and put it on the sub roll witch is also very good as well

Frank Ryan

Dont go to store unless you order ahead on app. Its pure chaos. Food was good though and priced reasonably

Tina Tharpe

Best sub shop I’ve ever been to! Mounds of meats and veggies on fresh baked bread! Yum!!

Bret Weber

The only one in Maine! Any time I'm near, it's a must go to, regardless of the time. They open at 10 AM so.....

Steve Page

Subs are a bit on the expensive side, but the food is so delicious! They have quite the list of subs, as well, so there is a LOT to choose from.

Kate Savidge

We never actually ordered from this place because there were no prices listed on the menu. Big turn off for us.

Kimberly Gambardella

We love Jersey Mike's subs! And they are so supportive of the community! Highly recommend!

Marc Phillips

That is the best original Italian it was the best I've ever had anywhere at anytime I recommend it to the highest point

Brian Annear

I was very pleased both times I've gone. Once was for a work function, everyone loved it.

Paul Kise

Line to order was a bit long but worth the wait was very fresh and delicious!!!

Radio demon

It was a decent place.I like that a littlethey have a spicy toppings as well

Dysfunctional Issues

Love this place grow up in Jersey. They know how to make the right sandwich

Thomas Doherty

Delicious subs just like you get down in New Jersey. Very authentic.

lshorette

Fantastic flavorful food. Quick service. I wish there was one closer to home.

Andwick W

My only thing which can use some improvement.... make it where the food won't slide out of the bread.

A lev

finally jersey subs in maine! just have your staff spread the mustard on the bread and you’ll be perfect

Rick Howard

Best subs in the area, steak and cheese and the ham and turkey club was fantastic.

Marcia Long

The portions are huge! Prices are good. Friendly staff. HIGHLY recommend

Anne Goodhue

My Italian sandwich was delicious but alittle on the expensive side. Will go back in the future

Andrea

It's so good! Fresh bread, meats, & veggies 🥪 …

Rick Carlisle

First time. Not saying it's the last time, but not moved try again soon.

Kristi Holland

Unbelievable sandwich shop! Always fresh and quick friendly service too!

richard meservey

Was very good, had to experience this shop. Had quite the line but went quick.

Donna Rousselle

Had to ask for another sandwich. Asked for Mayo. He put mayo and added oil and vinegrette!

Dana Duhamel

Excellent got the roast beef I wanted it warmed up I guess I should of asked

Jess Ward

It was good just not my favorite but I do recommend.

Rita Rose

Great sandwiches, friendly service and reasonably priced!

Robert Leonard

The food here is wonderful. Even a small is a huge serving.

Bob Ruby

Above average subs.

Patty Duquette

A little pricey but the sandwich was good.

Bill & Viera Vahey

Great product, great service, will be glad when it comes to Brunswick.

James Denz

Great subs. Fresh bread love them

Kellz Spherez

My granddaughter literally loves this place... me too

Merrill Robbins

The way a Philly and cheese sub should be. The best including the roll

Laurie Reynolds

Their subs are best that we have found in Portland area!

Eric Warren

If you haven't tried one I suggest you do. Subwhat. Blows them away.

Michael Broome

Awesome possum with a little chocolate saucem

Mark Levensalor

Nobody will make you a sandwich that's more fresh than Jersey Mike's.

Beth Olive

Always the same friendly service and perfect sub in a tub

James Amundsen

From N.J. Great to see them in Maine. Great subs.

James Craw

Always get a great sandwich at a great price.

Quent Doughty

Tried the Scarborough store fast friendly service and the # 17 was very good

Daniel Needham

The Best Period.... it just doesn't get any better!

Dianne Duarte

Best sub I've ever had, absolutely delicious.

Becca Wandell

We love Jersey Mikes! Great place!

Nathan Mathews

Jersey Mike’s makes good sandwiches that I eat. Nice.

Sandra P

Great sandwiches

Matt

Great tasting subs, friendly staff.

Patricia Millett

Sub was delicious. Line to wait safely outside.

Kathi Hanscom

Friendly staff. Always fresh ingredients

cc C

Freshest sub ever had. Very good

Katlin P

Love love them could eat the sandwiches every day

karen condon

Most excellent...from the sammich to the customer service! 😊 …

Thomas Briggs

Quick friendly service and good food.

Steve Green

Always love Jersey Mike's it's a great lunch

Alan Brearley

Great subs. Good people. Will be going back !

Stephen Hurst

Great sandwich never been disappointed

Stephanie Harmon

Excellent quality and fast service. Exceptionally clean store.

Erez Amit

Always delicious. Great social distancing practice

Amy Carlson

Great Philly Cheesesteak and friendly employees.

James Ganley

Great sandwiches, fast service.

ed morrison

Great subs, great customer service

Charlie McAloon

Ham& Provolone ...mmmm ill be back for sure

Allen Wright

Sandwiches are very fresh and delicious!

Bill Taylor

Nice subs. Seemed a little unorganized on the tail end.

Stephen Thayer

Just do it Maine, you won't regret it!

jeff simpson

Always liked. Great service, good friendly staff.

Paula Boesch

The service and the food was really good.

Amber Cote

everything is perfect

Raymond Austin

Good suds

Travis G

Great subs, friendly, timely service.

Heath Peaslee

Great subs

lewiston maineiac

The subs are great the juice is where it's at

Virginia Stopper

Always good and always fresh!

Aaron Bentley

Online ordering and great subs!

Christine Watters

Excellent!! Our third trip in a month!!

Richard Ferrara

Good sandwich, quick and quick service

megan godwin

Food was grate fist time eating here

Paul Gagnon

Not up to its usual greatness! 😬 …

Don Lemont

Best sub shop in our area

Christine Collins

They need to bring one closer to augusta

Mary Etta Ross-Targett

Get subs.

cory murray

Best sandwich hands down!!

Michael Mallozzi

Giant sub is really big!

Shar B.

Love their sandwiches

Dan R.

Yummy!

STEVE NASON

First time there, would go back

Krispy Slicein

Busy but really good👌👌👌 …

Evelyn Ireola

THE BEST

Kathleen Marie

Mmmm....

Sophie Cardone

Thank you for correcting the issue.

Peter Poidomani

Good was very fresh

Domekin and Tammy Francis

Small sandwiches for price!

Lahti maayan

Great sandwich.

Steve Pizzo

Good sub,slow service

Gary Rose

Ok

James Wallace

Amazing subs!

Cindi Mundell

The freshest ever!

Randy Cunningham

Great sandwich!!!!

Ray W

👍🔥 …

Scott Sad

Mmm mmm good

David Shane

Great as always

Steve Kurtz

Great food

Anthony Salines

Awesome subs

Nicholas Delaney

Fresh fresh fresh

Sue Blais

Just WOW!!!!

V Leavitt

I love the food ! It's always great!!!

Topher Sakofsky

Contact

Photos