Reviews of Elsie Mae's Canning and Pies. (Bakery) in Milwaukee (Wisconsin).

Elsie Mae's Canning and Pies

262 Reviews

9 Comments

Bakery

Pie shop

1101 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI 53202, United States

Description

Information of Elsie Mae's Canning and Pies, Bakery in Milwaukee (Wisconsin)

Discover the opening times, the location, contact, popular times, photos and real reviews by internet users.

This place has a very good rate, they treat their customers well and you’ll feel welcome, super recommended

Map

Open hours of Elsie Mae's Canning and Pies

Reviews of Elsie Mae's Canning and Pies

Kelsey Margelowsky

I used Elsie Mae's for our wedding pies. They make these small three inch pies called cutie pies and they were literally to die for! Everyone loved them and they were the perfect touch to our big day!

Rick Leonard

Wow. I don't know what to say about Elsie Mae's...it's or out the world and hard to overstate how perfect their pies are. As a huge pie aficionado these might be the best I've ever had. The flavor selection makes you want to order one of each...not one that sounds like you could pass it up. Great space, wonderful staff, worth every penny...you won't soon forget these mini-pies!

Edward Kristan

This is the coolest stop in Kenosha! 4 individual pies for 20 bucks and there are dozens of amazing selections. I would highly recommend taking home a couple of their frozen pot pies also. I really like the nashville hot chicken and their fish pot pie. Thanks Elsie Mae's!

E. H.

We love these pies. We were getting them from the harbor market on weekends when the storefront closed but I also like the little red pie wagon. It’s such a cute concept. The pies are absolutely delicious. My favorite is the mermaid pie which I never would have tried on my own but it’s amazing.

Nathalia Henrickson

After discovering this place about a month ago, my husband and I decided to make the 4 for $20 a weekly tradition. We love the pies so much that we have even given them as gifts... HOWEVER, we've found the customer service to be lacking. The first time I called for info about pie sizes, the young woman I spoke to seemed unhappy to even bothered with my question. The lady that has served us in-store seems very unsure of herself and like she can't wait for you to leave. Each of the 4+ times we've gone, we've been disappointed not to be greeted with a smile or welcome. Also, the shop looks closed from the outside (even with the light display). I've had people I've sent there express this, as well. Elsie Mae's has great pies, and the homey kitchen feeling is wonderful. But it's lacking in warmth, as no one seems to be concerned with customer care and interaction.

Sarah Tungate

These are the best pies in town! We always order these for holidays. They always have tons of different pies and are always changing up the varieties. They always hold different events for kids. We were here for a make your own mini pies for the kids. The staff is super friendly and helpful. I love that they sell at the local farmers markets also.

Kari Jean

First time I have been in this place was during restaurant week and they had a special for two people, 2 pot pies, 2 mini pies and 2 sodas for $20. I just tried the corned beef hash pot pie, which I took home to bake. You can eat there or take home. Well it smelled so delicious and looked so yummy coming out of the oven that i forgot to take a pic!! Here is my empty tin😊 so many baked pies to choose from. Bring Grandma a pie from here, guaranteed she will love it!!

jodie cima

Love this locally owned business! Pies and jams are delicious. Can't wait to try other things!

Steven Soltis

Elsie Mae's is a must stop for me anytime i come to Kenosha. The pies are second to none and the service is of similar quality. Depending on the time of the year will depend of flavors available.

Contact

Photos