Reviews of Mary's Mountain Cookies. (Bakery) in Cheyenne (Wyoming).

Mary's Mountain Cookies

216 Reviews

146 Comments

Bakery

Dessert shop

315 W Lincolnway, Cheyenne, WY 82001, United States

Description

Information of Mary's Mountain Cookies, Bakery in Cheyenne (Wyoming)

Discover the opening times, the location, contact, popular times, photos and real reviews by internet users.

This place has a very good rate, they treat their customers well and you’ll feel welcome, super recommended

Map

Open hours of Mary's Mountain Cookies

Popular times

Sunday

Monday

Tuesday

Wednesday

Thursday

Friday

Saturday

Reviews of Mary's Mountain Cookies

Jonathan Flores

After having Mary's Mountain Cookies in Fort Collins a few years ago we were VERY excited to see a location in Cheyenne while in town. We purchased 8 cookies and plan on having them gone in the next 2 days. Soft and fresh these cookies are everything we would want. Yes they are a little pricier than your typical "shopping mall cookies" but you are getting quality which I have no problem paying a little more for!

Taylor Landon

The best cookie shop in town!! Amazing customer service, and a great variety in cookies. My favorite is called the “wookie” (shown in the pictures) which is two chocolate chip cookies sandwiching edible chocolate chip cookie dough that is dipped in chocolate.

Southern Bell

This is a new favorite of mine! The store is very clean and the staff have been nice every time I have come in. I recently got the avalanche cookie (the Halloween one) and it was so good. The cookie itself was so he perfect texture in my opinion. It was soft but not too soft that it falls apart as you eat it. I am happy to drive a little further, and go downtown Cheyenne to get my sugar fix rather than the new cookie place in the mall that is mediocre. Thanks Mary Mountain cookies for all of your tasty options!

Mark Anthony Escalera Sr

Very knowledgeable staff. There are some ingredients we cannot have and they knew what was in the ones of interest. Purchased 3 different items today and I think we will be back again. The cookies are soft and fresh. The ice cream was just the right amount of sweetness and creaminess. If you are anywhere in the downtown Cheyenne area, they are easily accessible. My only complaint is a couple of little benches or cafe-type table seating would be nice. However, the Cheyenne Depot Plaza is just about a block away.

Felicia Millen

Ohhhh yeah! I'm from San Diego, CA & I wish you'd open one there too... It'd be a hit! Very tasty flavors of cookies and CHEWY just like I like 'em 😁🍪💯😋 If you're in Cheyenne you've gotta stop by... Ice cream too!! I even shipped some home for later ☕☀️🌴 …

Laura Brewer Hartley

Holy cow the cookies here are GIGANTIC and delicious! We had salted caramel, smores and the one with oreos in it. So good!

Janet Raeburn

Gluten Free!!!! Had the snickerdoole and the orange doodle gluten free cookies. SO. VERY. GOOD. Had to go back the next day and get more. Soft and chewy. Tastes great! (Not a cheap cookie but very good).

Diana Panyard

Beautiful people with GREAT cookies. Not to mention they also make milkshakes! Yum! Stop here for afternoon sugar fix!

Matthew James

The staff is ALWAYS super friendly. They have a few great cookie flavors. My favorite was the buckaroo. As nice and creative as they are everytime I go the cookies are kind of stale. Maybe that's just they're style or maybe I just catch them too late in the evening but...IDK. Also, their online ordering system needs work. My coworker would put our order in via their website and we'd still get their and have to tell them what we ordered and paid for.

Katherine Kelley

Fun, unique choices. We picked an assortment and they were all amazing. Friendly staff and reasonable prices. Wish we lived closer so we could stop by more often!

Jesska86

Dang! Some of the best cookies I've ever had and the icecream sandwiches are awesome too!

Mark Heisel

Delicious cookies! So many to choose from. Worth the stop!

Sarah Stegner

So cute and great variety! Cookies are big and ice cream delicious. A bit pricey.

Morgan Crozier

Amazing place to stop by for your cookie needs. Most memorable ones I've ever come across, so I guess that speaks for itself. Very friendly owners and a staff that clearly care about the quality.

Jerry Hargraves

Great cookies super friendly staff. Grab one for yourself or they have a bunch for everyone

Katie T

Before yesterday, our experience was good here. I ordered two dozen cookies to pick up later this week. I understand they got busy, but when I went to pay, I asked about their special the gentleman told me about, and the lady that rang me up told me it is not available. Regardless, I need the cookies, but I felt like she rushed me because they got busy after we walked in.

Julie Schulz

We had some errands to run this morning and I figured it was a beautiful day for ice cream and a cookies. All the ladies greeted us when we entered, they gave us space to pick our favorites out. Prices are reasonable and seriously the cookies are the best! I love the different varieties and love that they have ice cream options too!

Cody S

Hands downs one of the best places in town to grab a sweet, and they have keto friendly options.

Dale Buckley

The have excellent cookies. They have gluten free cookies that are yummy too. The cookies are large and so good you need to buy more than one. . You'll regret it if you don't. The staff is wonderful, as good as the cookies.

Steven Fiscus

Love these cookies!!! Everyone must try

Scottie P OMB

best cookie spot in cheyenne no completing at all what is a crumbl cookie? haa keep working guys

linda mays

Easy parking and the scent of fresh baked cookies draws you in. It's very clean and organized. They have gluten free cookies as well as a great selection of flavors. A little pricey but worth every penny.

Jeri Cranmore

I WON!! Thank you HOMETOWN MAGAZINE and MARY'S MOUNTAIN COOKIES!!! They were so generous and I got to pick 1 dozen cookies of my choice! If you haven't already tried them, you're missing out!! They are awesomely SCRUMPTIOUS 🍪 THANK YOU, THANK YOU ❣️🍪😃 …

Chelsea Schnyer

Delicious cookies and amazing staff! They have all sorts of flavors, but the snickerdoodles are the best. You can purchase frozen dough or large cookies to feed a group too. There's a military discount and loyalty program you can join.

Kimberly Jensen

Love the GF cookies!! Delicious and super soft cookies. You will want them ALL! Excellent service too. Great addition to downtown Cheyenne.

Amanda Terrell

Walked in and the girls at the prep table started arguing about who had to go help me. If I could leave negative stars for a review I would. Edit: after talking with the store owner she went above and beyond to apologize and try to make things right. She took the time to make sure my opinion of her store wasn't forever ruined by the negligence of the employees working that night. The owner is great, and I think if she could be there at the store all day every day it would always be a great customer experience. Unfortunately business owners in Cheyenne have to rely on employees, sadly, most of whom just don't care. Aside from the lack of hard working motivated employees in this town.... This shop has amazing cookies. Definitely will be going back.

Elizabeth Willing

If you want something sweet - visit this place! The prices are good and the cookies are even better! Get the large and split it (or enjoy it yourself) or get one of the mini cookies, My kids love the M&M cookies but I love the Salted Caramel. We don't have Mary's Mountain in Oregon so when we are in the area we don't miss it!

Carissa Rene

My son's cookie turned out amazing!

Errol Brown

Today was my first time there. These are cookies that would satisfy any Cookie Monster. I got the M&M cookie and it was delicious! The staff were friendly and upbeat. Always nice to see smiling faces. Next time, I'm either going to get the Snickers or the s'more cookie. Yum!

Daniel Laing

Pretty tasty cookie, kinda pricey but it was very big. There is a large variety to choose from, and they are friendly inside. Plus the location is great to grab one and munch on it while you walk around the downtown. Do stop in to see for yourself.

Kristine Wright

Love the happy people that work in this fabulous cookie shop. They have amazing cookies of all different varieties of flavors. Oh and gluten free cookies, they do not lack in taste.

Taylor Miller

They have milkshakes! What a lovely discovery with a friend. People stopped to ask her where she got such a delicious looking refreshment more than once. I've only ever had their cookies (amazing) but I'll have to come back on a hot day with a sweet tooth.

John Langdon

Just had our first experience at Mary’s here in Cheyenne and let me tell you what...SOOOO AWESOME! The cookies were phenomenal and the service was outstanding the lady there struck up a pleasant conversation while we picked out our cookies and treated my family so nice. We’ll be going back again very soon!

Brian Blair

Fabulous cookies, wonderful friendly staff, great flavors and selections. What's very nice, they offer a good variety of Gluten free substitutes. All an all, one great cookie shop.

Eleanor Grinnell

Great ice cream flavors, love the lemon cookie, a bit too expensive. We must limit our visits.

Connor Brown

Some of the best cookies we have ever had. And the employees were so incredibly sweet and helpful. Would make the drive back from Colorado just for this place.

Devin Hurley

The Salted Carmel are to die for! I just wish you guys had your whole menu (ice cream cookies) all day. I got there pretty early and you were still sold out. Everything else was great though. Great service and the bench out front was nice to enjoy my cookies on.

Jenn Plank

I mailed some cookies to my family in PA and they arrive so fresh and each cookie was labeled. We love Mary’s mountain cookies. The grinch cookie was one of they have ever tasted!

J. E. Bennett

Good cookies. High price. Convenient location and a lot of variety.

Grace Coombs

I’m from SLC, Utah, where there’s lots of great food and experience options. I’ve lived in Cheyenne for three years and there’s nothing really like it here, except for Mary’s Cookies. Everyone raves about Eileen’s cookies and I think they’re disgusting and I don’t understand!!! EVERYONE!!! needs to try Mary’s cookies. I’ve tried almost every cookie and each one is so delicious. Support local businesses like this because they deserve it!!!

Kathie Levy

Cookies are SO DELICIOUS! Orange doodle and salted caramel are my faves. Reasonable prices. Super friendly.

Diana Porter

Everyone is friendly and the cookies are awesome! My favorite is the Chai cookie! I can't wait for it to come back.

jose gonzales

Love this place! We went the very first day they opened, and they were about to close. They stayed a few minutes extra and we received wonderful customer service, including a free cookie! It's nice to be able to show support to a wonderful local business, especially in our downtown area.

Christina Bosch

very clean, welcome place. many options. cookies weren't too sweet just rithr. Unfortunately non vegan options are not available at the time. hope soon though. that would make it our favorite cookie spot for sure.

K M

Hands down, these are the best cookies I’ve ever had! Big, soft and chewy with a variety of flavors for everyone!

Leigh Williams

You need to do this. You should never go through this area and not get a cookie!! 4/20

Emma Stone

Love the Brady family and everything they're doing for downtown and Cheyenne by adding this fabulous cookie shop to our town! Great food, great employees!

Christine S

Best chocolate shake I’ve had since I left home!! Very friendly and helpful staff I’m so glad I stopped in there! Can’t wait to eat their cookies!

Jayla Dennis

Very soft cookies! Peanutbutter cookies wasn't as flavorful, but the rest were amazing. Love the cookie sandwich with the icing in the middle. The icing is a perfect balance of sweetness.

Unbound llama 258

A lovely little cookie / ice cream shop, with great staff and amazing cookies!

Holly Giampaolo

Huge cookies, very friendly and military discount! Only wish they had coffee too.

Beth Genenbacher

OMG. Such good stuff. I was planning to go in anyway, but they had the door open and the wonderful smell invited me in. Delicious cookies, brownies, etc. Loved everything.

Martha Cannon

You smell that wonderful smell of those amazing cookies a block away!! I think we bought one of each!! If you haven't been there.. you need to go ❣

Elizabeth Chenard

Friendly staff as well as wonderful cookies! Not only are there tons to choose from, but they have gluten free and keto options.

Tonya Harding

Delicious. So many varieties. Cookie dough is amazing! Cookies stay soft for so long!

Daffney Sandoval

Cookies, ice cream sandwiches, cookie dough, they even have keto cookies! Get yourself a punch card because you will be back for more. My new favorite downtown shop.

Britnee Hursin

Best cookies in town served by an awesome staff and great prices. I will be back whenever I am in town and recommend to all my friends to stop by!

Jason Bogstie

Mary's Mountain Cookies are the best around! The staff is awesome and the cookies are incredible. They have ice cream cookies e sandwiches and even keto!

Joe Panyard

Awesome service Great Cookies. Thanks

Stephanie Wollard

Amazing variety and quality of cookies. You won't be disappointed by this stop in Downtown Cheyenne.

Kevin Coughlin

Excellent place to satisfy your cookie craving! Great selection and even ice cream!

Cat D

What a treasure! These cookies are fabulous and the ice cream is delicious. The staff was friendly, hard working, and helpful.

James Sykes

All of my family and clients love their cookies. Always fresh and delicious!!

Daniel Jimenez

The cookies best in the world !!

Jesus Fresquez

Yummy 😋 yummy cookies. Great that we have a place in downtown Cheyenne Wyoming that's serves these great treats. The day olds are the bomb!!! …

P S

Best cookies ever!!!! Lots of variety and the people are great!

Jeremy Anderson

Giant cookies that are incredibly soft and very tasty. Plus the people working behind the counters and very friendly and patient.

Jan Erickson

Amazing cookies! Great selection. Friendly staff. And they're open after 5pm.

Justin Barnes

The cookies are amazing oh my will definitely be going back

Matt Closson

Great quality food and taste . But the service was just super Awkward and quite

Megan Luttrell

My family and I got 8 kinds of cookies. We shared them all and they were all delicious!

justin collins

So glad to see an epic cookie shop in Cheyenne. So far everything I have gotten has been amazing!

Jessica Hickd

Today was my first time there and I'll definitely be going back. I love the prices and the staff was so nice and helpful 😊. Great place to have a family outing and it date 😊. …

Kari Blanton

They have the best cookies and they don't get overly hard even after being left open to the elements or not eaten for a couple of days.

Matt S.

The staff are very friendly, and the cookies and ice cream are delectable. Drop on in for a single cookie or take home an entire party platter.

Fred Sisneros

Some of best cookies around. Large assortment to choose from. People are very helpful and nice.

Rashell Read

Got a cookie here last minute and they were able to get it done and personalize it for me! It was delicious.

Jamie Lee

Their cookies are the best I have tasted also their buttercream is divine.

Kelley Oneill

They have very yummy cookies I have had several...the brownies are to die for....cant wait to try the salted caramel cookie

Daisy Mae

I dont like leaving reviews* Doordashed their cookies the other day. Delicious!

Robert Rek

I visited November 23, you just asking about? I could have enjoyed a number, if not many of. Yet, all costs money 💰 …

Kaylee Hunt

Delicious cookies and friendly staff! Highly recommend!

Monica Y

Delicious cookies and other treats but a little more expensive than I'd like to pay!

Dan Young

Awesome treats and an even more awesome staff!! Absolutely worth it!

Ryan Brown

Their cookies are the closest things to legal crack. The snickerdoodle with icing filling was fantastic.

Gwendolyn Flake

Super delicious cookies, especially the Avalanches!! I take home at least three boxes when I visit Cheyenne😋 …

Amanda Roberts

Delish baked goods. Drop in the store to shop or they are also on GrubHub for delivery as well.

Donovan Fowler

These guys are awesome, super friendly and super clean. Also check out the pay it forward wall!

John Turner

Polite staff, and new choices all the time. Anyways amazing cookies and brownies!

Lesli Haston

Best white chocolate macadamia cookies in town. Great service.

Jason “Mac” MacGregor

Great owner, customer service, and good cookies as usual!

Stacee Sanchez

Such beautiful cookies that taste as good as they look! 💜 …

Sandy Armstrong

So happy to have these awesome cookies here!!! And the frosted brownies, yum!!

Vaclaurus

They home make their cookies, and they are the best, so good!

Lowell Toon

Always friendly and great cookies

Martha Thein

Wonderful customer service!! So patient while we debated our choices from all of the delicious choices!

M J89

Never disappoints!

Charles Cunningham

The management of this store made a very generous donation to the American legion. Thank you.

Kelly Randall

Their cookies are addicting. Lots of options and flavors.

kevschei

Friendly people, great tasting treats. They really embrace the community.

Jared Little

Haven't had a cookie I disliked here yet and I've had a lot of them.

Rod Dettling

Wanted to everything in the store lol is delicious 😋 …

Matt Halbmaier

Awesome cookies, awesome ladies

April Squires

So many to choose from! Fresh & yummy! I will return soon!

Casey L Palma

Friendly service & atmosphere to get wonderful treats!

Chris Elsey

Awesome gigantic cookies have ice cream too

James Blackman

Always amazing! Great staff!

Christopher Fail

Cookies were phenomenal

Elijah Marshall

It's cookies. A good replacement for Eileen's cookies.

Carol Jansen

How could you not love these cookies!!?

Cheri

Best cookies I ever had!

MamboPie Boone

Great service and Huckleberry shake

Lear Weaver

Great cookies!

Bill Statler

The cookies at this place or absolutely amazing.

Nicole Wellemeyer

Wonderful place and tasty treats

Parker Bennett

Key lime pie cookie was bomb

Bernadette Parrish

Delicious cookies, ice cream cone, and ice cream sandwiches

Bryan Wright

Great customer service.

Peter

The best cookies in town

Salina Camacho

I love their cookies

Mario Villalpando

Always so delicious!

Liz Wilcox

Cookies are good, very expensive

Max Duran

Outstanding cookies!

Kody Hampton

Delish!!

Christine Johnston

Yum!

Gillian Prose

10/10

Tonya

Best cookies ever ..

Hannah Zurita

Amazing place!

Richard Fawcett

Fantastic cookies...

Beverly Coon

Delicious treats

Lindasu Mcdonald

Best cookies in cheyenne

Scott Flamholtz

Not very good.

Rylokat

Cookies good.

Mrs PC

Delicious

nichole speigel

💖💖 …

Ryan Neumann

Ridiculous good!

Jessica McCleery

Phenomenal cookies!

Patrick Morris

Good cookies

Heather Smith

Wow excellent

Joel Hansen

tasty expensive cookies

Becky Cabral

Yummy cookies

Melissa Page

Yummy yummy comes

Mike Mauren

Incrdible cookies

Leailanie Ochoa

Great cookies with gluten-free and keto options!!!! Fabulous staff!!!

User

Best cookies in town !

Victor Hugo Segundo Ortega

The place is quite nice and their products are delicious, they have a promotion: when you buy 6 cookies you get 2 more totally free, only the last time I went they didn't give me those 2 cookies 🥺

Contact

Photos